Edison's house and his invention factory. It is quite likely that the world's greatest inventor was eating a Supreme Bakery glazed donut when he invented the light bulb. Since 1969, Supreme Bakery has been owned and operated by the Stolz family. It has been our goal to serve our customers the freshest and finest products possible.
We have an experienced and dedicated staff who are eager to provide outstanding service. It is also our goal to be a contributing member of our community and take part in many charitable activities that benefit local organizations. Our favorite project is offering free cupcakes for grade school students who achieve A's in major academic subjects.
We have an experienced and dedicated staff who are eager to provide outstanding service. It is also our goal to be a contributing member of our community and take part in many charitable activities that benefit local organizations. Our favorite project is offering free cupcakes for grade school students who achieve A's in major academic subjects.
Services
Have a specific idea in mind? Have a cake you want us to recreate? Then this is the right place for you. Our custom cakes can range from a variety of designs. From pull apart to tier cakes, buttercream to fondant. We can design any cake to your liking, the only limit is your imagination! Our custom cake prices may vary due to design and size.
We have a great selection of styles in our Wedding Cake Portfolio. You may come in to speak to our Wedding Cake Specialist and bring in ideas and styles that you are interested in. Prices may vary based upon size and design. Typically, wedding cakes are offered at $6.00 per serving. There is an extra charge for Fondant and Whipped Cream style cakes starting at $7.00 per serving.
We offer a wholesale menu to caterers, hospitals, school cafeterias, country clubs, temples, and all re-sellers of our products. We offer free delivery daily with a minimum order. Call or e-mail us for our Wholesale List. You can contact Richard Stolz, the owner, for special orders at [email protected].
Reviews (20)
Jamie S.
Jan 07, 2022
Report
Ordered through a food delivery service since we were craving sweets. They were out of something I wanted and an employee there called me to see what I wanted which I thought was really nice. And what they gave me as a substitute was delicious! Some type of apple danish which was so good. We also got cupcakes and cookies which were so good. definitely would try other items from here!
Alejandro M.
Dec 27, 2021
Report
I was looking up bakery's in my area and I'm glad I came across this one. This was like a month ago but the lady that was taking my order was going back and forth between money and the bread when I told her that she was grabbing money then my bread she responded with then don't buy it. Ridiculous especially with COVID happening.
Henry C.
Aug 23, 2021
Report
Robin F.
Aug 22, 2021
Report
Keith N.
Aug 22, 2021
Report
They make rugelach that come close to those we'd get at Garden Bake Shop in Floral Park NY-40 yrs ago. I'm on the verge of putting in a standing order for every few weeks.
Quality bakery. Not the easiest thing to find in the day of supermarkets. Good recipes-1/3 of the tripod. Ingredients 1/3 & the actual measuring, mixing & baking the final 1/3 + a little good sweat.
Rabbinical approval can only be a plus.
Quality bakery. Not the easiest thing to find in the day of supermarkets. Good recipes-1/3 of the tripod. Ingredients 1/3 & the actual measuring, mixing & baking the final 1/3 + a little good sweat.
Rabbinical approval can only be a plus.
Mark G.
Jul 28, 2021
Report
Lucky us we stopped in here on our travel across country. You lucky locals get to have this food whenever. We ordered by looks as we do not have this in Las Vegas. I had to ask if the total price was correct, $8 for all that. One of these would be $8 at home. The apple crumble and lemon danish were awesome. The black and white was our first and we kick ourselves for not getting more.
LaTisha P.
May 17, 2021
Report
I've been eating from Supremes since I was a child. I love their cakes, cupcakes and cookies. It was rare that I had an unpleasant experience there however, the past two times that I've come, the customer service has been horrible. There's an older Caucasian woman who I believe is the manager who is not only rude to customers but also to her coworkers. I don't know if she is overwhelmed but that is definitely not who they should have assisting customers.
Anna M.
May 09, 2021
Report
I'm from New York and was looking for a bakery to buy my husband's birthday. My husband loves carrot cake. So I decided to go to this bakery and wow I was not disappointed. The carrot cake was so flavorful and moist, I also had the blue velvet and red velvet cupcake to try again both were so tasty . Please visit this bakery I'm sure you won't be disappointed
Nalini C.
Mar 12, 2021
Report
Karen D.
Feb 22, 2021
Report
A friend's birthday was approaching and I was tasked with getting the cake. I ordered online and it was super easy. The cake was scrumptious - def the best bakery cake I've had in 15 years (and I'm in the food biz). Equally delish are their chocolate-frosted donuts, my weakness. I tried a choco ruggelach but honestly I've had better. I also ordered - of all things - a cinnamon raisin bagel & it was terrific. I'll be back for sure
Jerry D.
Oct 24, 2020
Report
Luci C.
