Mozzarella cheese, Italian sausage, mushrooms, garlic Parmesan cream sauce & provolone cheese. Pizza sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Pepperoni, Sausage, Banana Peppers, Green Olives & Black Olives. Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Sriracha Chicken, Pineapples, Green Peppers & Drizzled with Sriracha sauce.
Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers & chopped garlic. Times Square Pizza & Bagels brings the flavor of the Big Apple to the West Coast with incredible New York style Pizzas, Bagels, Calzones & more. Our Pizzas begin with a perfectly thin and airy crust, then the zesty sauce, and followed by the deliciously fresh toppings to complete what some have called a culinary masterpiece.
Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers & chopped garlic. Times Square Pizza & Bagels brings the flavor of the Big Apple to the West Coast with incredible New York style Pizzas, Bagels, Calzones & more. Our Pizzas begin with a perfectly thin and airy crust, then the zesty sauce, and followed by the deliciously fresh toppings to complete what some have called a culinary masterpiece.
Services
The founder Sal, of Times Square Pizza & Bagels marvel in delight that he can bring a little slice of New York City to your plate for breakfast, lunch or dinner. With years of restaurant experience, time-tested recipes, & Sal's New York City memories Sal enthusiastically prepares those chewy kettle boiled & oven-baked bagels & the thin hand-tossed authentic pizzas for everyone to enjoy here on the West Coast.
Reviews (20)
Ali B.
Jan 20, 2022
Report
Michael C. Mike
Jan 11, 2022
Report
Bonnie C.
Dec 24, 2021
Report
I think there must have been an owner change. This place is Not what it used to be. This used to be our second favorite place for New York Pizza after Bongiorno's in Temecula. The last time we got a pizza here it was gross. The sauce which used to be good, tasted like it came out of a can of tomato paste.
Kimmie N.
Dec 21, 2021
Report
J. R.
Dec 21, 2021
Report
Gerry Forand
Dec 15, 2021
Report
Rita Hirmez
Dec 01, 2021
Report
Skye W.
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Happened to be in town and craved some NY pizza during my stay. I've had my share of good pizza in NY, and this was surprisingly pleasant...for Temecula! I could really taste that good ol' greasy, thin crust on the Margherita slice. Nice service from the one fella running the shop, and the Yelp check-in offer of a free slice was great too!
Kathy M.
Nov 06, 2021
Report
I am new to Temecula and have been looking for a great Pizza. So far it.s been tuff until tonight. The pizza was great and the salad was amazing. But to top it off the delivery guy was honest. My husband asked if I tipped them and I couldn't remember but the driver said you did. WOW it was so nice to see a honest young man. I will for sure be back.
Victoria A.
Oct 24, 2021
Report
Wow we've been living here for a year and because I rarely eat bagels I decided to order a smoked salmon bagel from here. I was pleasantly surprised at the presentation. It had just the right amount of smoked salmon, tomato, red onion, cream cheese and capers. Finally a place that knows how to make it the way I like it! Totally hit the spot for me! I love that the bagel was crisp on the outside and perfect when you bit into it. I ordered my husband an egg bagel sandwich but he hasn't eaten it yet. I couldn't wait to review how much I enjoyed my smoked salmon bagel. Looking forward
Elizabeth M.
Oct 12, 2021
Report
So obsessed with this place. We lived in Brooklyn for 15 years and this is the same quality pizza that you'd find there. We have lived in Temecula for a year now and this is one of my favorite places for authentic NY style pizza. The garlic knots are amazing too. Most places make them really small and they're dried out but these are nice and plump and super fresh. We have easily ordered from there about 20 times and it's been consistently amazing.
If only they had Philly cheesesteaks
If only they had Philly cheesesteaks
Alexia H.
Oct 08, 2021
Report
This place definitely beats the typical chain pizza. The wings were okay could have been crispier, they don't toss them in the sauce. So, if you were to do take out you could pop them in the oven/air fryer to make crispier. All that said they were just okay. Family size Caesar salad is large enough for four (picture doesn't justify the size). Now the main thing we came for the PIZZA, the crust is AMAZING, that's huge for me. The pizza is greasy but that's a typical NY slice. The inside of the establishment was stuffy and not as clean as I would have hoped. The tables needed
Gina Marie
Oct 03, 2021
Report
So disappointed. This is not the ooey gooey fold in half and the cheese slides off yummy NY pizza I was hoping for. It smells weird and had no flavor at all. The Chicken parmesan salad is not..where's the parm? I was expecting sauce and cheese on the chicken, but no. Just breaded chicken strips. And the Tiramisu is not homemade. I guess I got spoiled from Al's in Costs Mesa
Matthew Covarrubias
Sep 13, 2021
Report
Nick P.
Jul 25, 2021
Report
Jose G.
Jul 06, 2021
Report
We just came over on 4th of July as they were like the only pizza shop open until late and and I was surprised to see that I didn't leave a review after our first visit which I remember as being decent?
This time we ordered a 12" BBQ chicken, a 12" cheese and a family Caesar salad. The salad doesn't look that big but it was enough for 4 of us to share which was great. The BBQ chicken was tasty and my wife's cheese was good too. Staff was friendly, too especially for working on a holiday... kudos to their team
This time we ordered a 12" BBQ chicken, a 12" cheese and a family Caesar salad. The salad doesn't look that big but it was enough for 4 of us to share which was great. The BBQ chicken was tasty and my wife's cheese was good too. Staff was friendly, too especially for working on a holiday... kudos to their team
Lili T.
Dec 11, 2020
Report
Every so often I find myself looking up random lunch spots in Temecula. Back in July (yes, a delayed review I know..) I was working in a clinic in the area and figured pizza would be great for a solo lunch in my car while watching the ducks in the lake nearby. I found this place on yelp and it was highly rated and also had a free slice with check in! I stopped by and was quickly greeted and assisted in choosing my slices of pizza. I went for the Margherita slice and the pepperoni was my free slice with check in.
This is the type of pizza place with thin NY style crust, which I love, and they reheat
This is the type of pizza place with thin NY style crust, which I love, and they reheat
Kaban Mathias
Sep 19, 2020
Report
I have delivered food for these folks prior to the Pandemic and today I wanted to show them some love!
If you're looking for a New York Style Pizza with some really fresh ingredients, this is your place! The staff is also wonderful and always friendly! Give these folks a shot if you like thin pizza! Help small business folks!! Totally foldable too 🙂
If you're looking for a New York Style Pizza with some really fresh ingredients, this is your place! The staff is also wonderful and always friendly! Give these folks a shot if you like thin pizza! Help small business folks!! Totally foldable too 🙂
Jack Ryan
Jul 19, 2020
Report
One of my favorite places in town for having a few slices and enjoying a beer. No question the prices on pizza are on the steeper side but with the extra few $$ comes super quality. I personally enjoy the thinner slices because they give great toppings portions while less bread because I'm not a fan of being a fat pig. Salads are great, garlic knots are delicious and I recommend.
Stephen Casillas
Aug 24, 2019
Report
Hands down the best NY style pizza in this area. I used to go to A Carini’s in Murrieta until I discovered this place. The crust is light, thin and crisp. The sauce has a perfect flavor and they use high quality cheese. I always enjoy going in. If you ever wanted to know what it’s like to eat an authentic NY slice, Temecula is closer and you can have it without the 7 hour plane trip.
