We offer an extensive menu featuring a wide assortment of food for the entire family at an affordable price. We take pride in our food being made with top-quality ingredients and served to our customers with a smile. Petey's Eatey's is located in Nazareth, PA and has been serving the heart of the Lehigh Valley with great food since 2009.
Come in today! All of our menu items are freshly made as soon as you order from us. If you do not see it on our menu, and we have the ingredients, just ask and we will make it for you. We love to hear our customer's ideas and creations that way we can give you exactly what you want. We have a large array of breakfast, lunch, and dinner menu items made with fresh and quality ingredients and sold at a great price.
Come in today! All of our menu items are freshly made as soon as you order from us. If you do not see it on our menu, and we have the ingredients, just ask and we will make it for you. We love to hear our customer's ideas and creations that way we can give you exactly what you want. We have a large array of breakfast, lunch, and dinner menu items made with fresh and quality ingredients and sold at a great price.
Services
Our Petey sure loved to eat. So we decided to keep his memory alive by naming our food establishment and many menu items in his honor. We pride ourselves on being family-owned and find joy in feeding the people in our community and beyond. So, from our family to yours, we would like to thank you for letting us fill your belly.
Fresh made assorted Breakfast Sandwiches available warm and ready to go for those on the run. There are Fresh made Hoagies, Salads and Sandwiches in the cooler for your convenience as well. The Deli sells Boar's Head Meats and Cheeses by the pound as well as homemade salads such as Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, Pasta Salad, Potato Salad, Coleslaw, and Pickled Eggs.
Reviews (27)
John Plante
Jan 27, 2022
Report
Chloe Doman
Jan 08, 2022
Report
P. C.
Dec 08, 2021
Report
WOW - DON'T order hot peppers on steak sandwich unless you want your mouth on fire - they put jalepeno peppers on. And no sauce could be seen. Threw in the garbage because impossible to pick all the peppers out and very unpleasant to eat.
This place used to be great - way downhill now. Won't order again.
This place used to be great - way downhill now. Won't order again.
Herm L.
Nov 06, 2021
Report
Thomas Vincent
Oct 19, 2021
Report
K. C.
Oct 14, 2021
Report
Steve Brad
Sep 21, 2021
Report
Tom Payne
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Place has gone downhill drastically. Waited at the pickup window after the time frame given after I placed the order, for over 15 minutes. Within that time, several people who had placed their orders in person had gotten their food. All I recieved for waiting at the window so patiently was the girl yelling in my face that someone elses number order was ready, before she closed the window and neither greeted ne or asked me what my order was. Such a shame because I used to love this place when I was growing up, up until about 2 years ago when I left the area.
Chris Cannata
Sep 17, 2021
Report
Although I have been there many times and love their food, their service has been going steadily down hill. I placed an order last night and was told 30 minutes. Thats fine because it is worth the wait. An hour and 10 minutes later they finally get my order out after realizing they didnt make half of it. I was barely offered any type of compensation.
Steve Gsxrmil
Sep 03, 2021
Report
Todd K.
Sep 01, 2021
Report
Young kids not knowing that steak sandwiches get sause, who eats a dry steak sandwich? The place has changed, the amount of steak meat filled the roll in the past but not now. The past year the amount of meat is less and less every time, in fact I took a fork and pushed the meat from one half to the other and made a normal looking steak sandwich. 50% less meat, rip off.
Trinity Boudreau
Aug 21, 2021
Report
Tyler S.
Jul 19, 2021
Report
Food was good but there was about 7 or 8 people working and we stood in line waiting to have our order taken for almost 10 mins. Not to mention it took over a half hour before we got our food while 3 people that were there who ordered after us got their food first. The girl said that it was almost ready, which it was about 5 mins after she told us that. The kicker is.. our food was sitting on the finished food tray for a good 10 mins before they packed it up after she told us that.they were all to busy joking around that they were oblivious to what was going on around them . I don't even know
Stephanie M.
Jul 06, 2021
Report
Linda Sokel
May 14, 2021
Report
Had a great light lunch, tuna salad, and the blueberry milkshake was delicious on a hot day. Menu had a nice variety, staff was very friendly and prices were very reasonable. Enjoyed eating at the outside tables. For a small place, the customers just kept coming and everyone said how good all their food was. Next time I'm in the area, I will stop here to eat again.
