Bay Real Experts
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Bay Real Experts
As a team of independent real estate agents with Coldwell Banker Realty, Bay Real Experts are the top-rated real estate professionals in Panama City Beach. Our team offers a tremendous variety of hyper-local real estate expertise and wisdom with over 40 years of combined local experience. Dependable and dedicated, our clients are our top priority.

A member of our team will ALWAYS be available to take or return your call promptly. We take great pride in ourselves for being recognized as great communicators by our past-clients and peers while maintaining the same high quality of service at ANY price point. Listing, Marketing and Selling Homes as full service Panama City Beach Real Estate Agents.
Services
Selecting an agent can be a tough decision when there are so many top producing agents with experience taking properties from just listed to just sold. Contact us to schedule your free marketing consultation. It is all about showcasing your home to well matched buyers. See for yourself why our plan worked for so many of our past clients.
Originally from Houston-TX, raised in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, and Florida resident since 2001. Over 16 years in the Real Estate industry. Exceptional sales performance has consistently ranked her among the top agents in the company. Alice finds great joy and success in helping her clients achieve their real estate goals without all the stress and headaches that are commonly encountered during a move.
Sean's taste for Luxury is probably genetic, if not osmosed. As a young man, his senior family members were extremely successful and discrete in business with celebrities and VIPs of Hollywood. That whirlwind of grandeur spun his heart with an infatuation for mansions, exotic cars, and the life of luxury.
Prior to becoming a Realtor, Libby was a successful and well-respected elementary school teacher. She holds a Masters Degree in Elementary Education from Eastern Kentucky University. Libby has been a full-time Realtor since 1984, specializing in resort real estate and beachfront properties.

