The Stuffed Mushroom
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
The Stuffed Mushroom has been creating memories since 1981 and continues to be one of Tampa Bay's most sought after caterers. Our boutique in downtown Safety Harbor showcases a fabulous collection of accessories for living and entertaining.

The Stuffed Mushroom offers full catering services, from planning assistance and gourmet menu selection to professional presentation and service for corporate events, luncheons and dinners, weddings, parties, and any other occasion you can name!If you prefer, many items are available for pick-up and delivery, including the hors d'oeuvre menu, special box lunches, and some entrees, oven ready.
Services
During these unprecedented times, we will be offering limited carry out meals. Delicious, single-serving meals, freshly frozen. Practice safe social distancing and enjoy a selection of meals from The Stuffed Mushroom in your own home. Consuming raw meats, poultry, seafood, or shellfish may increase your risk of food-borne illness.
Bite-sized pieces of chicken breast marinated in a soy ginger sauce and orange marmalade, wrapped in bacon. Slices of the most tender beef on baguette with capered mayonnaise, topped with bearnaise. Beautifully arranged variety of salami, pepperoni, and cheese with marinated artichoke hearts, olives, cherry peppers, and pickled okra.
Reviews (6)
Kaiya Johnson
Kaiya Johnson
May 14, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Value
Food was amazing. Service was amazing. Especially Mary Jane. She kept a great conversation, catered and served amazingly, and her heart seems so pure. I appreciate everything she did for my partners family. She is truly a delight to be around.
K. H. Bartoszek
K. H. Bartoszek
May 04, 2021
Report
Ordered the Easter dinner and it was delicious and perfect. So easy, too!
Alyssa Miller
Alyssa Miller
Jan 03, 2021
Report
I don't even know where to start! Betsy and the whole Stuffed Mushroom team are so beyond amazing! When I tell you that they go up and beyond they truly do! We had an unfortunate situation happen with our wedding coordinator and was left to do a lot on our own. But Betsy helped in any and every way possible. She truly helped make my wedding day run so smoothly. Our wedding guests/family could not stop saying how good the food is, and still talks about it when we talk about our wedding. I cannot recommend Betsy and the Stuffed Mushroom enough!
Beth B.
Beth B.
Sep 06, 2020
Report
I visited the boutique side of this establishment today and absolutely loved it! Great place for unique gifts and the staff was friendly and helpful! I will definitely be back for more Nora Fleming items (great selection of minis!) and any special gift needs!
Katie Turner
Katie Turner
Aug 28, 2020
Report
WOW!!!!! We had Stuffed Mushroom cater my brother's wedding and they were AMAZING! The food was absolutely delicious, the staff was incredibly professional and the owner (Betsy) was so organized! The bartenders, wait staff, and cook were all first-rate! MJ, Natalie and the entire staff were a joy! Betsy, who organized/cooked the entire menu, is a Safety Harbor treasure. I HIGHLY recommend them for weddings and other events. Absolutely OUTSTANDING!
Olivia Lee
Olivia Lee
Jun 10, 2020
Report
Positive: Quality
Wow! I was so thoroughly impressed with the food and the service! I worked with Betsy and all of the staff at Stuffed Mushroom and they were so helpful, professional & quick with all our requests. The pricing was so affordable for our corporate event & EVERYONE loved the food.