Paesano's Pizzeria
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
We've been in business for 23 years, we are located across from the Plattekill Town Court (behind hannafords) on 44/55. We serve fresh made to order food. You can eat in casually or sit in for finer dining, take out, or order for delivery. We deliver within a 7 mile radius with a dollar delivery fee.

We also make catering orders, all we need is 24-48 hour notice. Stop by for lunch and dinner and enjoy our daily specials, seasonal homemade soups, and cheesecake or freshly made cannolis. You can enjoy a variety of beers and white and red wines. We accept cash, check, credit cards and we also have an ATM machine on location!
Reviews (8)
John Randall
John Randall
Dec 22, 2021
Report
I have lived in New Paltz, closer to Gardiner, for 8 years. All of this time I have been going to that other pizza place...you know the one right in "downtown" Gardiner. I somehow overlooked this place, which is only a couple of minutes farther away. Last night I got a large pizza from them for the first time and g*d help me it is as good as the best pizza places in NYC. So now I have to face the fact that I spent 8 years putting terrible pizza in my mouth hole when I could have been getting this AMAZING pizza that whole time. This makes me sad but also happy at the same time. Trust me on this
Dave Ace
Dave Ace
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Nice kids working there, but I've seen them cleaning counters, sweeping with broom, and handling dust pan then grabbing your order without washing their hands. Wash your hands!!!
Fred Florsch
Fred Florsch
Sep 24, 2021
Report
Great pizza.... service was very quick, indoor seating, good selection of soft drinks. Pizza was delivered hot, and fresh toppings.
Tina Loveday
Tina Loveday
Sep 24, 2021
Report
This place is a total joke. Its too bad because they actually have decent pizza. I have actually ordered a pie from them and they were closed when I went to pick it up. They do not stay open as stated on their website hours. When I questioned the owner, he replied we close when we feel like it, so if its slow we will close. Heres a clue: try being reliable and nice to your customers and maybe you will have enough business to stay open like a normal pizza business. Don't waste your time at this place, drive a couple miles further and hit up Pasquale's in Gardiner. At least they will be open when
Robert Jones
Robert Jones
Sep 04, 2021
Report
The staff were friendly, and polite. The pizza was good l, had the right amount of toppings, and was cooked just right. Leftover slice was even good at room temp 2 hours later while on the road.
Saira Ayala
Saira Ayala
Jul 28, 2021
Report
Total rip-off $6.99 kid menu for 3 raviolis, way overpriced!!! I hate ordering from here, every time we order from here we have a disappointing experience we've had our orders switched with other customers and delievered to our house as such, we've had missing items, they answer their phone abruptly, rush your ordering...we only order as a last resort because I homecook nearly every day and they are the closest restaurant for me to get a break...the pizza is good but dang skimping out on your dinners.
Gary Buckman
Gary Buckman
Jul 27, 2021
Report
Ordered a margarita from here for lunch. My wife and I loved it. Crispy and a hearty pie for the price. We'll be back.
Karen Stoner
Karen Stoner
Jul 23, 2021
Report
This is the only pizzeria we use in the area. The pizza and sandwiches here are the best! If you want a great NY pizza look no further this is the spot to go.