Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters & Cafe
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Michelle and James collectively have 20 years of restaurant experience under their belts before they even met. From childhood Michelle loved watching the classic PBS cooking shows like Julia Child and always dreamed of opening a restaurant. As a child, James spent countless hours in the kitchen with his Sicilian grandmother, mom, and dad; Sundays were filled with making big family dinners.

So when they started their life together and Michelle presented the idea of opening a restaurant the idea came to fruition in a very natural way. After falling in love with the town, and the Water Street Market, they decided to take the plunge and signed a lease on the spot. Since then, they have added three amazing kids to the mix, all the while serving thousands of happy customers and creating a place that feels like home.
Reviews (7)
Jerry Pantano
Jerry Pantano
Jan 27, 2022
Report
Good food good Coffee great people to be with. It is a must go to in New Paltz.
Oleg Laptenko
Oleg Laptenko
Dec 23, 2021
Report
Very tasty food! Friendly service. Great atmosphere. One of my favorite places to have a cup of morning coffee.
Rev Dele
Rev Dele
Nov 20, 2021
Report
While I miss the indoor eating area, this place is still customer friendly and the small outdoor tables support cozy experiences. I enjoy the wide variety of teas
Kayla B.
Kayla B.
Nov 15, 2021
Report
Great service! Staff is very friendly! I had a salted caramel mocha and it was the best latte I have ever had.
Katy Halpern
Katy Halpern
Nov 04, 2021
Report
This is a super cute indie coffee shop in a great, scenic location. We grabbed two cups to go while we were walking around. Lots of outdoor seating if you wanted to sit and chat.
Christine Conetta
Christine Conetta
Oct 14, 2021
Report
The coffee is solid and the breakfast sandwiches are a reasonable size. One of the best coffee shops in New Paltz!
G.
G.
Oct 28, 2019
Report
Had an Italian Panini with Chicken. Definitely left an impression. I was amazed at the assortment of teas and in-house cofre roasting. This place is great!