Rummell Brill Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Rummell Brill Insurance Agency
Since 1948, our friends and customers have trusted Rummell-Brill to be there to put back together what life has torn apart. Sure, you'll get a welcoming smile and an honest handshake from our caring team, but most importantly, you'll get solutions that work for you when you need them. We know there's no insurance agency quite like ours so we get it when you tell us your business is unique.

We take the time to understand what you need out of your business insurance, to help protect it against blindspots. From restaurants to dealerships, we're in it to help, no matter your industry. We make it easy to protect your home, and everything in it. Partner with us to ensure your largest investment is properly protected in the event of a loss.
Services
Rummell-Brill is an independent insurance agency based in Plain City for over 70 years. To best serve our customers, we represent a select list of insurance companies, to offer you customized coverage solutions that give you peace of mind. Finding you the best solution to protect your home, business, farm, and life, it's what drives us.
Jenny started her career in Insurance in 1977 working for her father Joe Rummell, and eventually took ownership of the business. She oversees all office operations and management. As a Third Generation Agent, Rose is carrying on her family's legacy. Specializing in Commercial Lines and Life Insurance, you can count on her to provide you with the best experience possible.
At Rummell-Brill Insurance we listen to you. Matching you with the proper coverage at an affordable and competitive price is our job. When chaos strikes or life happens, it is important to partner with a trusted name, who has been showing up to help for over 70 years. To get in touch with our experienced agents, request a quote so we can be there for you when unexpected changes in life happen.
More than a means to an end, your vehicle connects your life. Accidents happen, and when they do, it's important to know that your policy will protect you, and your agent will go to work for you. Rental Reimbursement (In the event of a covered loss, this coverage will help pay for your rental car.).
Conversations about life insurance don't need to be overwhelming or complicated. Our experienced agents can guide you through your options, allowing you to plan for your family's security with our strategic financial tools. If you have others who depend on you financially, it is very likely that you need life insurance.
Reviews (8)
Eric Hooks
Eric Hooks
Jan 23, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I have been with Rummell Brill for many years and they have always been a great company with great people. They are outstanding and I would recommend them to anyone!
Terina Stewart
Terina Stewart
Dec 01, 2019
Report
Jackie Honigford was polite and explained everything so that I understood the policy!!
Cory Reda
Cory Reda
Sep 18, 2019
Report
Staff is wonderful and amazing! Customer service is important to me and I’m sure many other people too when it comes to a company and these guys are great to say the least. :)
Jordan Piper
Jordan Piper
Aug 10, 2019
Report
Wonderful experience! Rose did everything she could to make it a great experience and found us the best company/policy to fit our needs and budget!
Lisa Hamilton
Lisa Hamilton
Aug 07, 2019
Report
Anna Francis is phenomenal. She cares about her customers and is always looking out for her customers. Brings peace of mind knowing this agency takes care of me and my family.
Stacey Rymer
Stacey Rymer
Jun 22, 2019
Report
My husband and I have been with Rummell Brill since we got married in 2004. Everyone in the office is amazing! If I have any questions they go above and beyond to help me out. I love that when I call Anna always calls me by name. Thank you so much Anna and Rummell Brill for all of your hard work.
Melissa Hart
Melissa Hart
May 21, 2019
Report
The gals at Rummell Brill always make sure we have what we need to keep our office running smoothly. Whether its finding paperwork we have misplaced, walking us through what to do for a claim, or just making our day brighter - they are always on the ball. I know I can always depend on Anna to take care of our vehicle fleet, answer all my questions no matter how silly and make me laugh! When its renewal time or I need a COI, no matter how difficult the legal verbiage is from the company requiring it, Kathy handles it like a pro and I have it in hand right away! Everyone I have dealt with in the
Angie Lowe
Angie Lowe
Jan 15, 2015
Report
Wonderful staff who genuinely care about their clients! These folks are a pleasure to work with.