Jun 28, 2020
Report
Janel S.
Jun 07, 2020
Report
I always get my cakes from here and they TASTE GREAT!!! But the execution is subpar. The decorating of the cake was sloppy!! Whoever is there icing and decorating the cakes have to do better. My cake for my daughter looks as if the person decorating it didn't care. I only go for the taste of the cake, that's it. Everything else has fallen off the grid. So sad. The owner needs to fix this now or you will be out of business.
Elle B.
Jun 05, 2020
Report
I came here for ONE thing but left with about 10 lol!
Who can resist fresh pastries?
I specifically came for my BIRTHDAY CAKE, a Strawberry shortcake that I fell in love with way back in March 2019 when I had dinner with my family.
This cake is absolutely delicious and I am so happy that I chose this bakery to do the honors of being THE cake for a special day!
Thank you Supreme Bakery for having such delicious baked goods
Xx
Who can resist fresh pastries?
I specifically came for my BIRTHDAY CAKE, a Strawberry shortcake that I fell in love with way back in March 2019 when I had dinner with my family.
This cake is absolutely delicious and I am so happy that I chose this bakery to do the honors of being THE cake for a special day!
Thank you Supreme Bakery for having such delicious baked goods
Xx
Andrew M.
Mar 29, 2020
Report
This review was based on my DoorDash order. I was craving sweets, and since we are quarantined, I ordered some cupcakes to be delivered to my house. Unfortunately, the order came incorrectly and the cupcakes were dry and tasteless. I see similar complaints of the carrot cake from other users; very light brown cake with hardly any carrot, nuts, or raisins. I wouldn't recommend ordering from Supreme Bakery.
Elizabeth P.
Dec 08, 2019
Report
I ordered a custom birthday cake for my husband. The order was for a traditional carrot cake (which usually has more of a brown color) with cream cheese, icing. However, the cake that I received was a yellow lemon flavored pound cake with carrot flakes in it, nothing like a traditional carrot cake. Even the icing had a very strong lemon flavor.
After seeing a similar review on here regarding their carrot cakes, I was nervous so I called the bakery the day before my order was ready just to confirm that I would receive a traditional carrot cake and was told yes.
The cake was tasty, however, my
After seeing a similar review on here regarding their carrot cakes, I was nervous so I called the bakery the day before my order was ready just to confirm that I would receive a traditional carrot cake and was told yes.
The cake was tasty, however, my
Marcus S.
Nov 28, 2019
Report
Came here to get a Cheesecake with my friend as he wanted to bring one for his family Thanksgiving gathering. I've heard so much about this bakery, but have never actually come. Well the selection is plentiful her so any kind baked dessert you're looking for, you can probably find it here. I was impressed when I inquired on my friends behalf about Cheesecake the ones on display looked nice, but then the attendant went into the back and brought out a pretty strawberry cheesecake that kinda blew the regular cheesecake away. We went with that one.
That said, the staff, all of them were
That said, the staff, all of them were
Pamela B.
Aug 03, 2019
Report
Just picked up this cake from Supreme Bakery. It was $21. for an 8" cake. It's pretty small for $21 but I don't mind bc it's my Moms favorite. What I DO mind is the bakery charging $1 to write on the cake. Not only do they not tell you they charge to write on the cake now but it's not even what I asked them to write! Plus the "Happy Birthday Nana" isn't even readable. That is ridiculous.
Another girl came in after me & she was upset bc she ordered a cake and it wasn't what she ordered either. They were asking her who she ordered the cake from
Another girl came in after me & she was upset bc she ordered a cake and it wasn't what she ordered either. They were asking her who she ordered the cake from
Grace R.
Aug 02, 2019
Report
We went late, about an hour before closing on a weekday so it was empty. There were a ton of options (cookies, pastries, cakes, etc) and everything looked beautiful! We tried the tiramisu which was really good and the napoleon which was a bit too thick (cream) and sweet for my personal taste.
I wouldn't say this is a great place to study during busier hours since i recall there were only a couple tables. But I would say this is a great place to grab a box of pastries to bring to a gathering/meeting!
I wouldn't say this is a great place to study during busier hours since i recall there were only a couple tables. But I would say this is a great place to grab a box of pastries to bring to a gathering/meeting!
Cinthia K.
May 21, 2019
Report
Came here a few weekends ago with 2 of my friends to pick up some baked goods to bring to our respective families for Easter. They have a pretty wide variety of baked goods to choose from, all very reasonably priced (their smaller cupcakes were priced at $1.85 each, and they were a pretty decent size). They do custom orders as well, but I suppose you'd expect that out of most bakeries.
Bonus: if you check in on your Yelp app when you come here, you get a free small coffee with your purchase!
Bonus: if you check in on your Yelp app when you come here, you get a free small coffee with your purchase!
