Traditions On The Beach has an extensive menu featuring "Contemporary Cuisine, Sanibel Style, " & uses only the freshest local ingredients! Drink, Dine & Dance with Us! Luxury Suites Crisp Linens, Glass Showers, Full Kitchens, Personal Wet Bar, Breathtaking Views, Paradise on Sanibel is Matthews Lodge Luxury Suites.
Modern Comforts Free WiFi, Parking & Beach Chairs, Daily Guided Beach Walks, Maid Service, and NO RESORT FEES! Enjoy It All at the Island Inn! For more than a century, vacationers have sought out Sanibel Island Inn as the premier Sanibel Island hotel and resort destination. Today, people come to Sanibel Island Inn to vacation with family, host the perfect wedding, or simply get away by themselves.
Modern Comforts Free WiFi, Parking & Beach Chairs, Daily Guided Beach Walks, Maid Service, and NO RESORT FEES! Enjoy It All at the Island Inn! For more than a century, vacationers have sought out Sanibel Island Inn as the premier Sanibel Island hotel and resort destination. Today, people come to Sanibel Island Inn to vacation with family, host the perfect wedding, or simply get away by themselves.
Services
Perched on Sanibel's stunning south shore with miles of white sandy beaches alongside our private pool and hotel grounds, dotted with lush landscaping and towering coconut palms, the quaint Island Inn beachfront resort serves island adventure and relaxation. Conveniently located on the Gulf of Mexico, just a short drive from Southwest Florida International Airport; this Sanibel hotel is perfect for Florida vacations, getaways & events year-round.
Still have questions? Call us between 8 am-5 pm at 239-472-1561 and we will help you! Sorry, but the Island Inn is not pet or ESA friendly. A list of other properties that are pet friendly can be found on the Sanibel Captiva Chamber of Commerce website. Yes! Island Inn guests can rent bikes from our front desk and we have plenty, so no need to make a reservation for them.
The Island Inn's private, 10-acre beachfront property is home to three hotel buildings, five hotel suite styles and five spacious cottages featuring unique rooms to fit every guests' needs. All located within yards of the warm waters of the Gulf of Mexico.
All accommodations include daily maid service, complimentary WiFi, flat screen HD cable TV, complimentary parking, electronic safe, DVD/CD player, hair dryer, coffee maker, iron/ironing board and beach chairs & towels.Shelling on Sanibel Island draws thousands to the island every year. Island Inn is strategically located at the outer point of the Sanibel Island barrier reef where birds, shells and miles of sandy beaches are found in abundance.
All accommodations include daily maid service, complimentary WiFi, flat screen HD cable TV, complimentary parking, electronic safe, DVD/CD player, hair dryer, coffee maker, iron/ironing board and beach chairs & towels.Shelling on Sanibel Island draws thousands to the island every year. Island Inn is strategically located at the outer point of the Sanibel Island barrier reef where birds, shells and miles of sandy beaches are found in abundance.
Located directly across the street on historic Island Inn Road are our 4 Monthly Vacation Home rentals. These homes combine all the benefits, seclusion and affordability of a private vacation rental with the assurance and level of service provided by Sanibel Island's #1 Hotel. All Vacation Home reservations check in on the 1st of the month and check out on the 30th (except for February, which checks out on the last day of that month).
Starky Lodge's extra large rooms include a full, eat-in style kitchen and a large screened balcony with views of the Gulf. With two queen beds and a queen sofa bed, your room comfortably accommodates up to six guests. Spoonbill Gulf Front Cottage is one of seven different cottages on the 10-acre Island Inn property.
Reviews (25)
Michael Cook
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Brian M.
Dec 03, 2021
Report
Brandee Street
Nov 03, 2021
Report
Gretchen Scheibe
Oct 18, 2021
Report
We spent 2 nights having a girls' beach getaway. We stayed at the Kimball Lodge walking right out our patio to beach, pool, or grill. The room was spacious with a small area with fridge, sink, micro . The room was so clean and accommodating. We had a delicious dinner in their restaurant with excellent service with live music. 2 wonderful days walking the beach, going to the pool and enjoying the hammocks! What a wonderful time we all had with hopes of retuning!
Lisa Lee
Oct 04, 2021
Report
This is the perfect vacation getaway spot. Accommodations are wonderful, clean and updated. Staff are so friendly and helpful. The location and atmosphere are perfect, right on the beach. Also, the restaurant onsite, Traditions is delicious with a great atmosphere and live music. I stayed here twice this summer and highly recommend!
Michell G.
