Shafer Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Shafer Insurance
Established in 1900, Shafer Insurance Agency proudly provides comprehensive insurance solutions throughout Ohio. With nearly 120 years of service supplying the insurance needs of families and businesses, we are a trusted source for home insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance and more. Whether you need to insure a car or a car dealership we have an insurance solution for you.

Shafer Insurance provides all types of insurance protection. We can insure your personal insurance needs, such as your home, auto, boat, RV/Camper, ATV, jewelry or other valuables as well as personal umbrella coverage. If you have a farm, we can insure you too. We insure small businesses to large commercial accounts and write various types of bonds.
Services
Shafer Insurance Agency was established in 1900 in Byesville, Ohio by the late John B. Shafer. He moved the agency to Cambridge and ran it until he passed in 1923. His son, L. M. "Bing" Shafer, obtained his insurance license in 1921 and continued the family business until 1977. Third generation, John R. Shafer, joined his father in the agency in 1956 and continued the family legacy for 63 years.
Mindy has been with the agency for 24 years and became agency owner in 2020. She is able to write business in personal lines, commercial lines and life and disability insurance. She enjoys working with clients to help assess their needs and come up with a plan to find the right coverage. Jacilyn has been with the agency for 8 years.
We know that no two businesses are alike. Whether you need property insurance for your restaurant or dealer's blanket coverage to protect the cars at your dealership, we can help meet your specific insurance needs. Our experienced staff will tailor a package to protect your business and give you the peace of mind that comes with knowing you are covered.
From hobby farms to commercial agriculture exposures such as feed and seed dealers, it is important to identify risks associated with whatever it is you produce. We proudly represent top-rated insurance carriers that are specific to agribusiness to ensure you get the coverage you need at a price you can afford.
In addition to homeowners insurance, we also offer condo owners and renters insurance. We can help you with personal legal liability coverage, which covers your legal responsibility for property damage or injuries for which you or your family may be responsible. Give us a call today, we will create a home insurance plan that works best for your specific needs.
Reviews (3)
Dustin Mahrt
Dustin Mahrt
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
You know they are doing something right if they've been around for 120 years! Established in 1900. You get a certain level of integrity when you deal with an agency of this caliber. 10 out of 10, would recommend!
John Lewis
John Lewis
May 21, 2019
Report
Not enough praise for this insurance agency! Did a fantastic job. Very helpful and willing to work with me even though I wasnt able to come to the office. Thanks again!
Scott Hill
Scott Hill
May 16, 2019
Report
Best prices around, because they are independent and can shop for you. And just plain nice.