Fattusco's

Some of my favorite pizza I’ve had anywhere- let alone on Long Island. They make an excellent Neapolitan pie, and I also quite like their Grandma. Specialty pies aren’t often my thing, but the ones I’ve tried have been generally worthwhile. Their Italian entrees are also quite good.

Excellent Value.
Great Food; Superb Value.
No Corkage Fee; leave a Generous Tip to reward their Special Service !!

Always love this place! Last night was even better than usual- and they were slammed right up to (and through) closing time. My husband and I sat down at 7:15 and the waitress, Kaitlyn let us know that closing was 8. We put an app order in and took a few minutes, but decided quickly. She was working so hard- tables full inside and out! There was a minor mistake when our app was brought (sauce on instead of on the side, still delish, just not our preference). Marc (owner) came out to the table immediately, apologized and put a new order in. We ordered one of their amazing cauliflower crust pizzas

Amazing Sicilian pizza, all the food was fantastic, and the staff is top notch!!!
Very friendly kind people!! Highly recommend if you are in the area!

This is our new go to place. Definitely worth the ride for us. Every pizza we’ve tried has been delicious. The rice balls were the best we’ve ever had. Just the right amount of cheese and meat and their sauce is to die for! Everything we have had so far has been delicious. Would definitely recommend.

Have only had pizza here. First time had slice with a meat sauce, was excellent. Today had a plain slice. There marinara sauce was a little loose for me but surprisingly flavorful. Lots of oil but again good quality oil so OK. Nothing fake about these pies.

Great pizza always has delicious food in friendly people behind the counter!! We are here almost every week!!!

What can I not say about this pizzeria?! As a New Yorker, I was amazed at the quality, flavors and varieties of this pizzeria! I am so glad we stopped by for lunch. I ate the Balsamic Chicken slice which was amazing and the garlic knots. My friend had the vodka sauce slice, a Sicilian, and the slice with mozzarella, tomatoes and balsamic vinegar. Everything was excellent! The service was also great. If this place wasn’t an hour and half away from me, I’d visit every day.

What a hidden gem! The food was so delicious and the staff was so sweet! The sauce is fresh and delicious, calamari was tasty and crunchy, my husband said it was the best meatballs he’s had on Long Island (and we’ve been to our share of restaurants lol) I can’t wait for them to expand, we will def be regulars there. They were so kind to my six yr old who was eying some chocolate :) thank you!

Small place with awesome food. Daily specials 11-3pm. Local delivery too. Try the freshly made Focaccia bread and the Calzone, yummy!