For delicious thin Neopolitan and thick Sicilian pizzas, visit Vincenzo's Pizzeria in Elmira, NY. We are locally owned and operated by Vinnie and Dominic, with our combined experiences we have been making great tasting pizza for 50 years. Our specialty pizzas such as The Sinatra, Leonardo D'Vinci, Prima Vera, Caesar's, among many, are made from fresh dough and ingredients.
All you have to do is ask for them by name. We also serve hot and cold hoagies, antipasta and salads, fresh wings, calzone and stromboli, fries, party packs, and house specials. For the Elmira's best pizza and specialty pizzas, come visit us! You can dine in or opt for takeout. You may call ahead for rush or large takeout orders.
All you have to do is ask for them by name. We also serve hot and cold hoagies, antipasta and salads, fresh wings, calzone and stromboli, fries, party packs, and house specials. For the Elmira's best pizza and specialty pizzas, come visit us! You can dine in or opt for takeout. You may call ahead for rush or large takeout orders.
Services
My husband LOVES Pizza, but I can take it or leave it. When he is wanting a Pizza really bad and I am not in the mood to make one of my great homemade ones, we go to Vincenzo's. It is the only Pizza around that I will eat. It is always fresh and hot. The tomato sauce is not. Please remember that if you find yourself in Elmira - there are not much choices - period.
Reviews (8)
Danielle Hernandez
Feb 01, 2022
Report
Vincenzo's is hands down one of the best Italian pizza places in the Elmira area. Decent prices and variety yes, but the main thing is their quality. Absolutely delicious every time I've gone. Not to mention the cannolis and tiramisu available there, sooo good. My favorite is the Dinero pizza, but I love trying out whatever specialty slices they have on hand for a quick bite.
Kaylee Nick
Jan 27, 2022
Report
Chad Maphis
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Terri Kozier
Sep 26, 2021
Report
My husband and I ordered two pizzas for our wedding party two&1/2 months ago, I had several pieces left over so in the freezer they went ! I just pulled the leftovers out for lunch and they were as delicious as they were on July 2nd !!! Fantastic job you guys, BRAVO ! I WILL order any of their pizzas, especially the Frank Sinatra 😍😍😍😍😍 Sincerely, Richard and Terri Bywater ! Elmira, NY
Rena Banks
Sep 12, 2021
Report
We were passing through Elmira on a road trip and stopped to grab Subway. We saw Vincenzos beside Subway and a guy walking out with a sub so we decided to stop in there instead. Best decision ever! We had an Italian and a tuna sub. We didn’t know they were coming with fries so that was an awesome surprise. The subs were so delicious! The bread was warm and crispy and was my favorite part but the tuna I had was also so good. 10/10 would go here again if I ever find myself in that town again!
Anthea Cavallaro
Aug 12, 2021
Report
Vikki Crown
May 15, 2021
Report
Stephen Ruggiano
Aug 14, 2018
Report
I almost feel bad leaving such a poor review but I feel even worse about the pizza I just received. Almost no cheese and no flavor. Just look at the picture- not appetizing at all. Truly, this is possibly the worst pizza I've ever tasted. It's not as though it is cheap either, as I paid $25 with tip for a large cheese(less?) pizza.
