Since 1996, Mama Mia's Pizzeria has been hand-crafting Orlando's favorite pizza, calzones, Stromboli, wings and so much more. All of our ingredients are individually selected to assure the best and most authentic tasting New York style pizza south of Manhattan! Feel confident knowing we eat here too, which means, we wouldn't serve you anything that we wouldn't serve to our own family.
All of our dough, sauces and dinners are made by hand in small batches on location. Our Pizza and Marinera sauces are homemade with NO Sugar, salt, additives, preservatives or artificial colors. So, break free from the chains (chain restaurants, that is), and give this local pizzeria a try. You are sure to be satisfied.
All of our dough, sauces and dinners are made by hand in small batches on location. Our Pizza and Marinera sauces are homemade with NO Sugar, salt, additives, preservatives or artificial colors. So, break free from the chains (chain restaurants, that is), and give this local pizzeria a try. You are sure to be satisfied.
Reviews (22)
Anthony Robinson
Jan 29, 2022
Report
Carlos Ortiz
Jan 25, 2022
Report
This is not your ordinary basic pizza from Pizza Hut. If you looking for quality pizza this is one of pizzeria you should try. Your pie will be greasy and thin. When you order a large you’re getting a large pie. Only complaint i have is the slices had some flop. I kinda like my pizza well done and crispy. Yes I would order from this restaurant again.
Sarah Cardona
Jan 25, 2022
Report
Wow where do I start with this review... with much excitement to write this review I cannot express how amazing the service and food was! I went in with my husband and we ordered the two slice and drink special which I cannot tell you enough how amazingly priced this deal is ! The pizza was amazing!! And the service I would have to say was one of the best service I have ever had ! Kevin was truly a pleasure and inspiration to talk to! All smiles and laughter me and my husband could sit there and talk all night with him if we could! Not only did we enjoy the food but Kevin told us a little about
Michael Jimenez
Dec 25, 2021
Report
I've eaten a lot of pizza from many different pizza places. All over Florida and even a few spots in NYC. This place is on point with their pizza. Nice thing crust cooked perfect. Just enough sauce but sweet and savory. The cheese is nice and gooey. With just the right amount of toppings on top! So satisfying and delicious! Next time I'm around I'm will make sure to stop here again.
Trystin Chavez
Dec 20, 2021
Report
Amazing little establishment with such a nice atmosphere! I wish I had a hang out like this in high school. The pizza was perfect, their butter garlic dipping sauce is delicious! Their wings were to die for! Must come try! The staff is very friendly as well which is always a plus! Happy we stumbled across this place during our vacation :)
Nathan L.
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Stephanie Lutz
Nov 30, 2021
Report
Chris R.
Oct 20, 2021
Report
Amro H.
Oct 13, 2021
Report
I had driven by this pizzeria multiple times and always told myself "I want to try that place one day". I'm very glad I did. Family owned and run, and typically there is a family member in the restaurant. Everyone for the most part is polite and friendly.
They have a limited menu compared to most pizzerias but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Everything they make tastes pretty damn good especially the meatball sub. They are also open late into the night when other places are closed.
I saw some reviews written stating that the staff members are rude. I remember one time we ordered 2 small stombolis
They have a limited menu compared to most pizzerias but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Everything they make tastes pretty damn good especially the meatball sub. They are also open late into the night when other places are closed.
I saw some reviews written stating that the staff members are rude. I remember one time we ordered 2 small stombolis
Michael Pascuzzi
Aug 14, 2021
Report
Paul Wojcik
Jul 23, 2021
Report
Just recently moved to the area and was looking for an open pizza place in the Belle Isle area. Luckily I found Mama Mia’s. I ordered the meat pizza. It was delicious and $20 for a large. I was tired of the cost of delivery services so I went myself. It was clean a bit retro and charming. Service was superb and friendly. Give Mama Mia’s a call and enjoy a great pizza.
Wanda Lopez
Nov 04, 2020
Report
Stage C.
Jul 01, 2020
Report
Bridget F.
Jun 06, 2020
Report
This is the definition of New York pizza! We are new to the neighborhood and Mama Mia's has been on our list to try ASAP & it did not disappoint. We had a large cheese pizza and a large pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pizza. The crust was super crisp, with a few dough bubbles, yum and perfectly proportioned between sauce and cheese, dreamy! I can't wait to order again and also try other items on the menu. From one experiment, we're sold and don't think we could go wrong with their other options!
Aline-Alice R.
Feb 15, 2020
Report
Alex V.
Jan 16, 2020
Report
Drea S.
Oct 31, 2019
Report
Decent pizza for a decent price.
The pizza is a thin NY style pizza (fold).
The sauce is good and they are generous when you ask for extra cheese.
We ordered delivery and it took 1 hour although we live 6 minutes away so we only do take out.
Good deal $11.99 for a large two topping so four stars for the value but minus a star for delivery. It's now our go to spot for pizza.
The pizza is a thin NY style pizza (fold).
The sauce is good and they are generous when you ask for extra cheese.
We ordered delivery and it took 1 hour although we live 6 minutes away so we only do take out.
Good deal $11.99 for a large two topping so four stars for the value but minus a star for delivery. It's now our go to spot for pizza.
Paul H.
Oct 27, 2019
Report
Sasha R.
Sep 14, 2019
Report
Emmanuel R.
Apr 11, 2019
Report
Danny S.
Feb 26, 2019
Report
This place has the best wings. They are also really inexpensive . 20 for $15.99 can't beat it. Seriously my whole office asks where I got them makes the whole place smell amazing. The wings are made really well. No trans fats.
Pizza is amazing as well. 2 topping 16 inch for $12. Lunch special is 2 slices and a drink for $4.99
Mama Mia is a very talented cook and the joint is truly family owned and operated. This place is a local treasure
Pizza is amazing as well. 2 topping 16 inch for $12. Lunch special is 2 slices and a drink for $4.99
Mama Mia is a very talented cook and the joint is truly family owned and operated. This place is a local treasure
Cassi M.
Aug 01, 2016
Report
Visiting family down here and in a hotel for the weekend. After running around all day and it being late night, delivery is not always available. I called and asked if they delivered to our hotel and they did. So happy to not have to go out and get anything.
We ordered a large pepperoni and a 10 piece hot wing with a 2 liter. All together with tip only cost $35, which was not bad for all the food. The large is HUGE, so I'm sure their XL is enormous. The wings were good and hot. The pizza is really good amd cheesy. Will definately order again when we come back to visit family next
We ordered a large pepperoni and a 10 piece hot wing with a 2 liter. All together with tip only cost $35, which was not bad for all the food. The large is HUGE, so I'm sure their XL is enormous. The wings were good and hot. The pizza is really good amd cheesy. Will definately order again when we come back to visit family next
