Our History Bay Street Tattoo has been tattooing and body piercing in Milwaukee since June of 1999. We are a women owned business and always have been. We are a custom tattoo shop and would love to draw you the tattoo of your dreams. Black & grey, color, or cover-up we are happy to help. We also have almost 30 years in body piercing and the shop carries a large collection of body jewelry including genuine gemstones, gold, and acrylic of all styles.
Services
Bay Street is proud to be one of Milwaukee's best and most experienced piercing destinations. We always strive for perfection. We only carry the highest quality body jewelry available and offer anything from 18kt gold to exotic organics upon request. Our piercing needles are new, sterile, used one time, and responsibly disposed of.
Q: Can I feel the tooth jewel on my tooth? A: Initially something on your tooth will feel different, but a few days after the application you will get used to the new feeling. Q: Will the jewel harm my tooth? A: No! The jewel is bonded to the enamel like an orthodontic bracket without any drilling or pain.
Bay Street Tattoo is located at 322 E Bay Street in Milwaukee Wisconsin. Our bright yellow building is located on the corner of KK and Beecher. Plenty of parking is available in our private lot. WHEN ARE YOU OPEN? BST is open on an appointment only basis. HOW CAN I BOOK AN APPOINTMENT AT BST? Walk-in clients are not being accepted at this time.
Reviews (10)
Charlotte Anderson
Jan 14, 2022
Report
Sheri is an absolute rockstar!!!!!! i’m absolutely terrified of needles - but finally got the courage to get my septum pierced & after googling i found Bay Street. i’m so so glad i did!! Sheri was so kind & great, explaining the whole process but the best part was that she was super quick!! and gentle!! i just got my nostril pierced tonight and it was honestly such a breeze because i had an amazing experience the first time. i will for sure be coming back ! :)
Rasaan Sanders
Jan 04, 2022
Report
They did a great job with the eyebrow piercing but be aware that they over charge for service.
Eyebrow Piercing (Barbell)
$ 45.00
Price includes standard starter jewelry. $10 deposit is required to hold your appointment and will come off the total cost of your service.
Above was copied directly from their website. Yet I was charge 47.50 for the piercing and I was also charged $10 to hold my appointment. So total I paid $57.50 for the piercing. Their website should be changed for false advertising. Happy with the piercing disappointed
that I was over charged. I will not return and would not
Eyebrow Piercing (Barbell)
$ 45.00
Price includes standard starter jewelry. $10 deposit is required to hold your appointment and will come off the total cost of your service.
Above was copied directly from their website. Yet I was charge 47.50 for the piercing and I was also charged $10 to hold my appointment. So total I paid $57.50 for the piercing. Their website should be changed for false advertising. Happy with the piercing disappointed
that I was over charged. I will not return and would not
Rachel Sekey
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Positive: Cleanliness, Professionalism, Punctuality, Quality, Value
Sheri was very welcoming and kind from the moment I walked in to the moment I left. She was very caring when it came time to my piercing and took the time to explain everything to me.
Definitely recommend this shop!
Service: Nose piercing
Sheri was very welcoming and kind from the moment I walked in to the moment I left. She was very caring when it came time to my piercing and took the time to explain everything to me.
Definitely recommend this shop!
Service: Nose piercing
R. D.
Dec 19, 2021
Report
Do not purchase their "natural healing solution" for piercings. The bottle says it is made with tea tree oil, lavender and witch hazel. Lol tea tree has one of the strongest smells and so does lavender. The solution smells like nothing yet it's oily. It is literally water and olive oil. Dishonest and over priced. The only "happy" customers in their review are their friends and family.
I recommend Avant Garde on Greenfield Avenue.
I recommend Avant Garde on Greenfield Avenue.
Sasha Zitzelsberger
Oct 05, 2021
Report
Positive: Cleanliness, Professionalism, Punctuality, Quality, Value
I am related to the owner & her wife. My experience was amazing. Sheri is amazing at her profession & fast when it comes to tattoos. Sweetest tattoo artist I ever known. Best tattoo experience EVER! Definitely will return!!
Service: Tattoos
I am related to the owner & her wife. My experience was amazing. Sheri is amazing at her profession & fast when it comes to tattoos. Sweetest tattoo artist I ever known. Best tattoo experience EVER! Definitely will return!!
Service: Tattoos
Samantha Thomfohrda
Oct 02, 2021
Report
I called in asking if Sheri could squeeze me in for a nose and 2 lobe piercings— she was able to right away! I came in and was there for maybe 15 minutes. She was was kind, informative, and comforting. The shop was super cute and clean. I will definitely be back for more piercings in the future and maybe another tattoo 🎨🦋✨Highly recommend. 🌈
Frida Detres
Sep 04, 2021
Report
Wasn’t asked what earrings I would like to wear when my piercing was complete. Since I walked in and asked for what I wanted done. There was a list of reasons why they might not get the piercings to look identical. Only one of my ears was pierced and I was charged 50$… when it was 60$ for both. I would not recommend this place. I would even pay more for better service. I was also told to put contact solution to clean my ears so I wouldn’t get an infection.
Joe Ludwig
Aug 25, 2021
Report
Abby Schmidt
Jul 19, 2021
Report
I was looking for a place in Milwaukee that is in a safe neighborhood to get my navel piercing done. I found Bay Street Tattoo Co. by google search and made a appointment with Sheri. It was my first piercing besides my standard earlobe ones and I was nervous. Sheri was so nice, professional and made the whole process so easy. She explained everything she did beforehand and was extremely informative on the aftercare process and talked to me about a tattoo I have been wanting. She explained that the shop really valued their work and customers which definitely shined through. I will be coming back
Ann Nordeen
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Positive: Cleanliness, Professionalism, Punctuality, Quality
Took my 13 year old to get her ears double pierced. Sheri was very kind and engaging. My daughter still claims she felt nothing - she was totally shocked at the ease of the experience. Very clean and professional- would recommend to anyone!! Very pleased with the WHOLE experience!! Thank you!
Service: Ear piercing
Took my 13 year old to get her ears double pierced. Sheri was very kind and engaging. My daughter still claims she felt nothing - she was totally shocked at the ease of the experience. Very clean and professional- would recommend to anyone!! Very pleased with the WHOLE experience!! Thank you!
Service: Ear piercing
