Wagner Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Wagner Insurance Agency
Wagner Insurance Agency is independently owned and locally operated to handle your insurance needs. We offer affordable and reliable insurance choices all across Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, Indiana, West Virginia, Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee. We will help you find the right combination of tailored, personalized insurance coverage at just the right price to fit your needs.

We work with a wide range of quality, reliable insurance companies and can provide coverage options for any business or personal insurance need. Our staff has been working in the industry for many years. We offer guidance and help you make the right decisions for yourself, your family, or your business.
Services
We work very closely with families, business owners, risk managers and human resource departments. We feel our client requires more than just the sale of insurance products. We want to be a consumer driven organization, providing our clients with the information and counsel they need to feel confident that their choices made are the best choices for them.
The Dayton Ohio office is located on South Main St. right across from the main gates of the Montgomery County Fairgrounds. The office is easy to get to for people in the Dayton area because it accessible quickly from downtown, and I75. The office is also a quick drive for people living in communities like Oakwood, University of Dayton, the Oregon District, and the West Side.
The West Milton Ohio office is located on South Miami St. right across from U.S. Bank in downtown West Milton. The office is easy to get to for people in the Miami County area because it is right at the crossroads of Rte. 48 and Rte. 571. The office is also a quick drive for people living in communities like Ludlow Falls, Laura, Potsdam, and Tipp City.
Wagner Insurance Agency provides quality insurance choices for families and individuals throughout the state of Ohio. We specialize in finding the right coverage for your needs. Whether you are just graduating college, getting married, starting a family, sending a child off to college, or planning your retirement, we can help you find the perfect insurance policy.
Do not assume that the same plan you have this year will be exactly the same next year! There could be increasing co-pays, changes to drug formularies, networks and changes to treatment coverage. The window of time is very short (54 days which includes weekends and holidays) so it is in your best interest to setup a phone consultation or meeting with Pete sooner than later.
Reviews (7)
Elissa Fox
Elissa Fox
Sep 04, 2021
Report
I just finished talking with my new local insurance agent, Kyle Bergman, and was very excited to discover because of my savings he presented to me, I now am carrying rental insurance, as well! He clearly knows the business of Auto and RentalHomeowners Insurance and presented it in terms that were easily understood. The transition from moving from one area of the state to another has been made easier. I am pleased to report that quality Customer Service is alive and well through this Company, and this agent. I am blessed to have found Wagner Insurance Agency along with their agent, Kyle Bergman
Austin Lee
Austin Lee
Aug 03, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Helped me find a lower insurance rate, when I thought for sure it couldn’t be done. Thank you Kyle and the Wagner Insurance team!
Jim Wilson
Jim Wilson
Dec 20, 2020
Report
My family have been longtime insurance holders with Wagner Insurance Agency. They have always been accessible when ever we needed them, both for filing claims or just asking information concerning our auto and home policies. Would recommend this agency without hesitation.
John Sweeterman
John Sweeterman
Nov 06, 2020
Report
We have been clients at Wagner for over 20 years. Amanda and Mike are always so helpful with everything. We appreciate everyone at Wagner Insurance
Jeff Monroe
Jeff Monroe
Sep 08, 2020
Report
Wagner insurance has been awesome for our business. They worked diligently to find us an insurance option that fit our unique needs. And, they saved us money. It's great to have a local agent that we trust to keep us protected while looking out for our bottom line.
Donald Lewis
Donald Lewis
Aug 18, 2020
Report
I like the idea of an independent agency that can search several options to find the most cost effective option. Kyle was extremely helpful so that my insurance needs were met on the day I moved to Ohio.
Thomas Routsong
Thomas Routsong
Jun 09, 2020
Report
Wagner Ins has been very responsive to me and have kept me up to date on what's best for my account.