We are a family owned & operated pizzeria that offers local, fresh, traditional New York-Style pizza and delicious Italian food. Our hand spun pizza dough is made daily on the premises, along with fresh homemade sauces & entrees. Throughout the many years of hard work in this business, we have learned one important value; Treat our guest like our family!
Our small location is limited seating and we strive on take out and delivery. Whether catering an office party for lunch or ordering fresh pizza for your family for dinner, we want to be your go-to Family Pizzeria for any occasion. In our Catering Menu you will find some selections from our regular restaurant menu, available in larger portions.
Our small location is limited seating and we strive on take out and delivery. Whether catering an office party for lunch or ordering fresh pizza for your family for dinner, we want to be your go-to Family Pizzeria for any occasion. In our Catering Menu you will find some selections from our regular restaurant menu, available in larger portions.
Reviews (28)
Jeff Thomason
Jan 29, 2022
Report
I've never gotten beyond (nor a real strong desire to!) their pizza so can't comment on anything else. Not sure what they do, how they do it, but it's my favorite neighborhood pizza place. Everything tastes refreshingly awesome on their "Antonellas Pie". I've had 2 this month and very consistent. Parking and egress at Fairbanks store can be challenging, at evening rush, on a Friday, with 2 Fedex trucks in the way, and the normal lone entitled ID-10-T in an SUV, but worth it... I wouldn't change anything that might upset the atmosphere.
Larry S.
Jan 10, 2022
Report
Dropped in on a Friday night. Sat comfortably outside. Nice glass of chianti while waiting for soup and my chicken parmesan entree. Both were delicious.
They were super busy with takeout orders that night. Those people did a great job from where I was sitting. Speaking of great job so was our server. Very pleasant.
They were super busy with takeout orders that night. Those people did a great job from where I was sitting. Speaking of great job so was our server. Very pleasant.
Farah F.
Jan 04, 2022
Report
I absolutely love this place! I have brought several friends here and every time it is a hit. We normally start off with the garlic knots. The best I've ever had. They make them fresh and the garlic butter is to die for. I could drink that stuff! The baked ziti is yummy and so is their pizza. The Caesar salad is delicious as well. You really can't go wrong here. I've never been disappointed. The quality is consistent and it beats any other pizza place in Orlando.
Andres Avila
Dec 20, 2021
Report
Suzannah Gail Collins
Dec 19, 2021
Report
Katrina M.
Dec 03, 2021
Report
Best Italian food in Orlando! Great for simple pizza on a Friday night, but I've also used them several times for catering with their main dishes and everyone has always raved about their food... especially the tortellini! I'm from up north so finding a good Italian place in Orlando that I'd take my parents is rare but this place does it!
Russell B.
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Absolutely the best pizza & basic red sauce Italian food in FL. I found the place while I was dropping off a fed ex package a few years ago. I found it again a few months ago & gone several times. I am from NY & I know a good NY pizza. This is better then the average NY pizza place by far. The staff is awesome & fast great service.
Taryn Jones
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Jazlyn T.
Nov 09, 2021
Report
We did pick up so I can't speak for the inside. We're vegetarians, so we ordered a veggie calzone, mozzarella sticks, and a tiramisu. The veggie calzone was mainly cheese and lacked veggies we only got mushrooms and a few pieces of spinach. The mozzarella sticks were very good & the mascarpone on the tiramisu tasted very fresh and creamy.
Robert K.
Nov 04, 2021
Report
V. R.
Oct 19, 2021
Report
Sam G.
Sep 17, 2021
Report
I ordered in on this rainy Friday night and my craving for NY Style Pizza and salad was fulfilled ! The crust was thin and crispy and the cheese and toppings were fresh and yummy. I ordered the 10 inch Specialty and a small Greek salad with creamy Italian dressing. I also ordered a lemonade. I'd like to visit in person next time.
*I would've liked the pepperoni to be crispy but the pizza still tasted great!
*I would've liked the pepperoni to be crispy but the pizza still tasted great!
Rebecca S.
Sep 14, 2021
Report
Someone insisted I give this place a try so in we went.
Food:
I ordered what they recommended - Sicilian (cut into pieces) to start and penne vodka for entree which was accompanied by bread and salad. To start the sicilian was nothing special while my Caesar salad was delicious. I wish I had ordered a huge bowl of this! When my penne vodka arrived it looked thick compared to what the dish normally tends to looks like but I decided to give it a try. After all, it's the taste we want, not the look! Well, I wish it had one of two but it had none. It did not taste anything like a true vodka sauce
Food:
I ordered what they recommended - Sicilian (cut into pieces) to start and penne vodka for entree which was accompanied by bread and salad. To start the sicilian was nothing special while my Caesar salad was delicious. I wish I had ordered a huge bowl of this! When my penne vodka arrived it looked thick compared to what the dish normally tends to looks like but I decided to give it a try. After all, it's the taste we want, not the look! Well, I wish it had one of two but it had none. It did not taste anything like a true vodka sauce
Syd Kerr
Sep 04, 2021
Report
Nate Boe
Aug 15, 2021
Report
Emerald Marie
Jul 17, 2021
Report
Brought my grandmother here for a pizza and beer date. Emily was a really great waitress. We ordered a small cheese pizza to share which was delicious. The small caesar salad is well proportioned and very tasty, as were the garlic knots. We will definitely be back to see Emily. (& eggplant parm) 🙂
Michelle G.
Jul 16, 2021
Report
Madison Oetken
Jul 16, 2021
Report
Jonathan L.
