Treat your taste buds to a specialty pie from Old Town Pizzeria. Take the night off from cooking and enjoy the cheesy concoctions crafted at Old Town Pizzeria. Our traditional Italian ambiance and menu offer something the whole family can enjoy. Whether you're planning a Shower, Engagement Party, Sweet Sixteen, office lunch or just a family get together, we will custom design a menu for you.
We can accomondate in-house dining or we can provide you with a staff at the location of your choice. Old Town Pizzeria in Port Jefferson Station provides you with exceptional service and quality.
We can accomondate in-house dining or we can provide you with a staff at the location of your choice. Old Town Pizzeria in Port Jefferson Station provides you with exceptional service and quality.
Reviews (27)
Austin M.
Jan 30, 2022
Report
Food was really good, one of the few places that were open during the snow storm I got a large pie and a dozen garlic knots, only thing I can say is I was charged an extra 6$ after looking at the menu prices, should have been charged 24 and change not 29.68 but I'm sure it was accidental. Great pizza great food and great local location
Toni M.
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Ordered a pie New Year's Day as well as a couple of entrees and was brought this horrendous looking pizza 40 minutes later. Pizza was cold in the middle and totally overdone. I can understand being busy and a pie going slightly cold but this clearly was not the case. There was zero cheese pull and this was definitely a pie they baked the night before and was thrown in for a second time. Burnt and inedible.
Barbara Hansen
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Francina B.
Dec 24, 2021
Report
Liz M.
Dec 15, 2021
Report
Robert Castelli
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Thomas Helou
Dec 01, 2021
Report
Cathy F.
Dec 01, 2021
Report
We wanted pasta tonight and automatically went to old town pizza. It's close and always good in the past. 2 of us has the lobster ravioli and my husband had the pasta pomodoro with sausage. The sauce with the lobster ravioli was awful!! The shrimp & scallops in the sauce tasted like they had been in there for days. They were tough & inedible! The pomodoro sauce was like paste. Now I always knew a pomodoro sauce to be light w/ basil, this stuff was far from it and the sausage in the sauce was so dried out! $70+ dollars for 3 dinners that ended up in the garbage is a disgrace! Not the
Karena Israel
Nov 23, 2021
Report
We really wanted to like this place! We are new to the area and were thrilled to see the awesome salads they offered. We gave it a try one night for take out. No issues. So we ordered again the next two weeks. Each time the order was messed up. So disappointing.
The first time they gave our order to someone else. That person returned with our food while we were standing there waiting. The person behind the counter then tried to give it to us....um no thank you...someone else already left with the food and returned it??? They made us a fresh order but now of course we were late. Ok, everyone makes
The first time they gave our order to someone else. That person returned with our food while we were standing there waiting. The person behind the counter then tried to give it to us....um no thank you...someone else already left with the food and returned it??? They made us a fresh order but now of course we were late. Ok, everyone makes
Jimmy Marchisotto
Nov 02, 2021
Report
I love their Margherita pizza!!! The regular pizza is my go to when I am to busy to cook. I've also had their pasta and different types of Rolls like the chicken parmesan or Sausage and peppers. They always serve FRESH and delicious food. The staff are friendly and are very helpful in deciding what you want....
D'Angelo Caruso
Oct 21, 2021
Report
Erica H.
Oct 14, 2021
Report
Kevin
Aug 15, 2021
Report
Firstly, the dine-in or take-out question in the Google Maps survey is ambiguous. We have both dined in and taken meals home to go, both very good by the way.
Don't be misled by the appearance of a strip mall Pizzeria. They know what they're doing. Anything we've tried so far and it's like four times now was very good. And the pizza is really good. My only suggestion is use panko bread crumbs on the bottom of the crust. 4-star other than the dreary location.
Thanks,
KC
Don't be misled by the appearance of a strip mall Pizzeria. They know what they're doing. Anything we've tried so far and it's like four times now was very good. And the pizza is really good. My only suggestion is use panko bread crumbs on the bottom of the crust. 4-star other than the dreary location.
Thanks,
KC
Frank S.
Aug 07, 2021
Report
For a small get-together with friends my wife ordered a few dishes from Old Town Pizza.
We had chosen this establishment because we had stopped in one day; at the time our gym was near by; and were very pleasantly surprised at the tastiness of the food. For a pizzeria the "zuppa di pesce" that my wife and I shared was surprisingly delightful. Consequently, we thought we would order the same dishes we had had and added the baked clams to try.
In addition to the two trays of: "zuppa di pesce" and fried calamari; we also ordered two trays of baked clams. The restaurant added
We had chosen this establishment because we had stopped in one day; at the time our gym was near by; and were very pleasantly surprised at the tastiness of the food. For a pizzeria the "zuppa di pesce" that my wife and I shared was surprisingly delightful. Consequently, we thought we would order the same dishes we had had and added the baked clams to try.
