Villa Maria
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Villa Maria
Proudly serving Bethpage and Levittown, New York with pizza, pastas, and fine Italian food since 2013! Villa Maria is Bethpage's answer to fine Italian cuisine. Owned and operated by Chef Michael Goldsborough, a former NYC Executive Chef and Culinary Institute of America graduate, Villa Maria offers fine Italian food, prepared from scratch using only the freshest, hand-picked ingredients available, and cooked to perfection.

Italian food and culture go hand in hand which is why Villa Maria will make you feel right at home. The menus at Villa Maria have been hand crafted to satisfy the most delectable palate. Whether you prefer to dine in, take out or take advantage of our catering services you will be taken care of by only the best.
Reviews (24)
Raven M.
Raven M.
Jan 15, 2022
Report
My only regret is that I didn't order from them right when we moved to the neighborhood! The food is so delicious! They offer great specials and everything we have ordered has been yummy and large portions! The garlic knots are so good! And the pizza crust is crunchy and delish! This pizzeria is by far the best we've had since moving to the area in 2019. It has become a weekly go-to for us! Totally recommend!
Sheri Rosen
Sheri Rosen
Dec 31, 2021
Report
Picked up a chicken roll with very little chicken in it. Husband said it was not good. Please make sure the customer is getting the food that they paid for. Now he does not want to order from you again.
Anil Gupta
Anil Gupta
Sep 25, 2021
Report
Well received. Took care of our diet needs. Quality food. Personal Attention. Tasty food
Jarrett Krupp
Jarrett Krupp
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Picked up a pie with meatballs & it was excellent! The gentleman who answered the call on my order was friendly & courteous. This is the way a classic pizzeria should be. Was my first time at Villa Maria's but definitely won't be my last. Well worth making the trip from East Meadow!
Lady Of Winterfell
Lady Of Winterfell
Jun 17, 2021
Report
Ordered delivery through slice received a burnt pizza underneath was black the garlic knots were soaked with grease. I’m very disappointed ordered because my friend recommended it. Won’t order here again
Carolyn Rizzo
Carolyn Rizzo
Mar 29, 2021
Report
The food at Villa Maria is absolutely DELICIOUS! I drive 40 minutes to pick up and another to drive back and it’s so worth it. The entrees are the highest quality and they give healthy portions! My favorite Italian spot on Long Island, hands down!
Bruce Garelick
Bruce Garelick
Dec 30, 2020
Report
We have eaten at Villa Maria before but today was extremely disappointing. We ordered 2 different pizzas over the phone, a regular and an everything pie which we picked up. When we arrived, we waited for pizzas to come out of oven. After taking it home, we were very disappointed with the taste and the way it was cooked. The pies were totally undercooked. No char marks on the under carriage of the pies. The dough and toppings on the everything pie were cold and the mozzarella cheese was not even melted. We expected much better then what we received.
Eric S.
Eric S.
Dec 27, 2020
Report
We did the Christmas Eve special. The food was delicious and plentiful. I couldn't be happier. Great place
Joe G.
Joe G.
Oct 15, 2020
Report
I ordered 5 hero sandwiches and two large pies from Villa Maria on Sunday. I'm ashamed to admit that I drove them crazy on the phone. I mean, REALLY crazy. I was unsure of what I wanted and kept changing my mind. I was also having a hard time hearing them. As I was trying to speak to them, my grandchildren were clamoring for my attention. While speaking to them, I put my credit card down for a minute and couldn't find it afterwards. (It was in the refrigerator.) After I ordered, I reconsidered and asked them to void out my order and promised that I would call back. Not sure they were
Dan Midgette
Dan Midgette
Oct 08, 2020
Report
Wonderful local pizza place. Daily specials, pizza, pasta, & heroes. Super hard working owner and dedicated staff always make sure you are happy with your order. Great people even better food.
Mike Ciorciari
Mike Ciorciari
Sep 13, 2020
Report
In past food has been excellent and was a go-to local spot for my family. We used to get the big catering orders for parties and gatherings, so I wasn't just an every so often slice and pinwheel customer. I would actively promote villa to friends all the time. Last night I ordered and first, they did not have any Sicilian slices. I understand business may be slow and money conservation a necessity these days, but that would be a staple you have at least one pie to cover customer base. Then, I ordered two pepperoni pinwheels and I got two items which I can only describe as pepperoni and cheese stuffed
Joseph Harris Laudadio
Joseph Harris Laudadio
Sep 01, 2020
Report
I have to agree with Bruce. I am actually eating a pie now after giving it a second chance. I’ve lived here for 4 years and truly thought this was the best pizza in town...hands down. However, this is the second time now that we actually are throwing out the pizza. Cheese was not melted and it’s like a completely different pizza. I also just realized they took the “free pie” stamps off the pizza box. What a shame, as I now have to search for a new place.
It is only a matter of time before the same reviews start pouring in, as there is absolutely no way that a regular customer would not
Rob Schimenz
Rob Schimenz
Jun 07, 2020
Report
Ordered trays of lasagna, chicken parm, and sauteed spinach for Christmas dinner. It was delicious. They gave me directions to reheat plus extra shredded cheese and sauce. I don't particularly like spinach, but their sauteed spinach was fabulous. I'll be ordering from Villa Maria from now on!
Chris K.
Chris K.
Apr 29, 2020
Report
After living in Bethpage a few years finally tried this place, and I have enjoyed everything I have gotten here. Meat lovers pizza is great, I love the chicken parm slice as well, but for me the standout is their Sicilian slice. Thick, no skimping on the cheese, crust is delicious. One of the best Sicilian slices I've ever had.

