Premier Auction Galleries
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Premier Auction Galleries is proud to present and offer to you part of the BOB and ANNE FELLER Gates Mills residence in several of our upcoming auctions! All items presented from their home will come with a letter of provenance stating just that! Bob and Anne Feller were the first family of the Cleveland Indians for many, many years.

Cherished by sports fans in Cleveland and around the world, their legacy will live on forever. Premier Auction Galleries has had the privilege of obtaining many of the cherished items from the Feller home. Artwork, furniture, household belongings, Anne's handbag collection, Bob's personal desk, personal artifacts, sports memorabilia, clothing, household items and so much more.
Services
First off, I would like to thank you for your time and your interest. My name is Jesse C. Mathews II born and raised in Ohio. I am 40yrs old and the founder/owner of Premier Auction Galleries. Having grown up around auctions since the age of 8, maybe younger, I've always had an interest.

For those of you that know my father you know what I mean when I say that since the age of 8 I've been in and out of auctions all throughout the country and for those of you that may not, well allow me to take a moment and inform you.Jessie Carl Mathews, aka Mr. Willoughby's, Papa Genius and Carl, a well known antique dealer and collector, owned several retail shops in and around the Cleveland Ohio for well over 30yrs.
If you are a potential seller and have questions about the auction process please feel free call for a free consultation, stop in our Gallery or simply send an email to jessemathews@pag4u.com. We have the utmost competitive and flexible commision rates. We are always willing to drive long distances as well.
1. CAVEAT EMPTOR: The property purchased at Premier Auction Galleries is sold "AS IS" without any representations or warranties, express or implied, by PAG or its consignor(s) as to the merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, or description of any property. Any condition statement is given as a courtesy to the client, is only an opinion and should not be treated as a statement of fact.
The Law Offices of Scott A Fierman is a direct affiliate of Premier Auction Galleries. We take pride in our clients needs and personal property. The Law Office has many behind the scenes diligence in handling contractual Ohio requirements. Also, many direct estate descend from their offices as a result from our relationship.
Reviews (10)
Mindy
Mindy
May 30, 2021
Report
Premier Auction Galleries helped my family downsize and sell antiques that have been handed down to us. I received very accurate quotes on what items would sell for and they picked up items and sold them in a timely matter. They gave us great recommendations for what to do with items that they did not sell for us. I would highly recommend them.
Scott Donovan
Scott Donovan
Dec 08, 2020
Report
Buyers be very cautious bidding online. Descriptions are often wrong as I don't think they have any experts on staff. I unfortunately bought a few items and nothing was made by the manufacturer they claimed.
Daniel Rubin
Daniel Rubin
Nov 30, 2020
Report
Professional all the way-easy-easy-wish all of the auction houses operated like Premier-One call paid-and in house shipping-great--Jesse even followed up on an lot that was passed and i wish to purchase a week later-going the last mile-will make sure that i check out every operation of their's
Jordan Kamp
Jordan Kamp
Nov 21, 2020
Report
I've been collecting for fine art and antiques for over 15 years now and there's few houses as pleasant to work with as Premier Auction Galleries. Every transaction big or small has been seamless. Last week I bought something in their Winter auction and two days later it was on my front porch impeccably wrapped. Jesse Mathews and family have truly cultivated an auction experience that you won't want to miss.
Jenifer Bemis
Jenifer Bemis
Sep 06, 2020
Report
Paid for my one item immediately. No instructions on where, how, or when to pick up. Called, emailed five times.finally someone took my call said they’d call back. Never heard from them. Have tried for weeks to get a hold of them to either pick up or get item delivered and nothing. I would retract review if I could get my item... that I really want by the way.
Dominique Schulz
Dominique Schulz
Sep 04, 2018
Report
My name is Dominique Schulz. I have been in the antiques/collectibles business in the Northeastern Ohio area for many years, and have known Jesse Matthews for over a decade. It was recently brought to my attention that Jesse received a very negative review on Google, and considering how damaging bad customer reviews can be I felt I had to say something. I have had numerous business dealings with Jesse and have always found him to be honest and fair. He has been kind to my employees and has gone out of his way to do me favors when he didn't have to. Jesse's auction activities extend throughout Lake
Luybov Zakharova
Luybov Zakharova
Nov 21, 2017
Report
Awful to their customers. The site says that they help their customers in the delivery. But in reality there is no help. I wrote letters to them for a month. No answer! Although I immediately paid for the goods. I do a lot of shopping on the Internet, but this is the first time I have faced such an attitude. They apparently do not care if they buy goods from them or not. I have not received my things yet and I do not even know if I will get them. But I know for sure that they have no purchases
Michael Deshaies
Michael Deshaies
Jan 30, 2017
Report
What a shame, this kid, (young owner) is slowly running this company into the ground!
I recently bid on line and won an expensive item from Premier Auction Galleries. When it arrived in the mail, I discovered that almost all of it had damage that was not mentioned in the description and there were also major pieces missing that could not be noticed in the photos like the entire bottom half of a silver enamel box. Basically, this auction company is selling online to buyers who cannot see the items in person and when you try and return it, they refer you to their "small print" which says it is my
Skip Awl
Skip Awl
Jan 07, 2015
Report
I am an online auction bidder who recently dealt with Premier for the first time. It was a great experience in all respects. I will look forward to doing business with them again!
With thanks, Mike from Illinois
Sandra Mendoza
Sandra Mendoza
Aug 19, 2014
Report
Online auction bidder and recently dealt with Premier Auction Galleries LLC. My experience was horrible. The gentleman who delivers my items contacted Jesse Mathews a few days before picking up the furniture and Jesse never answered the calls. Calls were made to his business and no answer. Needless to say, my chairs could not be picked up. I called Jesse Mathews numerous times and he finally answered. Jesse PROMISED he would "look into" shipping my chairs with one of his vendors. Nothing happened. Jesse promised to pay the difference in shipping costs if I scheduled with another delivery company