P is for Pie Bake Shop is a boutique artisan bakery. We specialize in small batch sweet and savory pies and variations of pies offering a modern twist on classic American desserts and savory delights. Everything is made from scratch by hand incorporating natural, seasonal and local ingredients to every extent possible. Owners, Stacey and Ed, have had a passion for baking and cooking since they can remember. They appreciate intertwining flavors to make deliciously unique combinations while staying true to the classics.
Reviews (18)
Robin Denton
Jan 12, 2022
Report
A hidden gem. Everything that I have tried here is amazing. The care that goes into every item is noted with each bite. The owner, Stacey knows what she is doing and the customer service is second to none. The tomato pie was incredible, better than my moms and her bread puddings are incredible. A must stop location when driving down Corrine.
Patrick B. Davidson
Jan 10, 2022
Report
Hands down my wife and I’s favorite bakery. Not only are their sweets, tarts, and especially pies delicious… but their breakfast sandwiches and lunch offerings are savory and mouthwatering. Quite possibly the… best BLT I’ve eaten in my life… so much so, that my wife (who doesn’t dig on BLTs like 90 percent of the time) tried mine, ordered one of her own- and now we go back sometime specifically just for that BLT. If you can convert her… you can convert anyone! :) It was so good my wife had to say something to the chef/owners the first time she had one
Vanessa Gray
Dec 20, 2021
Report
Nelly Thom
Dec 03, 2021
Report
This place is absolutely AMAZING!!! My friend and I stopped here this afternoon and had the hey turkey and the Boca. They were both amazing! The quality of food was amazing and the prices were too :) the people working there were amazing too, genuinely so sweet! The cinnamon roll was also so sweet I'm obsessed with the spread they include with it! We can't wait to visit again soon!
The picture is of the boca ! There's two halves of the sandwich but I ate one before taking the photo
The picture is of the boca ! There's two halves of the sandwich but I ate one before taking the photo
Charlie Redmond
Nov 28, 2021
Report
P is for Pie is literally the best place for food in all of Orlando. If I could visit every day, I would. My only complaint (and it's not really a complaint, it's just me complaining) is that they aren't close to me but I would drive literal hours to get sweets from here.
A few of my favorites are the cinnie bread pudding, the sweet potato hand casserole pie, and the buffalo chicken hand pie.
If you're visiting Orlando or looking for a new place to visit, you must go here!
PS. Also, the entire staff is the most friendly bunch of people you'll ever meet. Everything about this place is perfect
A few of my favorites are the cinnie bread pudding, the sweet potato hand casserole pie, and the buffalo chicken hand pie.
If you're visiting Orlando or looking for a new place to visit, you must go here!
PS. Also, the entire staff is the most friendly bunch of people you'll ever meet. Everything about this place is perfect
Rosie Estes
Nov 15, 2021
Report
Gladys Storms-Fairley
Sep 26, 2021
Report
We have enjoyed this place several times in the last year and every time the food is AWESOME ..WE LOVE THEM . Great preorder by phone system for pickup . Great fresh Farm to Table food . We have enjoyed the… slab pies ..Large portions Mini Pies and Mini Jars Great Sample / Mini Portions Cookies Donuts Cimmies(Cinnamon Rolls ) Large portion Large Slices of Speciality Cake on Saturdays and OMG ...THE BEST BREAD PUDDING ...LOVE LOVE LOVE IT ....GREAT FRIENDLY SERVICE ALWAYS ! SPOKE W/ OWNER REGARDING A SPECIALITY CAKE I MISSED ON PREVIOUS SAT AND SHE HAD IT PLACED ON THE MENU THE FOLLOWING
Eleanor Elle Davis
Sep 10, 2021
Report
Carlos Castro
Aug 22, 2021
Report
Beatrice Miranda
Aug 21, 2021
Report
Crystal Clarke
Jul 22, 2021
Report
Diane White Mealo
Jul 14, 2021
Report
If you want a whole pie, order ahead or arrive early in the day. Today’s impromptu visit did not disappoint. I made a last minute decision to head here first before visiting Leu Gardens. Was looking for… dessert to go with dinner tonight and a quick savory bite to satisfy my lunch craving. Decided on the BBQ Jack Fruit hand pie warmed for lunch and it was off the chart. The crust was baked to perfection and the filling a moist and flavorful combination of “pulled” jack fruit, roasted vegetables, in a sweet and savory BBQ sauce. It held together nicely down to the last bite
Bernie Anderson
Mar 26, 2021
Report
Eddy Prieto
Mar 13, 2021
Report
This place deserves a ten! This is just two of my favorite breakfast items. Their pies are AMAZING!
My husband and I visit once a week and we have yet to try one item we dislike. Their chocolate bourbon pecan is my favorite. With the key lime being a very close second. If you are in the area, stop by, it’s a must. You won’t be disappointed.
The staff are truly hard workers. Thank you guys
My husband and I visit once a week and we have yet to try one item we dislike. Their chocolate bourbon pecan is my favorite. With the key lime being a very close second. If you are in the area, stop by, it’s a must. You won’t be disappointed.
The staff are truly hard workers. Thank you guys
Mee Mee Ah
Dec 30, 2020
Report
Rv Travel Adventures
Nov 14, 2020
Report
Tom Grealy
Oct 02, 2020
Report
Kari Klein
Sep 12, 2020
Report
One of my favorite places in Orlando! I called to place a pickup order (can not recommend doing that enough, especially on a weekend). The staff was courteous and helpful - even the other patrons (who lined up… outside, socially distanced and wearing masks - yay!) were in good spirits. My order was packed up and ready to go when I arrived. The pies are first rate and SO flavorful - this was my first time also ordering breakfast (why haven’t I done this sooner?!?) My “lil piggy” was anything but “lil” - omg it’s HUGE and probably the best breakfast sandwich