Name: By The Bay Motel
Address: 4123 Main St, Fish Creek, WI, 54212, US
Telephone: (920) 868-3456
Rating: 3.86

By-the-Bay Motel is open for the season and ready for guests! We are at the forefront of Fish Creek's beloved downtown motels and we strive to give our guests a great Door County experience in their lodgings, whether they're in Fish Creek, Juddville, Egg Harbor, Jacksonport, or Baileys Harbor, WI. We are taking extra precautions and following CDC guidelines to ensure you with a clean and comfortable stay.

Our motel rooms offer great views of the harbor from many of our rooms, as well as the spacious patio. Walk to the many shops and restaurants downtown or take in a beautiful sunset at Sunset Park. Whether you're coming to explore the beauty of Peninsula State Park, in town for a family vacation or looking for a quiet weekend getaway, guests have access to everything the Door County community has to offer.

Website Update

Services

Hotel Rooms & Prices Report

At By The Bay Motel, we're committed to providing visitors to Fish Creek, Juddville, Egg Harbor, Jacksonport, and Baileys Harbor, WI and the surrounding areas with comfortable, clean motel rooms and modern amenities in a relaxing and convenient location. Since 2001, we've been providing an excellent motel experience to our guests, who enjoy our personalized approach and affordable rates.

Reviews (7)

Write a Review

Michelle Burnett

Oct 28, 2021

Report

A great location. A view to the bay and walking distance to shopping and restaurants. Owners are very friendly. Rooms are a little dated, and water pressure not the best. But the location and price make it worth it. We will stay again.

Messer Cutting

Oct 15, 2021

Report

See like Senor DeGrazia said review, musty, very outdated, tiny tv, terrible coffee. Seriously the owners need to put a crowbar in their wallets to update their small rooms. THE SMELL WAS the WORST! Never in a million years would I stay there again.

Melinda Thompson

Aug 23, 2021

Report

Close to shops and restaurant's. Great views of lake. Inside decor outdated but everything worked great.

Bobbie Korzeniecki

Aug 23, 2021

Report

Amazing experience!! The rooms are exactly what you would expect by the the appearance of the property. The rooms are quaint and very cozy and very well maintained.The owners are helpful and extremely friendly. I already made my return reservations for next year.

Senor DeGrazia

Jul 16, 2021

Report

The room was very musty, really unpleasant to walk into, even airing the place out was ineffective. Also, the wallpaper was really outdated, along with the sheets. It had “motel art,” which isn’t a huge deal just looked weird. Tiny TV with poor quality, literally better to watch something on your phone. Other than that, relatively clean, but the smell made it seem dirty as anything. Decent cheap place, definitely not a great spot.

Sue Fischer

Jul 13, 2020

Report

Just traveling up for one day and everything was booked. Called and Mary had a few rooms available. Great location with view of the bay.

Debbie B.

May 13, 2020

Report

Great location very walkable to anything in Fish Creek. Older motel that is clean and well kept. Owners are very nice. Room is spacious and clean, tad outdated. Beautiful sunset across the street by the beach. The 2 annoyances were the sheets on the bed were scratchy and weren't big enough. Every time my husband moved, he moves a lot in his sleep, the sheet came off. Shower head needs to be replaced. We will definitely stay again when in the area. Easy drive to anywhere in Door County.