Our mission is to share a passion for creativity and innovation through custom cakes and education. Specializing in creating custom cakes as unique as the people they are for. We have an incredibly talented team from various backgrounds. Hiring for values and providing continued education opportunities ensures our team is always learning and growing.
We have the best people and that is not by accident. We offer complimentary cake tastings. For those last minute events or when you are just having a craving; we have a case full of never frozen, decorated cakes and cupcakes ready to go. Combining simple, premium quality ingredients with experience means you are getting the best!
We have the best people and that is not by accident. We offer complimentary cake tastings. For those last minute events or when you are just having a craving; we have a case full of never frozen, decorated cakes and cupcakes ready to go. Combining simple, premium quality ingredients with experience means you are getting the best!
Services
Check out our portfolio or we can create a custom design for you pulling from your invitations, colors or inspiration photos. Classic Cakes created such a wonderful cake for my wedding reception. They had a lot of ideas about how to make it look like some of the photos I brought in as well as let me try a lot of samples to make up my mind.
Complimentary Cake Tastings are by appointment only. During your appointment you will get to sample from about a dozen cake flavors & fillings as well as design your custom cake. You will receive your quote at this time as well. If there is a particular flavor you know you want to try please let us know & we will have that available for you as well.
I am so excited that you are interested in a Cake Decorating Class with Classic Cakes! I have been teaching cooking classes for over a decade now & I absolutely love getting to bring YOU into my kitchen! I have had a blast sharing my tips & tricks with you during our Tutorial Tuesdays but it is time to get your hands dirty too!
After 25 years of business in Carmel, we are working with local businesses to provide their menu & customers with a taste of Classic Cakes. We are partnered with several hotels, caterers & restaurants & coffee shops, providing their clients with quality cake. Interested in partnering? Qualified vendors receive their first cake FREE!
Have you been dreaming of opening your own bakery? Do you already own a small business in the food service industry & feel like your business is running your life? Are you thinking about succession planning? After years of entrepreneurship & mentoring I have decided to make it official & became a certified business coach.
Reviews (8)
Amber Day
Dec 13, 2021
Report
We got 5 cakes from Classic Cakes for our wedding in November and they were all delicious! 3 of these were ordered only 2 weeks before our wedding when our original desert plan from another vendor had fallen through! Classic Cakes was very professional and were able to accommodate our short notice order happily.
Thank you so much for everything!!
Thank you so much for everything!!
Dawson August
Nov 27, 2021
Report
Great cakes and a pretty fair price for what you pay. The employees were very friendly and welcoming. I have gotten a few cakes from here before as well as a cheesecake... I will say that the classic cake is a little on the dry side sadly compared to their other cake flavors (I thought this might've been a one time thing but after multiple times purchasing this cake it has consistently been this way so it seems like a preference thing), my favorite so far is the cookies and cream flavor. The chocolate cake portion of it is just the right amount of moisture, it is very sweet so small slices will
Cynthia R.
Nov 15, 2021
Report
Katt Hawthorne
Oct 21, 2021
Report
Classic Cakes is, hands down, THE perfect wedding cake vendor in the Indianapolis area. Their work is both elegant and imaginative--their cakes are like statement art pieces that will have your guests talking for years after your wedding. Their flavors are delicious, and need to be sampled to be believed. I am not normally a fan of buttercream icing, but their proprietary recipe makes theirs something special--I could eat just it without any cake involved, and be totally content. Even their fondant, which is a substance that is renowned for being disgusting, is a gustatory delight. It actually
Nancy Knight
Aug 30, 2021
Report
Where to start? When our local bakery could not meet our request for a birthday cake, we tried Classic Cakes. That was over a year ago and we have not looked back!! We recently did a cake tasting for my daughter's wedding. What a fun experience! The staff was so helpful and made navigating through the decisions so much fun. We chose a beautiful small traditional wedding cake - and then 5 flavored cakes! Can't wait to hear how much the wedding guests love these fabulous flavors of cakes and what a beautiful display the cake table will be at the event.
Chris Kimball
Aug 23, 2021
Report
Chloe Opalka
Oct 27, 2020
Report
Classic Cakes did an AMAZING job on the cake for my brother’s baby gender reveal!! Jennifer walked me through the entire process while I was all the way in Colorado, kept me informed, and made the cake look absolutely incredible! I made a mistake and told them that the cake was for July 14th rather than June, and when we went to pick it up the day before the party and it wasn’t there, instead of saying that there wasn’t anything they could do on such short notice (many cakes are ordered weeks-months in advance and they are Busy), they made the cake that night, and the owner of the bakery
Allison Butler
Aug 13, 2020
Report
My husband and I chose Classic Cakes for our wedding cake, and we are so glad we did! Megan and her team are so sweet, and were wonderful to work with. Our wedding cake was absolutely STUNNING and became a focal point at the reception. Every aspect and detail was done beautifully! Not only was it gorgeous, but the cake itself was delicious and moist. We received many compliments on our cake, and I was more than happy to let everyone know that Classic Cakes was the one who was behind it all!