Sep 21, 2021
Report
Had a great stay for 4 nights. Pics on web site are just like my room. Beds were comfy and room was clean. Stayed in the Starky suites building and really enjoyed it. This place is like old school resort very rustic and natural. It’s clean but weathered and worn but in a good way. Housekeeping people were great! Pool is nice but small and closes at 7 😢 gotta pay for umbrellas and water toys FYI. Would definitely go back 👍🏼💥😎
Chris Eiceman
Sep 15, 2021
Report
Island Inn was very nice. Clean room. We reserved the smallest room in Kimball Lodge. It was nice. We went to the lounge in the same building to watch football to have more room. 👍
Every employee was very nice. Pool was clean. You do need to drag your chair to the beach and rent umbrella if you need one, which you will need.
We wished the restaurant would have been open for breakfast and lunch. I don’t cook on a 3 day vacation. We had to walk down the beach to another resort that had a restaurant and beach bar. Would have rather supported Island Inn.
Every employee was very nice. Pool was clean. You do need to drag your chair to the beach and rent umbrella if you need one, which you will need.
We wished the restaurant would have been open for breakfast and lunch. I don’t cook on a 3 day vacation. We had to walk down the beach to another resort that had a restaurant and beach bar. Would have rather supported Island Inn.
Jennifer Anderson
Sep 13, 2021
Report
J. H.
Aug 24, 2021
Report
Fantastic. Ken at the front desk was very nice. We had an incredible view of the ocean from our room in the Kimball Lodge. The room was clean and private. We saved a lot of money by cooking meals in our room. Outside the lodge, the beach is maybe twenty steps away. In town, be sure to visit both locations of Gene’s Bookstore, one of the best-stocked bookstores I’ve seen. Overall, this was the most relaxing trip that we have taken in Florida. The Island Inn is a wonderful spot for getting away.
Evan R.
Aug 16, 2021
Report
On Sanabel island it doesn't get much better than this. A little piece of heaven that will make you wanting to come back. The location is literally right on the beach. The rooms were spotless. The staff was friendly. And the amenities were great. Prior to staying here I was at a well-known chain hotel considered to be high end. This place blows it out of the water. No pun intended. We were also able to enjoy a nice dinner at the restaurant on property. The food is phenomenal and the service is fantastic.
Chrisy Va
Jul 26, 2021
Report
Island Inn is such a beautiful and peaceful place to stay! My husband and I just came back last week from a 3 night stay. We stood at the Kimball lodge with a beautiful Gulf view. The room had a very spacious bathroom with 2 sinks. The kitchen has everything you need; stove, refrigerator, utensils, cups, teapot and more. There is a sofa bed in the living area as well as a coffee table and a small dining table and then a super comfortable king sized bed in the sleeping area. The view from the balcony is just amazing! This place is perfect for families and couples alike. Every one we met there was
Madison M.
Jul 05, 2021
Report
Every year my mom and I spend a few days in sanibel to relax and collect shells, every year we try a new hotel or inn. This one is it. 100%! The suites are great, you have a balcony with a view, which also has a wet bar to rinse shells! Ample room to sit and relax.. 5 second walk to the beach. I really loved the room set up, you can have it as a open floor plan, or if someone needs privacy to sleep you can slide the huge doors shut and make the bedroom private. Full kitchen. Full sized fridge. The restaurant had great food and it's steps away from your room. Centrally located, This place really
Cory K.
May 17, 2021
Report
Unfortunately after staying at the Island Inn for a few years, and understanding the rustic history of the inn, and offering suggestions on how to improve I will not be returning. The inn is located on a great stretch of the beach in Sanibel, however the management nor maintenance staff are not keeping up with maintaining the property. The hand rail and exterior of the main building where guests check in is all dirty and badly needs painted, the beach chairs are rusting away and fabric is ripping. Our tub was chipped, and the tub faucet coming out of the wall. And finally our screen door was
Sue H.
May 02, 2021
Report
I stayed in "Matthew's" cottage September 2020. Great experience. Nice bathrooms, super comfy beds and the air conditioner worked great. (ie) it didn't blow right over the bed etc.).
There is a large drop off to get to the kitchen. I didn't have a problem with it, but my friend who has had knee surgery wasn't thrilled, but she restricted in using the kitchen.
Inside the cabin, you can see the gulf but you see more of the beachy grounds more. Attached photo is from outside the front door. I found the view to be peaceful and beautiful.
There is a large drop off to get to the kitchen. I didn't have a problem with it, but my friend who has had knee surgery wasn't thrilled, but she restricted in using the kitchen.
Inside the cabin, you can see the gulf but you see more of the beachy grounds more. Attached photo is from outside the front door. I found the view to be peaceful and beautiful.
Kat W.
Jan 15, 2021
Report
This truly was a very pleasant surprise... it says it's a three star establishment but it's more like five star if you ask me. We stayed in a room with an ocean view and private entrance from the beach. Room was huge, had a living room and kitchen and a beautiful outdoor terrace equipped with table, chairs and even a sink. Whole place is sparkling clean... I had a lot of reservations while staying in a hotel during a raging pandemic, however, this place truly did make me feel safe and comfortable. They follow strictly CDC guidelines. The staff of this place is great, special shout-out
Allie L.
