Brooklyn Pizza located on Route 9W in Newburgh NY serving the Hudson Valley the best Pizza and Subs with a Brooklyn taste. If you are craving for the tastiest pizza in town, stop by or call in for a free delivery. The lunch special is one of the best deals in the area. The slices were exceptional but took a backseat to the garlic knots, which were almost too perfect.
I've never had buffalo garlic knots until now; they'll become a regular part of my diet. I learned that the southern entrance to the parking lot is the easier of the two options, but even the northern one is doable if you have a small turning radius and no one is tailgating you.
I've never had buffalo garlic knots until now; they'll become a regular part of my diet. I learned that the southern entrance to the parking lot is the easier of the two options, but even the northern one is doable if you have a small turning radius and no one is tailgating you.
Reviews (24)
Berk Ozel
Jan 30, 2022
Report
Lisa Cobb
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Chris Pena
Oct 19, 2021
Report
Pizza and wings are 4.5 stars.
The rating of 2 stars is due to placing an order for delivery, waiting over an hour for delivery, being called by the delivery driver after waiting for over an hour and being told they do not delivery to my address when they have delivered to my address 2 times before.
The rating of 2 stars is due to placing an order for delivery, waiting over an hour for delivery, being called by the delivery driver after waiting for over an hour and being told they do not delivery to my address when they have delivered to my address 2 times before.
Michelle Sullivan
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Randy Collazo
Aug 29, 2021
Report
Me and my Wife are New Yorkers by birth but now reside in PA. We miss NY pizza! We were in town for my Daughters wedding and leaving to go back home when we thought...hey we haven't had our pizza. We found Brooklyn Pizza and tried it. Garlic knots...dam good, and we got a large pizza to eat in the way. Thank you guys for giving us our great memory of the pizza that we miss. Would go back!
Stephenie
Aug 18, 2020
Report
I stopped in here for the first time with my family and ordered two pies. It was very disappointing to see such thin slices with VERY LITTLE cheese. The grease was literally dripping from the slice as you pull it out the box. I must say it was definitely the worst pizza my family and I ever had. 😫
Emma Jendrejeski
Jul 14, 2020
Report
Myself and the rest of my family have been ordering from here for years, the Buffalo chicken bacon ranch is for sure my favorite thing to order but everyone in my family has a different favorite.. would definitely recommend trying the Buffalo knots or the chicken parmigiana! Love supporting local businesses and this one has got the best pizza hands down!
Chris Gman
Jun 06, 2020
Report
Euriese F.
Nov 15, 2019
Report
Kevin Buckley
Aug 30, 2019
Report
The lunch special is one of the best deals in the area. The slices were exceptional but took a backseat to the garlic knots, which were almost too perfect. I've never had buffalo garlic knots until now; they'll become a regular part of my diet. I learned that the southern entrance to the parking lot is the easier of the two options, but even the northern one is doable if you have a small turning radius and no one is tailgating you.
Joe S.
Aug 13, 2019
Report
Trinity A.
Jul 12, 2019
Report
V. B.
Jun 27, 2019
Report
Aislinn H.
May 16, 2019
Report
My husband and I are here atleast once a week, Danny is wonderful and so is the rest of his crew! Even the other "regulars" we've started to know are the best. Always a fun spot to stop in quick for a slice and their bite-sized garlic knots! Feels like going to your cousins for lunch. Five stars isn't enough.
Ariel D.
Dec 30, 2018
Report
Christine A.
Oct 21, 2018
Report
Food is 'meh'. But with so many disappointing Italian places in Newburgh this winds up be a de-facto delivery place..
Had good experiences but tonight the delivery guy was obnoxious. Very snide about having to wait while he knocked (so didn't hear). I apologized but he wasn't satisfied. We exchanged words.
Will not order again from here. I don't need to have attitude when giving 20% tip and order arrives late and I am admonished for not being quick to answer the door!
Had good experiences but tonight the delivery guy was obnoxious. Very snide about having to wait while he knocked (so didn't hear). I apologized but he wasn't satisfied. We exchanged words.
Will not order again from here. I don't need to have attitude when giving 20% tip and order arrives late and I am admonished for not being quick to answer the door!
Jazzi M.
Mar 23, 2018
Report
I have to say I'm really impressed with this place. The beef patty was flaky, flavorful and had a good amount of beef. I loved how they put the fried dough in a paper bag and NOT a container. Because warm fried dough in a container causes condensation on the top of the container which turns the sugar into a paste. This is one of those places that you try and know it will become a place you will always be happy ordering from. Check this place out.
Jamie H.
Oct 16, 2017
Report
Daniel L.
Mar 18, 2017
Report
Gabriela M.
Apr 25, 2016
Report
I'm always in this spot for some chicken rice soup. They're never short of my lemons. My favorite pizza is the taco pizza, it's to die for! The key with this lovely creation is the crispy crust... Yuuummm! One more key item, the buffalo garlic knots are necessary! If you're in the neighborhood give it a try, you don't regret it!
Clint B.
Nov 01, 2015
Report
D. S.
Aug 09, 2015
Report
Steve L.
Jun 21, 2015
Report
I'm now halfway done with the taco pizza, which I got at the Newburgh location. Quite disappointing, and a waste of money. It doesn't taste like taco; it doesn't taste like pizza; it doesn't taste like anything in between. It seems to lack any seasoning at all, is very soggy, and there's nothing to hold the ingredients on the pizza. Barely a dribbling of cheese. It is the sloppiest pizza I've ever tried to eat.
Is the Newburgh restaurant under new management? Doesn't seem as friendly as the last time (which was my first time) I was there. The pizza I got here
Is the Newburgh restaurant under new management? Doesn't seem as friendly as the last time (which was my first time) I was there. The pizza I got here
Kobe M.
Jan 28, 2015
Report
I worked here for about 2-3 months as a pizza maker and left because another job presented itself. I've worked in pizzerias for 7+ years and from first hand experience I can tell you that this establishment uses only top notch ingredients in their pizza. Everyone is very polite and welcoming in the store and service is excellent. As a former employee I would fully recommend stopping in and plan on doing so myself. Check em out, owner danny is a good dude.
