Sheeley Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Sheeley Insurance Agency
At Sheeley Insurance Agency, we specialize in home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance and day care center insurance throughout Pennsylvania. Insurance throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties. Sheeley Insurance Agency offers personal insurance and business insurance throughout Pennsylvania.

We are an independent insurance agency, locally owned and operated since 1933, serving the individuals and businesses throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties. We offer personal and business insurance solutions, with our specialties in home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance and day care center insurance.
Services
Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Sheeley Insurance Agency, we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most in business and in life. Sheeley Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency made up of exceptional, passionate people focused on protecting you from the unexpected.
Life can be unpredictable. You can count on us to be there for you, ensuring things happen promptly and efficiently, always with the goal of getting your life and business back to normal as quickly as possible.

Sheeley Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency offering a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions to protect you from the unexpected throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties.
A company is only as good as the people behind it. We are always interested in meeting talented individuals who want to progress their careers and make a difference to our business. We believe that successful people make successful businesses, which is why we make every effort to provide our employees with an environment in which they can excel.
We are an independent insurance agency throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties. Insurance can be a complicated purchase that requires more than 15 minutes of your time. As an independent insurance agency we work for you, not the insurance company - giving you the power of choice.
Choosing the right insurance can be complicated. We partner with the industry's leading insurance companies so you can enjoy the most appropriate, affordable protection. Even better, we help you make the right choice. Sheeley Insurance Agency has access to leading insurance company partners, ensuring we can find the right insurance coverage for your needs.
Reviews (13)
Christian Busutil
Christian Busutil
Oct 30, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness, Value
Sarah was so helpful during the whole process of getting my business insured. I highly reccomend using Sheeley for all your insurance needs. Be sure to ask for Sarah!!
Wayne Riddlehoover
Wayne Riddlehoover
Jul 16, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness, Value
Everyone gives me excellent customer service. Anything I need, they take care of it right away, every day.
Office Dunkin
Office Dunkin
Jul 04, 2020
Report
Ken is phenomenal, great addition to our company bringing you guys on-it has been seamless and simple.
Linda Amoroso
Office Manager
Rhonda Tiernan
Rhonda Tiernan
May 21, 2020
Report
We are a small local business and have used Sheeley Insurance for the past twenty-five plus years and are very pleased with the service we receive. Chris and his staff are professional, friendly, knowledgeable and quick to respond to any business needs or questions you may have. I highly recommend them. Miller-Tiernan Service Co. Inc. Heat and A/C East Stroudsburg
Adrienne Mauro Primrose
Adrienne Mauro Primrose
Dec 06, 2019
Report
We work with Ken Parrish for our business insurance. He has always made himself available to answer any question or concern we have had. He is amazing at following up and checking in. Today I made one phone call to him about homeowners and sure enough I had the answers and insurance set for closing. I recommend Sheeley and definitely Ken to everyone for both commercial and residential insurance. Ken thanks for always being there and on top of things! You’re the best!!!
Rob Bishop
Rob Bishop
Oct 31, 2019
Report
The one thing that stands out most is the personal attention. Years ago, when we needed to file a claim about a burst pipe, our agent met with us personally and walked us through every step, and made sure we got the funds we needed for repairs. I couldn't imagine dealing with an agency that was in another state or only available by phone or online.
Sarah Kroski
Sarah Kroski
Sep 18, 2019
Report
They have Always been there for me Year After Year Rose and Jim had been just wonderful...been through a lot and they have Always walked us through it All... I would Highly Recommend Sheeley Insurance
Carolyn Vallese
Carolyn Vallese
Aug 22, 2019
Report
Great agency. Very responsive. They did all the leg work, comparing and presenting rates, and were quick to secure the insurance and documents I needed in a very timely manner. Very friendly, and professional. I would highly recommend them.
Philip Pritchard
Philip Pritchard
Aug 20, 2019
Report
John was very responsive in helping renegotiate our house insurance, and save us money with the same or better coverage. We didn't have to pursue him at all to have him come out and reassess the property in an efficient, polite and professional manner.
Roger M.
Roger M.
Jun 26, 2019
Report
I've had the pleasure of dealing with Sheeley Insurance for a number of years for my home and auto policies. My agent Stephanie Smith is responsive, knowledgeable, extremely professional and pleasant to deal with. I highly recommened using them for all your insurance needs.
Stephanie Burke
Stephanie Burke
Jun 11, 2019
Report
Our agent is always available when we have questions or need new services. It's great to have someone who gets back to you right away.
Robert Baisley
Robert Baisley
Dec 08, 2018
Report
Sheeley was patient and helped us find the best rate for a multiple policy!
Steve Heberling
Steve Heberling
Nov 25, 2016
Report
Chris and his staff are first rate! Friendly, knowledgeable and efficient, they are a true professionals. I always feel like I am their most important client. I can't imagine working with anyone else.