In addition to the two trays of: "zuppa di pesce" and fried calamari; we also ordered two trays of baked clams. The restaurant added
G. C.
Jul 24, 2021
Report
Cris P.
Jul 13, 2021
Report
S. V.
Apr 22, 2021
Report
Terri Spin
Feb 03, 2021
Report
I ordered stuffed mushrooms which are in the menu as having scampi sauce. The first batch came with a gloppy brown sauce. Scampi is butter, wine and garlic. The second batch came the same way after I gave them a chance to correct it. Well apparently Old Town claims brown gravy is scampi. Google it scampi is not that!!!
Jill B.
Jan 16, 2021
Report
Tara K.
Sep 27, 2020
Report
Brendan C.
Jul 03, 2020
Report
Decent pizza but they can't get orders right for the life of them. Today is the day I gave up, after asking for Arrabbiata sauce in my pasta they gave me pasta with sausage and peppers. When I called to say they messed up the dish and the food was for a vegetarian I was told "well hun, arrabbiata comes with sausage." Arrabbiata sauce is tomato sauce cooked with chili flakes and extra garlic. Like I said, decent pizza, pretty inconsistent kitchen food, and condescending staff. Learn ur dishes. Dime a dozen spot that I won't visit again.
Robert E.
Jun 07, 2020
Report
Stopped in for a slice. Needed a snack. NONE of the workers were completely covering their faces with masks. Most of the cooks in the back room didn't have one on at all! Sorry, maybe I'm overthinking this thing but if you post a sign that patrons must wear a mask to enter, maybe the employees should as well.
Oh, I left without my slice.
Oh, I left without my slice.
Greg S.
Feb 14, 2020
Report
Glenn S.
Dec 05, 2019
Report
This place is always busy with lots of customers ordering takeout. That shows how good it is. But there are booths for eat-in too. Service has always been good whenever I went there.
I usually drop in for a chicken parmigiana hero, but have had other things too. The food is always fresh.
A huge parking lot in front makes it easy to park. Take-out usually takes about 20 minutes to prepare, but you can call ahead to have it ready.
I usually drop in for a chicken parmigiana hero, but have had other things too. The food is always fresh.
A huge parking lot in front makes it easy to park. Take-out usually takes about 20 minutes to prepare, but you can call ahead to have it ready.
Natasha T.
Sep 29, 2019
Report
With exceptional specialty in service and ITALIANO eats Old Town Pizzeria is an array of fineness
Served by John was as absolute pleasure the listening of his story within the restaurant business for 15 yrs. and his journey with Old Town Pizza was a remarkable insight to the dedication and integrity he has for his time with the business. When you hear such marvelous feedback from employee's of there employer you can't help but appreciate a business more. The infrastructure of this business is high standards serving fine eats. Rosie was just as welcoming this crew is one fine asset in
Served by John was as absolute pleasure the listening of his story within the restaurant business for 15 yrs. and his journey with Old Town Pizza was a remarkable insight to the dedication and integrity he has for his time with the business. When you hear such marvelous feedback from employee's of there employer you can't help but appreciate a business more. The infrastructure of this business is high standards serving fine eats. Rosie was just as welcoming this crew is one fine asset in
Paula N.
May 14, 2019
Report
I called at 5pm to order a pie for delivery at my house after ordering for our place of business.
Finally 8pm I called again because They never showed. I called three times, got three different stories!
The fourth time I called to cancel and make sure they charged my card back.
The manager grabbed the phone YELLED at me " there's a pizza coming outta the oven now, you want it YES OR NO"
We are new to the area found a decent pizza place that delivers, but constantly at our shop and home.
This is s service ?
Any reccomendations for GOOD PIZZA WITH GOOD CUSTOMER service
Finally 8pm I called again because They never showed. I called three times, got three different stories!
The fourth time I called to cancel and make sure they charged my card back.
The manager grabbed the phone YELLED at me " there's a pizza coming outta the oven now, you want it YES OR NO"
We are new to the area found a decent pizza place that delivers, but constantly at our shop and home.
This is s service ?
Any reccomendations for GOOD PIZZA WITH GOOD CUSTOMER service
Congo Bongos
Aug 26, 2018
Report
Its good food if you go there but forget about ordering from here. Every time they mess it up. last time they forgot a salad and didnt put mozzarella on the mozzarella garlic bread. This time they gave us a disgusting pizza with oil all over the bottom of the box and under the pizza making the entire thing a soggy mess. The garlic knots we ordered because we didnt trust them to put mozzarella on the bread this time was cold... not room temp... COLD!!
