Neptune Designs
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Neptune Designs
Located at 301 Duval Street, Neptune Designs is the oldest jeweler in Key West, FL. Featuring custom made in-house designs, and fine jewelry from around the world, Neptune Designs specializes in unique and one of a kind jewelry. With professional jewelers on staff, Neptune Designs provides resizing, appraisals, repairs, cleaning, and custom design services.

Let Neptune Designs make your custom jewelry ideas into a reality. The retail store also stocks a wide selection of gold & silver fine jewelry, along with a collection of ancient coins and treasures, including Atocha artifacts. Specializing in sharing rare finds such as uncut emeralds, collectible coins, and investment-grade jewelry.
Services
We specialize in custom jewelry projects, have an idea, let's collaborate and create your fantasy piece. We work in silver, gold or platinum and can cast or fabricate your design. Neptune Designs is owned and operated by Jay and Carmenza Pfahl. Neptune Designs has been a local establishment in the heart of downtown Key West since 1976.
From custom design to repair of your favorite piece, Neptune designs can help you realize your jewelry dreams. Do you have a family heirloom and are unsure of the value. Neptune Designs can write appraisals for insurance and personal records. Is your favorite piece looking dull or dingy? Our staff can also clean your jewelry and have it looking as good as new.
Reviews (10)
Silvio P.
Silvio P.
Oct 04, 2021
Report
Amazing store with unique pieces and fair prices. Spent some time speaking with Jay while at the store and as a self professed history geek his background and stories are interesting to say the least.
My wife has been looking for a unique piece for me for some time and we found it while on vacation in Key Wet of all places, with a Roman Republic ~90BC Apollo Horse Racing Denarius that was turned into a bracelet. I requested a change in the band to something more "rustic" et voila a beautiful unique bracelet that gets constant compliments.
A very fitting piece for a horse owner/lover and history
Rso
Rso
Jul 29, 2021
Report
Best ever!!! Super trust worthy great selection.. ask for it they will find it..
James Martin
James Martin
Jul 23, 2021
Report
I’ve bought several pieces from Jay and his team. I highly recommend Neptune Designs
Keith & Judi Rhodes
Keith & Judi Rhodes
May 24, 2021
Report
Went shopping there today and spent way too much time asking questions. Then I asked more questions. Big decision for me to spend the money on a silver coin. Jay was very patient and accommodating. Gotta say thanks to the staff. I did finally purchase what I wanted.
Mia Festoso
Mia Festoso
May 18, 2021
Report
They were so friendly and helpful, they fixed my necklace in 5 minutes for a very low price. Super cool selection too, definitely worth checking out!
Jeff Fair
Jeff Fair
Apr 26, 2021
Report
Spent over a year searching for a particular gold charm only to finally find it at Neptune and several versions to choose from! Staff was wonderful!
Cindy B. Swis
Cindy B. Swis
Mar 25, 2021
Report
The staff was nice/friendly and really listened to what we were looking for. Not pushy. I found the perfect Key West piece- souvenir.
Angela Nunez
Angela Nunez
Feb 19, 2021
Report
Absolutely amazing customer service!!! Went in to make my engagement ring a little bigger and they put me at the top of the list they did it then and there. Ended up chatting for about 30 mins and ended up pre ordering a pretty necklace that I saw but didn't have my size so they ordered me a bigger one. I can't wait till it arrives . highly recommend!
Gary Rose
Gary Rose
Nov 14, 2020
Report
Once again, Jay has designed a beautiful piece of custom jewelry for me. He has the uncanny ability to capture in white gold, exactly what I had imagined in my mind. I so greatly appreciate how much attention he pays to detail and creating each unique design.
Jetty & Buoy
Jetty & Buoy
May 31, 2019
Report
Excellent jewelry store with amazing nautical designs! Did fantastic service on my watch too and a few other pieces of jewelry I brought in. Staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. Jay is awesome. If you want an honest shop and beautiful jewelry go to Neptune's!