Responsive Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Responsive Insurance
Responsive Insurance is owned and operated by Matt Nance. His experience in the insurance industry has taught him that clients want to feel valued enough to receive a call back, an answer to their question, a response. At Responsive Insurance, Inc, our belief is that along with the right insurance coverage you deserve a timely and complete response to your questions, concerns and requests.

We are committed to leveraging our skills, experience and resources to earn our clients' business. We will do this by providing you relevant information, the knowledge you require and options that meet your needs. Responsive Insurance is an independent insurance agency - meaning we do business with multiple insurance companies and compare protection.
Services
Matt established Responsive Insurance in January of 2013. He was born in 1981 in Mount Vernon, Indiana. Matt moved to Naples in 2006 and began working at a local Naples Allstate agency. He is married to Casey since 2009 and they recently adopted two girls that they had been foster parents for the past 3 years.
Not all insurance agents are the same! Choosing the right one can make a big difference - not just in price but also in service, proper need assessment, coverage and value. Responsive Insurance is an independent insurance agency - meaning we do business with multiple insurance companies and compare protection and prices to find the best value for you.
The right auto insurance policy can help get you back on the road quickly if your car is damaged or destroyed by accident, fire, theft, or other covered event. Your policy may also provide protection against medical and legal expenses resulting from injury, loss of life, or property damage caused by an accident involving your vehicle.
Responsive Insurance can help make your time on the water relaxed and worry-free! We will find you comprehensive protection that protects you, your friends and family, your watercraft and your boating equipment. You'll enjoy being on the water even more when you aren't worried about your safety, the safety of your passengers, or your investment.
Not all classic or antique cars are used the same, so Responsive Insurance will work with you to select the appropriate policy to accommodate coverage needs, miles driven, vehicle age, and vehicle modifications to make sure you have the best policy to meet your needs. Agreed Value: This means the provider will pay you the full (agreed to) amount in the event of a covered total loss, less any applicable deductible.
Reviews (10)
Anthonyandmary Mcgrath
Anthonyandmary Mcgrath
Dec 12, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness, Value
Contacted Mat for a quote and he really help walk us through the options that were available in the complex world of insurance these days help us obtain the best value for money from the right carrier with no B/S. Highly recommended.
John Boatright
John Boatright
Jul 28, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Very professional and knowledgeable team to handle all your insurance needs. Customer oriented!
Patricia Kinsey
Patricia Kinsey
Oct 03, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Matt provided the highest level of service. He was very responsive, answering all my questions and provided a policy that was comprehensive and competitive. I could not have been more pleased. I highly recommend!
Joseph Heavey
Joseph Heavey
Sep 26, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Responsive Insurance has been great in meeting all my insurance needs—cars, home, “umbrella”, etc. The team of Matt, Rich & Judy have been superb in offering alternatives in the most informative, competitive, courteous, professional manner!
Joseph Hoener
Joseph Hoener
Aug 29, 2020
Report
Matt and his team go well above and beyond to make sure your insurance fits your needs, and is the most cost effective as well. Judy is our " angel" who makes sure we are up to date on all our policies. I cannot recommend this firm enough. They really give personalized service. Rare today.
Larry Pronovost
Larry Pronovost
Jan 04, 2020
Report
I had been carrying the same car insurance and home owners insurance for years, automatically renewing each term or year as the case may be, feeling all was good and rates acceptable. But, I decided to have Matt review my policies to see if the coverage was acceptable and the rates as competitive as I thought. This included the General Liability and Workers Comp coverage I needed for my business. In short, Matt reviewed my policies, advised me where there may be shortcomings in my home owners policy and lack of reasonable coverage in my auto policy. He made recommendations in a clear and concise
Chrisandyvette
Chrisandyvette
Nov 09, 2019
Report
I have to finally write a review for this great local company. We have used Matt for many years and we would highly recommend that anyone at least give him the chance to bid your insurance. If he cannot do better than what you currently have for a particular line of insurance he will just politely tell you, so you have nothing to lose by sitting down and discussing your insurance needs with him. He is very knowledgeable, professional and polite. He always takes the time to answer all of our questions. I just can't imagine that you would not be happy with the hands on, local service you will get
Suzanne Saletan
Suzanne Saletan
Sep 25, 2019
Report
Insurance has always been confusing for me ( I am a widow).In late August I needed to secure a new home policy.. Matt was beyond helpful.. He explained everything in detail and just took his time and answered all my questions.. Not only did I get a great home insurance policy, I now really understand everything...No one ever took the time before..Great experience and I highly recommend them..
Lauren Connors
Lauren Connors
Jun 02, 2019
Report
Matt Nance, owner of Responsive Insurance Inc, is the best insurance agent my husband and I have ever worked with. He reviewed all of our current insurance policies; including home, auto, flood and umbrella policies, and provided excellent recommendations for modifications to existing policies and better insurance provider options where appropriate. Matt is extremely knowledgeable, consciences and was very patient with our questions and concerns. I recommend Responsive Insurance Inc without question to anyone needing help with Insurance Coverage in Florida.
Stan Busman
Stan Busman
May 16, 2019
Report
Just had a great experience with Judy at Responsive Insurance, who took care of us with auto, motorcycle, and umbrella policies. Judy is a wealth of knowledge and so easy and accommodating to work with. Having worked in the claims end of insurance for several years, she has a broad breadth of experience working in the insurance industry. She was so thorough going over the policies with us. We highly recommend!