Name: Lenny's Pizza & Trattoria
Address: 80 Morristown Rd, Bernardsville, NJ, 07924, US
Telephone: (908) 766-0465
Rating: 3.3

We're so much more than pizza! Our family-owned establishment prepares all dishes to order, using only the best ingredients-superior meats, artisan cheeses, bakery bread, fresh seafood, and top-quality produce.

Whether you prefer plain or one of our gourmet pies, our expert pizza chefs handcraft our signature dough every day from scratch using Lenny's original time-tested recipe, and our secret marinara sauce is made using the finest imported Italian tomatoes.We guarantee an exceptional experience with the friendly service that has made us the area's favorite dining destination since 1995.

Website Update

Reviews (10)

Write a Review

Wick Smith

Jan 29, 2022

Report

Their Margarita pizza is the absolute best. Like any pizzeria, the best taste is eating in. But take out is also delicious.

Jamie Landsman

Dec 19, 2021

Report

In all my years I’ve never ever ever thrown out leftover pizza before I tried this place. Truly one of the most flavorless pies I’ve ever had. Very disappointing.

Greg

Dec 02, 2021

Report

They have just excellent Margherita and meat lasagna. A few months ago, the quality went a bit down and the lasagna became fatty, but recently all came back normal, eg, great! Hey - has the cook came back? ;)
Hint - consider grilling the bread for lasagna. Just a bit.

M. H. Mh

Oct 11, 2020

Report

We have been going here for over 10 years and it’s a shame that the quality of the pizza has deteriorated, the service has plummeted and the prices have increased. It was better when the decor was more quaint and customers were appreciated. Now the only thing you can count on is getting free attitude with every order.

Dan Krych

Aug 28, 2020

Report

I tried the margarita slice and grandma. both were excellent. the crust was very very interesting. it was soft with a slight crunch to it. i really enjoyed it. it seem to melt in my mouth. the sauce was good as well. i think store bought but i enjoy this pizza. i would come back. the place was clean as well.

Chuck Mound

Aug 26, 2020

Report

Margherita Slice was very Good. Good portion slices of Mozarella with a very good tasting sauce. The Crust was good, but could be great. That was the missing component for a 5. Just can't quite put my finger on it, but just needed something more with the crust to put it over the top. Service was average and the place was clean. I would go back.

Kristi MacDonald

Jun 27, 2020

Report

Pizza is pretty good most of the time but inconsistent. The low rating is for the terrible service I received a couple weeks ago when I ordered 2 of the "grandma's Brooklyn style" pies for hungry volunteers working hard on a project in town. The pizza was filled with sandy grit. So embarrassing! I called Lenny's to tell them and all they said was, "Sorry for the inconvenience. It must be the basil." No offer to replace the pies or give a refund.

Flying Lap Productions

Jun 26, 2020

Report

I understand that all businesses and eateries that have had to make drastic changes and accommodations and it hasn't been easy. I do acknowledge that. But at the same time I do notice the quality of food and preparation has dropped off slightly. The staff are super friendly and professional. But the last two times I have gotten food from there, it has had fatty bits within the chicken and then with the sausage. The pizza is still good but like I said I think the quality of Lenny's is suffering from this manufactured crisis.

Arun Vishwanathan

Oct 25, 2019

Report

Judging by the crowd, am sure the pizza is great.
However my veggie slice had three flaws:
A) Lukewarm not piping hot
B) No salt
C) Had broccoli (who puts that in a pizza?)
Place is clean and nice
May come back to give them another chance

Sara Izad

Sep 27, 2017

Report

Best Margarita pizza ever, period. The Lazio chicken panini is amazing as well. They are consistently great for as many years as we know them. Really nice staff!