Name: Catello's Italian Art Cuisine
Address: 103 E State St, Pendleton, IN, 46064, US
Telephone: (317) 498-5906
Rating: 4.5

When you're ready for an exceptional Italian restaurant experience in the state of Indiana, visit Catello's Italian Art Cuisine. Our chef-owned eatery offers authentic Italian food made from scratch and with the freshest ingredients. On top of that, we've been voted as the best Italian restaurant in the state of Indiana!

You're sure to love the many options on our menu, ranging from traditional pasta like Spaghetti Alla Nerano to chef-featured meals such as our Spigola and Ceci dish. For your dining convenience, we have locations in both Indianapolis and Pendleton. Dine-in, carryout, and delivery are all available.

Website Update

Services

Catello's Menu - Indianapolis Report

If you want an authentic Italian meal that's made from scratch, visit Catello's Italian Art Cuisine in Indianapolis, IN. Our chef-owned restaurant uses Italian flour in our pizzas and pasta and organic cheese curds to make our famous mozzarella and burrata cheeses. Even our liquor is made in-house!

Catello's Menu - Pendleton Report

When you're searching for real Italian food in Pendleton, IN, look no further than Catello's Italian Art Cuisine. Our cuisine is made from scratch using time tested recipes by a real Italian chef. It doesn't get any more authentic! We offer a wide variety of menu options, ranging from appetizers and salads to traditional pasta and chef-featured dinners.

Reviews (10)

Write a Review

Geoff Steinke

Jan 28, 2022

Report

The food was amazing. Our service was exceptional and the atmosphere was pleasant. They even had a live piano player. I can't wait to come back.

Umberto Fonda

Jan 04, 2022

Report

I actually didn't eat here as Bologna is quite far from Indiana, but I appreciated the effort to preserve Italian food tradition. Every time you add shrimp on Bolognese an Italian grandmother dies.

Chelsea Seal

Dec 26, 2021

Report

We were incredibly refreshed by the professionalism of our waiter and the consideration taken into pacing at this restaurant…I haven’t found that many restaurants in the Midwest have this ability.
We had a great time! Wine was second to none in Indiana

Sam Zizo

Nov 21, 2021

Report

It’s amazing food amazing service
Kelly is the best service kind and great
Thank you for the owner shef Cattello amazing place

Sue Ream

Nov 20, 2021

Report

Fantastico! A true fine dining experience in Pendleton. The wine selection is very good - which is hard to find in this neck of the woods, and the food is excellent. Everything, including the pasta, is house made and very fresh. The service was great. I understand the owner is from Naples, Italy and has expanded downtown Indy Catellos to Pendleton. Graci! The restaurant has recently expanded and is charming, with exposed brick and a cozy ambiance.

Christopher Kimmey

Aug 19, 2021

Report

Usually excellent. This time we had the worst service ever in any restaurant we have been to. We were brought entrees from other tables at least 3 times. My dish was not as advertised on the menu and the lobster was rubbery and flavorless. We were offered a gift card for our "troubles" only to find out there is a total of $0.00 on the card. Their excuse was that the waitress was on her first day... and alone on the floor. This is poor management. We were willing to give another chance in the future but that is not likely now. Absolutely disappointing.

Trav

Mar 19, 2021

Report

I just tried this place for the first time. I was amazed to find something like this in the small town of Pendleton. I had the FILETTO AL TALEGGIO. A Filet with Taleggio cheese in a puff pastry. It was spectacular. The Filet was cooked perfectly. Flavorful and tender with just enough of the cheese to compliment the taste, but not overwhelm it. I highly recommend trying this if you have the chance.

Daniel Spieth

Jun 01, 2020

Report

Catello’s is a great place to share food wine and a wonderful experience with family and friends. I ordered the wine mojito to drink. It was refreshing. The bread is excellent. I got lamb and pasta. They make their own pasta. It was amazing

Robert Schounce

Jun 30, 2019

Report

The service here was impeccable as was the atmosphere. The food was good, but didn't quite make exceptional. The crab was difficult to clean indicating it was slightly overcooked. The flavor, however was astounding. I cannot say enough about the service. Well worth a trip. I will visit again.

Kilyssah

Jul 13, 2018

Report

If you are craving fresh mozzarella, consider yourself a professional wine taster, love authentic Italian food, or just want to try something new..this is the place. I can’t wait to come back!