We are a family-owned and -operated business that offers New York traditions fused with Mexican and Southwestern flavor. We have established a reputation for providing high-quality food, excellent customer service, and speedy delivery to customers in the Arcadia area. We can promise satisfaction because all of our dishes are freshly prepared every day with premium ingredients.
At My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we are where New York meets the Southwest. When I want pizza, this is my go-to spot! I just discovered this place a couple months ago, and we have now been coming here weekly. The pizza and wings are amazing, both have delicious sauces. I definitely recommend this place!
At My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we are where New York meets the Southwest. When I want pizza, this is my go-to spot! I just discovered this place a couple months ago, and we have now been coming here weekly. The pizza and wings are amazing, both have delicious sauces. I definitely recommend this place!
Services
Let's be frank: You will probably want more than just one slice when you go to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, a quirky Arcadia pizza joint that marries New York pizza-making traditions with Southwest-inspired flavors. But if you're looking to whet your appetite with just a slice or two, the restaurant offers pizza by the slice daily.
My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we're passionate about pizza and trying new flavors. In fact, our owner, Phoenix native and Camelback High School graduate, Randy Bortin, put everything on the line, including selling his house to deliver you his unique vision of Southwestern style pizza and authentic New York style pizza at family-friendly prices here in Phoenix, AZ.
Reviews (9)
Bj Patel
Jan 20, 2022
Report
I have such a Divine altitude of gratitude, appreciation and love for everyone down there, at my slice of the pie, as it is a team effort that makes those pizzas the best pizzas you’ll ever have. And Randy, thank you for existing and for creating such a beautiful atmosphere and place for us all to embrace. You are a legend and your legacy will live on forever! Thank you!! Much love & gratitude to you all. The world wouldn’t be the same without folks!
Daniel Fern
Jan 10, 2022
Report
Yesterday I ordered over $100 of food on-line, including Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie. When your staff was packing my order to go, I was informed that there was no Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie available. Someone from the back said that they would remove it from our charge. I received an email with the receipt and the item was not removed from our bill.
I have been to your restaurant on several occasions, and have always had a good experience.
I was very disappointed in the lack of follow-through.
I have been to your restaurant on several occasions, and have always had a good experience.
I was very disappointed in the lack of follow-through.
Mister Bee
Dec 31, 2021
Report
We were excited to try this pizza after reading the positive reviews and menu of specialty pizzas.
Both pizzas had dry, chewy crust that wasn’t crisp at all and the ingredients were not as we expected of lesser quality.
The mole style pizza tasted pretty good but the el blanco was horrible.
Won’t be back.
Both pizzas had dry, chewy crust that wasn’t crisp at all and the ingredients were not as we expected of lesser quality.
The mole style pizza tasted pretty good but the el blanco was horrible.
Won’t be back.
Henny Cx
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Crust: thin and crunchy, definitely my favorite kind of crust
Flavor: Bomb! Full of flavor and fresh ingredients
Service: 5 star service, they pay attention to details and they really care about their customers
Honestly coming from MA to AZ its been very hard finding a really good pizza shop. This place has it all and will now be my go to spot even after trying it one time! Everything about my pizza was spot on so please go try it!!!!
Flavor: Bomb! Full of flavor and fresh ingredients
Service: 5 star service, they pay attention to details and they really care about their customers
Honestly coming from MA to AZ its been very hard finding a really good pizza shop. This place has it all and will now be my go to spot even after trying it one time! Everything about my pizza was spot on so please go try it!!!!
Matthew Starcher
Oct 24, 2021
Report
Albert David Guillen
Aug 16, 2021
Report
McCall Knutson
May 16, 2021
Report
Nice local place. I love the elongated table with the built in checker board and the detailed mural on the wall, it's an awesome vibe.. but what really shocked me was the menu!! Homemade wing sauces, carne asada pizza, elote flatbread, I couldn't decide what to get! Everything hand crafted and unique. I'm definitely coming back to try it all! And Daniel is amazing! Customer service on point
Victor Mann
Oct 18, 2020
Report
Enjoyed slices at " My Slice of Pie Pizzeria", a friendly litte restaurant offering Traditional NY Style, Southwestern Style, and Gluten Free pizza. They also have salads, toasted sandwiches, wings with 5 different sauce choices & more. Now to the pizza-- It's really good! We had the cheese, Italian sausage , and our favorite, a specialty slice, if " You Gotta Carne Asada". A must try. I love a thin crust slice of pizza that you can hold out and it doesn't collapse, it was crispy and good. Please support our local businesses.
Kayla Dreska
Aug 30, 2020
Report