Steven P.
Apr 09, 2021
Report
Brayden R.
Dec 19, 2020
Report
Stephan S.
Sep 12, 2020
Report
My, my, my, who would think , a small eatery , next to a gas station would produce such a fantastic array of sandwiches ? I have ordered from here several times . The steak sandwiches are very good,the Ribeye sandwich is excellent , it's the very fresh rolls , that brings it all together .The milkshakes , always very cold . On a hot day ,when you don't feel like cooking , give this place a chance , you won't go wrong
Emalia W.
Aug 02, 2020
Report
J. P.
Jun 28, 2020
Report
Christine S.
Mar 03, 2020
Report
Ordered from door dash so I've never actually been here. I got a chicken Cesar salad and a cheese steak. I was disappointed in the salad. First, no one puts onions on a Cesar salad. Second, the chicken was unseasoned. Third, I was given a packet of Cesar dressing. Who doesn't know how to make Cesar dressing? It's 3 ingredients! And you mix it in the lettuce! I unfortunately got sick after I ate this meal. I felt awful for the rest of the day. I'm hoping it was just the salad/chicken and not my remaining cheese steak that is in the fridge for lunch today...
Amy B.
Nov 21, 2019
Report
I don't know why this doesn't have better reviews. The food has always been top notch-and the prices are very reasonable. The trick is to call your orders in ahead of time especially during busy hours such as lunch or dinner. We have had a wide variety of items from the menu & never been disappointed. They will generally also make something special request if they have the items needed to do so
Jodi D.
Jun 06, 2019
Report
This place is a Disaster. Malfunctioning gas pump. The parking is horrible. The the staff is rude. Peteys staff is under educated trash with hostile temperament. Obviously these people work here for a reason. That's not my fault.
I will report the leaky malfunction gas pump to PA DEP.
I paid for gas 6/5/19 went to my pump, picked up the gas nozzle and it began to spray gas all over me and my car. The handle on the pump was damaged and jammed I couldn't get it to stop. It finally stopped and I went inside to tell the cashier. I asked him to put my gas on another pump that was not malfunctioning
I will report the leaky malfunction gas pump to PA DEP.
I paid for gas 6/5/19 went to my pump, picked up the gas nozzle and it began to spray gas all over me and my car. The handle on the pump was damaged and jammed I couldn't get it to stop. It finally stopped and I went inside to tell the cashier. I asked him to put my gas on another pump that was not malfunctioning
Bear B.
Feb 17, 2019
Report
Great breakfast sandwiches. Convenient to Rt33 ez on/off. Call ahead for pick up. I had Peteys favorite western omelette with bacon on a Kaiser roll. They had Cheerios inside the convienence store for my child. Too early in the morning for ice cream, so we will get that next time. Good place to Gas up and get your feed. #supportsmallandlocalbusines's.
Lisa Y.
Oct 12, 2017
Report
Erin C.
Oct 25, 2016
Report
My go-to take out place for amazing cheesesteaks, wraps, breakfast sandwiches and ice cream! It's always busy so call ahead.
Portion sizes are excellent for the price. You will be hard pressed to find a better cheesesteak this side of the turnpike!
My favorites are the cheesesteak hoagie (fried onions, not raw, and lots of mayo) and the chicken bacon ranch wrap. It is delicious and big enough to share! Mozzarella sticks, onion rings and pierogies are always perfect too.
Portion sizes are excellent for the price. You will be hard pressed to find a better cheesesteak this side of the turnpike!
My favorites are the cheesesteak hoagie (fried onions, not raw, and lots of mayo) and the chicken bacon ranch wrap. It is delicious and big enough to share! Mozzarella sticks, onion rings and pierogies are always perfect too.
Nicole W.
Aug 22, 2016
Report
My husband has been telling me about this place. He's from PA I'm a Staten islander .. Now that we're making the move to PA together we're constantly driving back and forth so today we finally stop at petey's and omg I regret not coming here when he first mentioned them! I got the Cali burger on a whole wheat wrap he got a buffalo chicken wrap and they were amazing. Milkshakes and pierogies also! I told him We need to try everything on this menu which he probably already has! But I def recommend it! For the price and serving size It's crazy
