Cake Conspiracy
Website
Cake Conspiracy
Cake Conspiracy made our wedding cake and truffles as take home gifts for guests, and they were both FABULOUS. The cake was moist and flavorful, the filling was divine, and the service was wonderful! We will be ordering future cakes from you guys! All I can say is WOW! From the cake tasting to the final event, everything was immaculate!

We have so much cake left but refuse to share its so good! Our wedding cake was a 3 tier: Chocolate Noir (I'm not a chocolate lover, but i can't stop eating this cake!) Lemon/Raspberry and Carrot Cake. The grooms cake was Cinnamon Roll. I believe we are four cakes in with Cheryl and she has outdone her previous creation each and every time!
Services
Cake pricing is considered on an individual basis. Many factors go into a quote such as the flavor profile, difficulty of the design, servings, and detail required. Starting pricing for all cakes is based on a clean frosted or fondant covered cake, with no additional detail. We require a 50% non-refundable deposit to book for cakes ordered more than 3 weeks in advance.
Reviews (17)
Isabel H.
Isabel H.
Jan 03, 2022
Report
The custom design is amazing just beautiful but the taste wasn't all there and is too pricy. I mean you really have to be into the flavors they offer otherwise it's all about the looks of the design.
TraLa LawGrrl
TraLa LawGrrl
Dec 12, 2021
Report
Cheryl did a flawless, gorgeous job with our wedding cake. We wanted it simple/classic with a boho flair, and she delivered. It was also delicious!
Kie Hankins
Kie Hankins
Dec 06, 2021
Report
They did a beautiful job with the cake and desserts at our wedding. Very nice staff, flexible and pleasant to work with. Creative and delicious food. Many guests went back for seconds and thirds.
Kate Leonard
Kate Leonard
Nov 21, 2021
Report
The best cake experience! We loved working with Cake Conspiracy, it's a lovely local shop ran more professionally than any other shop we visited. They really impressed us, from the cake tasting, to the service, to the final product. The cake was moist and delicious on the day-of, and my brother won't stop talking about how good it was. We can't wait for our anniversary cake!
Tanya Little
Tanya Little
Oct 18, 2021
Report
They did an amazing job for my daughters wedding. She did a three tier wedding cake, grooms cake and cupcakes and there was nothing left at the end of the night. Everyone went on and on about how good everything was. She did an amazing job. I highly recommend Cake Conspiracy❤️
S. Smith
S. Smith
Jun 27, 2021
Report
They did an awesome job on my brother’s graduation cake! The cake was very moist and flavorful and the decorating was outstanding! I would use them again for my next cake needs.
Franchellie O.
Franchellie O.
Sep 07, 2020
Report
My son's first birthday cake. In love with the details and how well they interpreted my ideas
O. Russkikh
O. Russkikh
Sep 07, 2020
Report
This was an unbelievable piece of art and sculpture...that happened to also be a cake! It was simply amazing. The attention to detail and sheer beauty were breathtaking. But wait...the taste was amazing to match. Just excellence all the way around. The process of ordering and pickup were equally good. Recommend Cake Conspiracy to all and to the owners...THANK YOU FOR MAKING OUR SON'S BIRTHDAY SO SPECIAL!!
Sara C.
Sara C.
Jul 13, 2020
Report
I had a very positive experience with Cake Conspiracy and would definitely recommend them. The ordering process was super easy, and I was able to pay online which made everything simple. I sent a picture of a cake that I found online and they replicated it exactly!
Tyler Howard
Tyler Howard
Jun 21, 2020
Report
The cake was a huge hit! My wife loved it and said it was the best cake she’d seen. It was worth the wait and happy I found your business. I appreciated the easy no contact pickup too.
Patricia R.
Patricia R.
Dec 21, 2019
Report
I worked with Cheryl regarding my bridal and groom's cake for our wedding this year. Not only is there EVERY kind of cake flavor you could imagine available to choose from, but the actual cake tasting hugely impressed all of us including my very hard to impress father. We used real flowers from our florist, The Blooming Idea, on the bridal cake and the groom's cake was in the shape of a Titliest golf ball!!! Super professional, well-priced, TASTY, warm, and easy to work with are only some of the adjectives to describe Cheryl. I WILL be using her again for future events!
Tye C.
Tye C.
Nov 21, 2019
Report
I believe we are four cakes in with Cheryl and she has outdone her previous creation each and every time! Bringing a child's imagination to life is a difficult task that Cheryl tackles with excitement. Compared to other custom cake designers we have worked with, Cake Conspiracy is unparalleled in every aspect of the process and we look forward to every birthday with one of her creations as the centerpiece!
Jerah S.
Jerah S.
Nov 10, 2019
Report
Second cake we've ordered and definitely still beyond impressed! It was so pretty we hated cutting it, but glad we did because it was as delicious as it was beautiful! Will definitely be ordering again for events. Well worth the money. You can tell precious time and thought goes into every cake!
Nancy G.
Nancy G.
Aug 21, 2019
Report
I was looking for a bakery for a 25th wedding anniversary.....it was no easy endeavor locating one when I lived out of town. Finally I found Cake Conspiracy. Cheryl responded to my e-mail promptly, and time was of an essence. Her choices are many. I looked at the menu and found the perfect cake. From the very first, she responded to my e-mail, text or phone message in a timely manner. The cake was delivered promptly to the restaurant and the table was in awe when the cake was brought in.
Adrienne B.
Adrienne B.
Feb 12, 2017
Report
The cake was a hit at the bridal shower! It was not only gorgeous but also one of the best tasting cakes I have ever had! She is awesome and delivered exactly what I was hoping for!
Kim G.
Kim G.
Sep 11, 2016
Report
Did a wonderful job on a short notice. Thank you so much for making my daughters 4th birthday a big hit
Kaleigh C.
Kaleigh C.
May 02, 2016
Report
I cannot say enough about our cake and cupcakes! From the beginning Cake conspiracy was great. I sent her my ideas and some pictures and she nailed it. It turned out stunning and delicious! We are ordering another specialty cake from her and I cannot wait!