Tomato Pie Cafe
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Tomato Pie Cafe
Hello, we are the Fisher Family. Together we have created an experience that showcases our heritage; artistic beauty, culinary creations, rich coffee, bakery delicacies, laughter and conversations that warm the soul. Tomato Pie Cafe boasts eclectic flair signature to the places we have been and the people we have met.

We are delighted to share a little piece of our journey with you. We commit to you that our Fisher Hospitality is infused in every detail of your visit. Come, allow us to enlighten your senses with a gourmet experience you will remember for a lifetime. As an Urban Style eatery you will experience a simple but artful menu executed to perfection, both visually and tastefully.
Services
Welcome to 2021, we are looking forward to the opportunity to serve our friends, family, and community with distinctive food sensations and noteworthy service. Owner, Karen Fisher, enjoys taking time to perfect each savory bite. Seeking to preserve the old and yet introduce the new, her heartbeat and passion is the flavor of each recipe created.
Reviews (9)
Rachel Leigh
Rachel Leigh
Feb 02, 2022
Report
Delicious meal, great service. Quaint, quiet atmosphere, with diverse menu. The menu labeled gluten free and vegan options.
I got the veggie burger it was tasty with a pretzel bun. Also, got oatmilk cappuccino it was delicious. There are enough options for a vegetarian or vegan to choose a meal.
NOTE: Tomato Pie has cheese/dairy in it for those that cannot have dairy.
Brenda Mason
Brenda Mason
Dec 25, 2021
Report
As always, the food was delicious! They ran out of their side salad to go with the tomato pie, but added chips as a replacement. They seated us quickly and the staff was very helpful and pleasant.
Steven DeLaurentis
Steven DeLaurentis
Nov 11, 2021
Report
What a perfect place to eat in a perfect little town. You feel like you have traveled into the past. The food and service was very good. The namesake tomato pie is a must have.
Cindy Eng
Cindy Eng
Oct 24, 2021
Report
Lovely and quaint cafe with really great seasonal items like an autumn salad and maple and cardamom latte. Their coffee is strong and their food is hearty while their staff was welcoming and friendly. Totally recommend!
Courage DeLeon
Courage DeLeon
Oct 12, 2021
Report
The servers are mostly always fairly Kurt, efficient, but could be friendlier. The owner is super friendly.
Kyle Irwin
Kyle Irwin
Sep 18, 2021
Report
Great staff, great food, great coffee, and a wonderful patio on a crisp Fall Sunday morning. Definitely recommend the Pumpkin Pancakes!
Matthew Martin
Matthew Martin
Aug 22, 2021
Report
Like always the food was fresh, hot and very tasty. I got the signature tomato pie with butternut squash and my son got the farm house turkey burger. My daughter had the blueberry pancakes with the lemon cream topping. The coffee was awesome and topped off regularly. The waitress was fantastic and on top of her game. We loved the experience very much!
Melody Loomis
Melody Loomis
Jul 21, 2021
Report
This place was spot on for service, food quality, portion sizing and environment! It is so quaint with shaded outdoor seating. Kids meals are so inexpensive so even with a large party of children the menu has something affordable for all. My biggest concern was dietary restrictions- I am gluten and dairy free but they made all the accommodations down to using macadamia nut milk in my latte and baked Oatmeal. My one suggestion is for them to set aside their dry gluten free pancake mix and offer to made to order GF & Dairy Free pancakes or French toast. Other than that everything was amazing!!!
Maurielle C.
Maurielle C.
Jun 10, 2021
Report
This restaurant is pretty good, but it’s not wonderful by any means. The employees are somewhat friendly but they are pleasant to be around & very attentive. The food just isn’t amazing but it’s okay. The wait time is normal, not too long. The portion size is a bit small. It is a bit crowded, you are guaranteed to hear every conversation at surrounding tables. It is an okay place to eat but it’s not a must.