Her expertise, however, is not limited to just resort real estate and beachfront properties as she has successfully marketed all types of residential and light commercial properties.As "The First Lady of Real Estate", Libby is consistently among the top producers of Coldwell Banker as well as all of Bay County, Florida.
Would you like your property to be featured on our website? Contact us for a free evaluation and for a marketing consultation. If you would like a custom search refined out of all the MLS condos and homes for sale in Bay County Florida, please contact us at (850) 628-5385 to get started. Ready to find and make an offer on your new dream home?
Reviews (16)
Chinazom O.
Chinazom O.
Jan 04, 2022
Report
Alice is a wonderful realtor. From Day 1, she proved that she would deliver and that's exactly what she did throughout the whole process. From the moment I started working with Alice, I knew I could always count on her. She always spent the time to clarify things for me which made the process so much smoother. As I was out of town for the whole process, Alice kept me very well informed, she was my eyes and ears at all times. She was always on top of things and extremely highly knowledgeable. She's just simply amazing and the best at what she does. She played an integral part in this process
Gina Mann
Gina Mann
Dec 08, 2021
Report
Alice and Sean were wonderful to work with. They are very knowledgeable and professional and very quick to respond throughout the entire process. They helped me sell one home and buy another. Without hesitation, I recommend them.
Lady Tyrannosaur
Lady Tyrannosaur
Dec 01, 2021
Report
We sold our house recently and we have to thank you Sean and Alice so much for everything! We were also traveling while the house was listed and everything was done virtually or by phone, which made things much more efficient for us. They made this whole process as painless as possible and we appreciate everything!! Would absolutely recommend them to anyone buying or selling.
They were also great at answering questions and giving guidance months before we were even ready to list, they really just go out of their way to help you.
Samantha Miller
Samantha Miller
Nov 20, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Sean is the best he helped me out so much finding my property im so grateful thank u for everything
Dan Homp
Dan Homp
Oct 21, 2021
Report
I've been waiting for a chance to write this review for 9 months: the time I first started working with Sean, Alice and Libby, to now, when we're just about to close on our new build. If you're reading this, considering Bay Real Experts as your realtors: you're done! Look no further!
When I was looking for a realtor back in January 2021, I did an exhaustive search of recommendations and comments from literally hundreds of buyers and sellers in Panama City Beach. This group stood out, head and shoulders above anyone else I came across.
From the moment I contacted them until now, 9 months later
Margaret Allen
Margaret Allen
Oct 06, 2021
Report
Libby and Sean are the two best agents you could possibly have. I inherited a home that needed many home improvements. Libby set up a contractor and was involved with the repairs every step of the way. When we needed inspections, I relied on their expertise in hiring home and pest inspectors. Sean and Libby were in constant communication regarding showings, offers and finally a Purchase and Sale agreement. They are both extremely professional and have the highest integrity and go above and beyond for you the client. They were our advocates throughout the whole process and maintained a positive
Edwin Lyngar
Edwin Lyngar
Sep 30, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Great real estate company. Very responsive. The online tools are great, and my agent, Sean, was a true professional. Highly recommend.
Bruce Brodsky
Bruce Brodsky
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Excellent experience working with Sean and Bay Real Experts. They did everything that they said they would do, and were promptly responsive to all questions or requests that I had. I highly recommend Bay Real Experts to anyone looking to sell or buy a home!
Derenda Brown
Derenda Brown
May 29, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
We had a great experience with Bay Real Experts. Sean and Alice listened to our needs and found us the perfect house. They were hands on through the whole process and made us feel like we were their only customer. Highly recommend!!!
Christi Wilkett
Christi Wilkett
May 07, 2021
Report
Sean and Alice are the best! We found them on google while reading reviews for Realtors. They certainly lived up to their five stars!! They were both extremely responsive, and we had A LOT of questions. They helped us in our search for a condo in an extremely crazy market. They spent as much time as it took to get us there. We will definitely call them again for our next condo purchase.
Erik Courson
Erik Courson
May 06, 2021
Report
I was looking for a realtor for an out of state purchase in Panama City Beach, and eventually settled on Sean and Alice. They were fantastic throughout the process, and most importantly they always took the time to answer all of my questions. From the moment of Sean and I's first conversation, I felt like we'd be a great match. He took the time to listen and understand what I was wanting to do, and they helped guide me there every step of the way.
I couldn't have made the purchase without all of their help, and I couldn't recommend them highly enough!
Eric S.
Eric S.
Mar 18, 2021
Report
We made a great choice by selecting Alice and Sean to help us find our beach house. They went above and beyond to help guide us through the entire buying process that can sometimes be overwhelming. We feel blessed to have found the right realtors from the start and I would gladly recommend their services to anyone!
Matt T.
Matt T.
Jul 22, 2020
Report
I couldn't recommend Alice de La Penha and Sean Casilli from Bay Real Experts more as real estate agents. We worked with them as we started our home search from the Washington DC area. They did not hesitate to visit any of the properties we were interested in. The quality of Alice and Sean's video walkthroughs were outstanding, as they provided honest and constructive feedback (good and not so good) on the houses we had only viewed online. I would absolutely want to work with them again; they made our first-time home-buying experience as smooth as I can possibly imagine! I will certainly
Tim S.
Tim S.
Jan 15, 2018
Report
I met Sean through a mutual friend and couldn't be more impressed with his excellent follow up and the fact that he really knows the local market. I'm looking to invest in something that will not only appreciate in value but give me good rental income in the meantime. When I visited northwest FL I pictured a tropical paradise and Panama City Beach seems like my perfect future home. I told Sean about my vision of a normal 3 bed 2 bath house I'm searching for more specifically a large kitchen as I want to put a fish tank near the entrance and wow Sean surprised me with his fish, corals
Adam R.
Adam R.
Nov 08, 2017
Report
Well what can i say Sean is a stand up guy. Always personal , helpful, good communicator.. Things you need when looking for a house. .If your looking for home this is your guy. He has answered my questions and has spent the time to do the research on finding the right spot. Very Proactive and will get out in front of things before the opportunities are gone.His customer service was beyond the best. Weekend or not his response time was great in getting back to me on my questions. Please don't hesitate to give him a call so that he may find the right place for you
Justin J.
Justin J.
Oct 05, 2017
Report
Top 3 requirements in a Realtor?

1) Dependable
2) Communicator
3) Long-term Relationship


1) Dependable - If Sean says "yes", he means it. You're not going to get a text an hour or two before the appointment with some lame excuse that you need to reschedule. He's not going to drag his feet on doing the research to answer your question. He will be by your side from the day you introduce yourself until the day you close on your home - and beyond.

2) Communicator - There are SO many agents out there that are not into client/agent relationships.. Instead they're like a