The Italian Village
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
The Italian Village
As a boy who grew on the dirt streets of Sicily, John Balconi knows something about what it means to be authentic Italian. As the son of the town baker, who never wanted to see anyone go without bread- whether they could afford it or not - he knows what it means to be hospitable and to treat people the way you want to be treated.

And since his father died when he was young, John has known nothing but working hard to provide for his family first in Italy, and then as they arrived in America with little more than each other. Through 5 decades, the Balconi family has shared the same food at their restau- rants that they shared at their dining room table at home.
Reviews (22)
Emi N.
Emi N.
Jan 22, 2022
Report
We wanted to give this restaurant another try... sadly we were still disappointed. The fettuccine Alfredo was bland. No flavor whatsoever. The chicken in the fettuccine was even blander. Definitely won't be trying a third time.
Tony Boncore
Tony Boncore
Jan 21, 2022
Report
We often do takeout at The Italian Village. Great recipes on the menu and believe me, you'll be back again. Our favorite is Pasta Puttanesca. The chef crushes this offering.
If you get to The Depew/ Lancaster, New York area make this little restaurant a must visit.
Last Espada TheLastESPADAx
Last Espada TheLastESPADAx
Jan 12, 2022
Report
1st time there only did take out. 1hr wait time. Food was hot. Drove 20 mins back home and was still warm.
Food was good I ordered the carbonara and the platter (chicken parm, speg and meatball, stuffed shells) garlic bread and some desserts.
It was good. Place seemed clean, lots of traffic of people coming and going to dine in and take out.
Kaylei Russell
Kaylei Russell
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Have ordered here so many times within the last year of the pandemic and all I can say is always superb service and amazing food!
Tonight I got there for a pickup order to find there were 2 big parties plus the dining room and take out orders and there was a problem with one of the ovens.
I just want to say that the entire staff was amazing and accommodating and running around to make sure everyone had what they needed. I truly applaud these fine staff who make it a priority to do everything they can while it was obvious they were under a lot of stress. Great job always and can’t wait to continue
Pat G.
Pat G.
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Had a family dinner last night for my wife's birthday at the Village.
We eat there often and always have a fantastic dinner and service!
There were 13 of us and was very happy how efficient all the staff!
Taking care of a group of 13 is a big chore and was executed very well!
The food was excellent and large portions!!
Thank you Balconi family and staff. It was a memorable evening
Randy Weston
Randy Weston
Dec 01, 2021
Report
Typically the food and service is outstanding, tonight they were a little off their game. Was seated and no one came over for about 10 minutes. Garlic bread took 20 minutes and spaghetti was a little hard ( more than Al Dente) when the meal arrived. It was very busy so this may have had something to do with it.
Joanna Zoe Christopher Ch
Joanna Zoe Christopher Ch
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Excellent eggplant parmesan! Fine service. I felt a little funny when I walked in and was asked if I were picking up a delivery, I guess not many people go there alone! I would recommend it. It was enough food for two meals so I took some home!
Guy V.
Guy V.
Nov 17, 2021
Report
I travel several weeks per month and look for local food. This fits this description. I ordered Chicken Margarita upon the waiter recommendation ... wow ... outstanding. The chicken was very tender, perfectly cooked and the sauce was great. I should have order a glass of Chardonnay not Pinot Noir.. It was obviously home made. Great job chef.
Q. M.
Q. M.
Nov 09, 2021
Report
Everything we ordered was delicious and the servers were very attentive and prompt. We ordered, ceasar salad, the Italian trio, calamari and gnocchi. The gnocchi di nonna Lucia was fantastic, chewy gnocchi, and the white wine sauce, my goodness. We also ordered dessert, tiramisu, and the peanut butter pie (both vanished before the entrees). From the bread to dessert we were very pleased, especially after a flight. It's a nice chill spot.
Philly T.
Philly T.
Oct 26, 2021
Report
This place is the greatest. The food and staff are awesome. I can't rave enough about the freshness of the food and the authenticity of there Italian cuisine. The staff is always friendly and puts the customer first. John and Miemo "Mo" are the best at everything they do. Always 1st class and only the best comes out of the kitchen. I had a great time there and felt right at home.