Jul 11, 2021
Report
The staff here treated us like a family. A group of 10 walked in and they immediately catered to us, moving tables around so we had a place to eat. They brought us crayons and coloring books- like real, legitimate coloring books, not a piece of paper. They were amazing!! They really take care of their customers and constantly checked to make sure that everyone was okay.
I ordered the small antipasto salad which had a good amount of olive oil dressing on it. Our friends ordered the 10 inch pizza which was like a personal size. We ordered the 14 inch medium pizza that was cut into 6 slices. It was
I ordered the small antipasto salad which had a good amount of olive oil dressing on it. Our friends ordered the 10 inch pizza which was like a personal size. We ordered the 14 inch medium pizza that was cut into 6 slices. It was
Darwin G.
Jul 10, 2021
Report
This is THE NYC pizza slice for Orlando. For NYC, this would compete well. The crust is crispy thin with the proper amount of cheese and sauce. A great slice for NY, and "world class" for Orlando.
A great deal is the lunch special with the "Mambo Combo." A great chicken parm, manicotti, and meatball. All are fantastic with their sauce and broiled with some cheese for texture. The best part is that it's not greasy at all. A dense and delicious meal, but avoids the greasy parts of eating at many pizzeria.
The mozzarella sticks were unimpressive.
Service was unreal amazing
A great deal is the lunch special with the "Mambo Combo." A great chicken parm, manicotti, and meatball. All are fantastic with their sauce and broiled with some cheese for texture. The best part is that it's not greasy at all. A dense and delicious meal, but avoids the greasy parts of eating at many pizzeria.
The mozzarella sticks were unimpressive.
Service was unreal amazing
Autumn S.
Apr 14, 2021
Report
Another stop on our great pizza tour! And this place??? May become a new favorite in our family. My boys (2 and 5) LOVED it here! And the parents did as well. We had seen the amazing reviews on Yelp about this spot and knew we had to try it since we have two VERY pizza obsessed little boys. We all decided to get pizza as our meal but I did find myself gazing at another table's pasta dishes and so that may be my next venture when we visit. I also added a side salad to my order and it was great!
The decor is so cute here and it reminds me of a small pizza joint you might find in NYC. I felt
The decor is so cute here and it reminds me of a small pizza joint you might find in NYC. I felt
Gregory S.
Mar 20, 2021
Report
Teressa Watts
Mar 13, 2021
Report
Joey Florida
Jan 07, 2021
Report
High quality food and people! It is a little too small and hard to get in at certain times, but it's worth it if you do. Delivery business is strong too, so do that if you don't want to wait. Lunch is affordable, dinner a little pricey. Excellent food though, and family owned. Sauce is homemade. Clean and cute. They have improved their little outdoor porch with heating lamps and rain cover for drizzly days.
Francois B.
Oct 04, 2020
Report
This local Italian pizzeria is outstanding! It's a very small family owned restaurant but they make you feel like home. Also important note this restaurant is back open to dine in also.
Staff:
The staff were very caring and often check up on you and are on the top when your drink runs out! This family restaurant is one of the nicest I've been in so far.
Food:
The food is definitely it's out of this world! It's so tasteful and they give you a big portion for the amount you pay for so that's always great!
Staff:
The staff were very caring and often check up on you and are on the top when your drink runs out! This family restaurant is one of the nicest I've been in so far.
Food:
The food is definitely it's out of this world! It's so tasteful and they give you a big portion for the amount you pay for so that's always great!
Craig L.
May 11, 2020
Report
First time in. Yelp proactively told me they were open for pickup and delivery during COVID, so, after looking at the menu and reviews, I decided to give it a try. Ordered pizza, meatballs, garlic knots and cheesecake to pick up. I was able to pre-pay for my food, so that was a plus. They had curbside pickup - another big plus. And finally the pizza. Looks great. Tastes even better!! I asked for well done pie and it was cooked to perfection. Obviously, I can't assess the service. The curbside was quick and easy. Good experience. I will add them to my Italian rotation.
Next day follow
Next day follow
Nancee M.
Apr 25, 2020
Report
This is not my 1st experience with Antonella's but it's my first time carrying out and it wont be the last. I utilized their website to place my order and it went great! If you are not tech savvy you can still call in ahead as well. On our 1st visit we indulged in a pizza and the stromboli but this time around we just wanted the pizza. When we arrived we went over to the curbside carryout podium and waited for the server to come out since the dining room is currently closed. Everyone else waiting for orders kept a respectable distance from each other. We noticed the grocery grab and go
Andi P.
Aug 21, 2019
Report
5 Stars for great delivery pizza that satisfied.
Gotta give Antonella's Pizzeria 5 stars because it hit all the marks. Really great crust, big slices, and tons of cheesy goodness. We ordered a plain cheese with pineapple and a Margarita. The Margarita had large, round, thin-sliced tomato slices on top, which was a nice tough (versus the little soggy cubes most places use).
It was cheaper to call the restaurant and order directly through them instead of Uber Eats and the pizza came hot and timely.
Not a long review because it was a simple order, but I would definitely order from them again
Gotta give Antonella's Pizzeria 5 stars because it hit all the marks. Really great crust, big slices, and tons of cheesy goodness. We ordered a plain cheese with pineapple and a Margarita. The Margarita had large, round, thin-sliced tomato slices on top, which was a nice tough (versus the little soggy cubes most places use).
It was cheaper to call the restaurant and order directly through them instead of Uber Eats and the pizza came hot and timely.
Not a long review because it was a simple order, but I would definitely order from them again
