Nino's NY Pizzeria
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
When you want food in Weedsport, NY, come to Nino's NY Pizzeria! We offer a wide array of traditional cuisine such as Pizza, pasta, sandwiches and much more. We pride ourselves on the excellent service we provide to our customers and our affordable rates. Our food is prepared with the freshest ingredients and our staff is friendly. For great service in Weedsport, NY, call on Nino's NY Pizzeria.
Services
Since 2004, our pizzeria has been providing the highest quality Italian dishes to Weedsport, NY! We are known for our fantastic New York Style Pizza, which we offer in traditional or pan-style. We have a myriad of sandwich options. Grab a sub or turkey sandwich. We also have hot wings made right! Zesty buffalo sauce is mingled in every bite.
Reviews (13)
Albert Taylor
Albert Taylor
Jan 13, 2022
Report
I was just driving through town and found Ninos. Great Deal on the perfect pizza. I will stop again
Matthew Kukiela
Matthew Kukiela
Jan 04, 2022
Report
I dont think 21.42 is a good price for a large pepperoni pizza and a 2 liter when it shows up 30 min late and cold and i only live 5 mins away ill go pick up from some where else from now on
Aternal
Aternal
Dec 23, 2021
Report
For how much money you charge we shouldn’t be getting broken messed up chicken wings.
Cody
Cody
Sep 28, 2021
Report
Just moved nearby and tried this place with recommendation from family, so glad I did! I always get just a plain cheese pizza from a new pizza place because if the place cant do good on a simple pizza there's no way I'm tossing money at something more expensive. cheese pizza from here is GREAT not that it needs to be said! real NY style pizza, large foldable slices, I'm really picky about pizza sauce because I don't like the metallic taste most have and I love this places sauce! and they don't overdo it on sauce to the point the cheese is sliding all off the pizza! staff is usually having a good
Colleen D.
Colleen D.
Sep 17, 2021
Report
We were traveling from Buffalo to Saratoga and were looking for a quick lunch. We were really happy with this choice! 2 slices and 5 garlic knots. PRICES ARE GREAT and service is even better. i recommend ninos to all my fellow travelers
Paul S.
Paul S.
Jul 18, 2021
Report
I had stopped going in or ordering from this place because it went totally down hill for some reason.I figured let me give it a shot its been awhile... I just had the absolute worst pizza I have ever had. I picked it up so it would be hot. I got home and its cold. I turn on the oven, heat it up and it is absolutely disgusting!!! NEVER AGAIN!!!
Emel Kangi
Emel Kangi
Jun 18, 2021
Report
My husband and I ordered charbroiled wings, the philly cheesesteak and baked ziti for delivery. Delivery was fast and correct, and the food arrived hot! The wings were out of this world. They tasted amazing, and they were soft and juicy! The cheesesteaks were huge, lots of fillings. The ziti was great too!
I definitely recommend this place. I’ll be coming back here if I’m ever in the area again.
Brett Burr
Brett Burr
Oct 17, 2020
Report
Best hot charred wings I've ever had. Perfect moisture content, perfect amount of seasoning on the exterior without sacrificing interior flavor. The pizza is good too
Holy Diver
Holy Diver
Jul 13, 2020
Report
2 stars only because employees were courteous and friendly.
Pizza was bland no real taste I did a taste test for the family.
I bought Ragu and shredded cheese and put it on round cardboard and they preferred the cardboard pizza over the Nino's everytime.
Lauren B.
Lauren B.
Jul 15, 2019
Report
We fell in love with Nino's. Unfortunately they are under new management and have gone absolutely down hill. Orders are never correct, take over an hour to make when we're told 30 minutes on the phone and staff is so rude when you tell them your order is wrong.

We have been given the wrong order (another customers) the last two times we have been there

Time to find another spot.
Roberta S.
Roberta S.
Apr 14, 2019
Report
Literally the worse place to eat pizza is nasty and the wings are even worse! Don't go there it's a waste of money!
Justin D.
Justin D.
Mar 08, 2019
Report
Good value, tasty grub. The pizza was good and their house special sauce on the wings was really tasty. Fast delivery.
Larry R.
Larry R.
Jan 19, 2018
Report
Friendly staff. Fast delivery! Hot, fresh pizza...great for folding. Mozzarella sticks equally delicious. Inexpensive also! Pizza is consistent, ordered late March '17 and late August '17.