Stopped by a few weeks ago to grab a few slices while out walking, and even my wife was impressed and she's picky when it comes to pizza.

Definitely one of my go to places for pizza now.
Elizabeth C.
Elizabeth C.
Dec 21, 2019
Report
Ordered penne with Garlic and oil with grilled chicken an broccoli ...so difficult to mess up but this was bad... chicken was rubbery and their was no flavor at all other than the taste of grilled burnt chicken...gave it 2 stars for the basic cheese pizza which is good...dont buy the entrees.
Irishmjk K.
Irishmjk K.
Dec 16, 2019
Report
When I moved from Queens in 2009 it was tough finding a good pizza place near here. I was very happy when the new owner took over and ever since Me and my kids love the food from here. We usually get the pizza, knots, fries and wraps. Always friendly and never had a problem with any of the items I ordered from here.
Alyssa M.
Alyssa M.
Sep 16, 2019
Report
Pretty average Long Island pizzeria. Ordered a pizza and two hero's last night. The pizza was half cheese and half sausage and peppers. The hero's were chicken parm and meatball parm. Everything tasted pretty average. The flavor of the sauce did not stand out. The hero's were generous portions which was nice. My favorite part of what I ordered was the pizza dough and crust. It was very light and airy. I was able to eat more since it was not heavy and doughy. My boyfriend loves their sesame seed pizza crust which is why he often orders from here!
Joseph M.
Joseph M.
Jul 13, 2019
Report
This place has really gone down hill - We had the pizza on a monday nite and it was absolutely HORRIBLE - I was very concerned and even emailed the business establishment - To my absolute HORROR - I never even got a response from the owner MICHAEL GOLDBOROUGH. Here is my email for which I got zero response! I really think I was being more then fair and even wanted to help this business owner out since he is local and has been around for some time!!

EMAIL Sent
Hi Michael - My wife and i stopped bye last night (Monday June10th) and ordered a plain cheese pizza. The pizza looked incredible but that
Lauren C.
Lauren C.
Jun 23, 2019
Report
We have been frequenting this place since we moved to Levittown 2 years ago. My parents frequent this place at least 2x a month. My boys are hooked on the meatball and pepperoni pizza. I love the meatball pizza. My dad says he talks to the owner everyone he sees him. The pizza has been awesome and my favorite is when he brought home some penne a la vodka one Sunday. It is the best I have ever tasted. I want to try more of the food.
Samantha B.
Samantha B.
Apr 18, 2019
Report
My fiancé saw them on News 12 and decided to order from them for our WrestleMania party. The baked ziti pie with garlic knot crust was the best pizza I've ever had. Sometimes the pasta on those specialty pies gets over cooked and the noodles are crunchy- this was NOT the case. Garlic knots and wings were fantastic too. They tasted good even after being reheated throughout the week. Food also still tasted amazing days later. We ate that pizza for days!
Tj L.
Tj L.
Mar 31, 2019
Report
Tried a regular pie and 6 garlic knots seeing as they won news 12 food fight.

Called and they said it was a regular pie special night. Price was low, but questionably low.
How can they not use cheap ingredients?

Garlic knots were very good. The cheese pie was definitely unique. Ate 2 slices. Taste started to get to me and couldn't finish the 3rd.

Would like to see a step up in ingredients and presentation.
Maybe some small changes here and there can really make a difference.

News 12 showed kids under 10 making garlic knots............awesome.....
Tom M.
Tom M.
Mar 26, 2019
Report
I have never even been to Villa Maria, but seeing how many people get "sick" and "nauseous" from the food, I can't wait to try it now! These sleazy fake reviews only spotlight the fact that the place must be so good, it's competitors have to stoop to the lowest possible level to try to convince people otherwise. "Sick" and "nauseous?" Can't you numbskulls just make up something we might sort of believe, like "the sauce is a little runny," or "the crust is a little too thin?"

The funny thing is that, had I seen this
Cindy M.
Cindy M.
Mar 18, 2019
Report
Poor quality food and very rude people. After eating there i became sick. After having such a bad experience, I will not be back.
Adriana Q.
Adriana Q.
May 21, 2018
Report
I didn't like the grandma pizza . The sauce was to sweet I taste sugar in it plus it was so soggy .