Oct 26, 2020
Report
My husband and I recently stayed at the Island Inn and we will definitely be back! The property was extremely clean, staff was all wearing masks, and our temperatures were taken at check-in. We felt so safe. Our room was immaculate and absolutely beautiful. Can't beat the view! This is the best place we've stayed on the island and can't wait to return. Thanks for a great stay, Island Inn!
Maria C.
Oct 04, 2020
Report
I made my check out today; I stayed at the beach house specifically zyreep beach house #275; terrible house; very old with a strong damp smell; I actually had to go out and buy scent candles and Tina's attention at the reception was good but Gloria was not friendly; at a front desk, customer service must be impeccable; was terrible experience in this property :(.
Maday R.
Sep 07, 2020
Report
We enjoyed our stay at the Island Inn!! The property is amazingly clean, the staff friendly and helpful. The beach is WOW lovely - lot of shells to choose from!!! The water is not crystal clear but it is clean and warm! White sands.... great times at Island Inn - we will come back definitely!!!
Suggestions: bring water shoes if you don't like to touch the shells under the water and repellent for no-see-ums (small mosquitoes) - the front desk sells the repellent in case you forget.
Suggestions: bring water shoes if you don't like to touch the shells under the water and repellent for no-see-ums (small mosquitoes) - the front desk sells the repellent in case you forget.
Elizabeth R.
Jul 21, 2020
Report
The room was like a match box- very small and not easy to get around in. The room had a moldy smell. When, I called the front desk to ask questions, the staff member had the " it is what it is mentality." It was definitely not worth what we paid per night. I would not go back nor would I recommend this place.
Angel L.
Jun 27, 2020
Report
All in all, I liked the Island Inn. It was good, but there are several things that could make it great.
Our first room that we were given had an extremely sour smell in it. Initially, because they were all out of the same rooms that we had rented, they were going to charge us to move us.
Clearly, that was not an issue that should've been put on us considering they attributed the smell to their cleaners cleaning with dirty mop soap. Eventually, they did rectify that, and not charge us.
If you're looking for a place to take your family that is following rigorous COVID-19 precautions
Our first room that we were given had an extremely sour smell in it. Initially, because they were all out of the same rooms that we had rented, they were going to charge us to move us.
Clearly, that was not an issue that should've been put on us considering they attributed the smell to their cleaners cleaning with dirty mop soap. Eventually, they did rectify that, and not charge us.
If you're looking for a place to take your family that is following rigorous COVID-19 precautions
Brian A.
Jun 26, 2020
Report
We have stayed here several times in the past and never had a problem. It's a nice, quiet location. We booked a three night stay with two rooms, but needed to shorten the stay by one day. I've stayed with many hotels and they are generally very understanding especially if you been with them multiple times in the past and spent as much as I have done with the Island Inn over the years.
This trip I booked two rooms and was staying with my family as a little holiday/getaway/staycation/get out of the house expedition. I was informed of the change in policy when I checked in, BUT it sounded
This trip I booked two rooms and was staying with my family as a little holiday/getaway/staycation/get out of the house expedition. I was informed of the change in policy when I checked in, BUT it sounded
Rick H.
Mar 21, 2020
Report
On an island full of spectacular scenery and amazing landscapes, it's almost impossible to choose a place to stay. However after having much fun doing some research, I discovered The Island Inn. I wanted a place where my with could relax, do nothing or everything. She cares for her elderly mom 24/7 in our home. She is dependent on food, medicine and hygiene. I try to get my wife way every once in awhile to collect herself and The Island Inn was a perfect selection. Beautiful beaches, amazing sunsets,great restaurant, friendly staff. Time went by slowly and quickly which I imagine makes some
Umeandthesea S.
Sep 05, 2019
Report
Love this place. We visit a few times a year. We love to shell. Obviously Sanibel is the best shelling in the world. Island Inn is right on the gulf. Cozy, quiet, romantic place. Nice restaurant. Up at sunrise for early morning shelling. Back to the resort for a very good complimentary continental breakfast. Then a day at the beach. Followed by a romantic dinner. We try not to leave the property. The rooms are very clean. Bed was great. Going back in October. Cant wait!!!
Dave P.
Jul 15, 2018
Report
Absolutely a hidden gem! Perfect location, exceptionally clean. Staff was beyond friendly and helpful. I was blown away to see how all staff, from front desk, to cleaning, to lawn care staff all went way out of their way to anticipate guest needs before we even had them.
Best run hospitality business I have ever seen.
Feel was quiet, intimate, and charming. Will definitely be back ASAP. Wish we could have stayed much longer!
Best run hospitality business I have ever seen.
Feel was quiet, intimate, and charming. Will definitely be back ASAP. Wish we could have stayed much longer!
Elizabeth P.
May 22, 2018
Report