T. J. D.
T. J. D.
Sep 05, 2021
Report
Probably the best stuffed pasta shells I've ever had! I only order that every time. Their cheeses and sauce is perfect. Not pictured here is their Carbonara pasta which is also amazing.
Victoria B.
Victoria B.
Aug 21, 2021
Report
This place is very good ,the portions are gigantic I think I got 3 meals out of my baked pasta! Very home made taste and flavor will go back when I get the chance! The Italian wedding soup was made for a meal in itself !
Cod H.
Cod H.
Aug 15, 2021
Report
I been in this restaurant several times and the food is pretty good. I would say a 3 of 5 on the rating here on Yelp. But this restaurant is an entire joke. Service is horrible with half the staff not caring and the other half running around clueless. I know a person who works there and even says that the kitchen staff actually turns off the grub hub and door dash computer orders when they get busy on busy days like Fridays.
Maybe if you go into it at a time when no one is there you may get fair service. But my family and I will never be back. Go to Chefs or Frank's Sunny Italy if your from
Frank T.
Frank T.
Aug 13, 2021
Report
Great food great service. Best Italian Restaurant in Western New York. Large portions and great flavor
Erin Fulton
Erin Fulton
Aug 12, 2021
Report
My friend and I almost didn’t stop here because the location… tucked inside a little strip mall, but I am so glad we did! We ordered the Haddock and Eggplant Parmesan, and both dishes were among the best we have ever had. I actually still think about the Haddock and wish I could go back and have it again!!! Kudos on an amazing meal. Staff was attentive and friendly, too.
Miguel Chang
Miguel Chang
Aug 12, 2021
Report
Restaurant was okay for me. We went there for dinner during weekday and it was a little busy, had a small waiting time before sitting. The dining area is a little small and felt all the table were next to each other, I guess I got used to spaced seating.
Once we got seated, server brought us water and bread with oil and butter. Ordered a couple of drinks before server came back to take our order. We ordered pasta Provanzano and Pasta Ala Giovanni for our entrees, didn't ordered any appetizer because we saw other tables dishes were huge portion. The Pasta Ala Giovanni was okay, it was supposed
Sarah Nightingale
Sarah Nightingale
Jul 14, 2021
Report
It was absolutely perfect. Went with my family for my dads birthday, we had never been! The stuffed peppers had the spice I love and the filling was delicious. The dinners were ALL tasty and the portions were huge! It’s a clean and friendly place that we will be visiting again!
Lois L.
Lois L.
Jul 11, 2021
Report
The food was awful! Stay away! The front looks run down but the inside is nice....go with your instincts and look for another place
Walter Garcia
Walter Garcia
Jun 13, 2021
Report
The building is in need of repair, the ac doesn’t work and the ceiling has a lot of leak spots, however the food is pretty good and service is pretty good! I’d recommend if you can deal with a little warmth
Christina V.
Christina V.
Jun 08, 2021
Report
Delicious food all the way around. Have been eating here for years and it's always consistently good. Today fir lunch I got the steak sandwich, Arancini and a salad. This will for sure turn into 3 meals. Everything here is huge and delicious. My delivery arrived piping hot and everything has been really yummy. The bread on the steak sandwich was the perfect amount of form but chewy, and the Arancini were the size of Bocce balls!! This is for sure a go to for Italian food.
Sheryl P.
Sheryl P.
May 22, 2021
Report
I saw this restaurant on doordash and I always wanted to order from there so I told my son about it and he treated me to dinner here, the place is very homey, small and quaint, clean very welcoming and the service that we received was outstanding, the waiter also explained the menu to us, once we were seated they brought out some warm bread and oil and herbs and some butter and water, the staff was very attentive. I ordered the manicotti, I think there was either five or six shells on my plate the sauce was red a little bit sweet but it was just perfect. My son ordered the veal parmesan, with
Don B.
Don B.
Apr 22, 2021
Report
True Italian. Traditional food you would expect. Everything our group had was excellent. I highly recommend for som good Italian I'll be back.