Auto & Business
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Auto & Business
Italiano Insurance was established in 1960 by Nelson A. Italiano and has grown into a thriving, full service agency. In 1986, the business was passed down to Jeff and Nat Italiano. Nelson couldn't be more proud of his sons; Jeff manages the Tampa office, while his brother, Nat, oversees the corporation's Boca Grande operation.

Through the two offices, Italiano Insurance meets the needs of thousands of families, individuals, and businesses throughout West Central Florida. Whether you are looking for inexpensive Term Insurance or a Whole Life product, we have several different plan options available. We can design a Life product that meets your individual need.
Services
Welcome to Italiano Insurance Services, your one stop shop for all your insurance needs. We represent multiple insurance companies to make sure you get coverage that matches your needs at the most competitive price. Whether it's for your home, auto, business, boat or life, we can provide the peace of mind that comes with knowing you're insured with a reputable and financially superior insurance company.
Italiano Insurance has a highly trained and motivated staff of Florida insurance agents that work hard to help you find different solutions for your insurance needs. With two locations, Boca Grande and Tampa, we have the strongest group of individuals in the South Florida region. Get to know our insurance professionals today!
At Italiano we operate under one basic principle. Doing the right thing! We understand that being part of our local community comes with much responsibility. Giving is a large part of this but also getting involved and helping our neighbors makes us proud.

Whether it's supporting the Boys & Girls Club, assisting in Pediatric cancer research or providing life saving thermal cameras to local fire departments, we understand that it is more than just corporate responsibility.
Your house is one of your greatest assets and needs to be fully protected from disasters such as fire, hurricanes, vandalism, theft and sinkholes. Price is important but not the only consideration when choosing the right insurance company for homeowners insurance, renter's insurance or property insurance.
At Italiano we're passionate about protecting your business! Allow us to evaluate your specific needs and provide a coverage solution that is tailor-made for your company. By representing many different companies we can ensure you get coverage that matches your needs without overpaying your premiums.
Reviews (9)
Donna Duran
Donna Duran
Nov 19, 2021
Report
I would definitely be careful with this insurance company. We got audit after canceled with them last year . The officer who came to our restaurant said someone have reported us with uninsured which we bought from somewhere else , obviously after canceled with them then got audit ????? So run as far as you can from them !
Jorge Perez
Jorge Perez
Sep 12, 2019
Report
I'm using Italiano insurance because I heard Drew Garabo on the radio station 102.5 The bone I hear his Commercial about Italiano Insurance Company and I was looking for insurance to buy a house. I called the insurance company I'm using for my truck and Italiano Insurance Company to see who I was going to use. I need home and flood insurance. Both companies had the address but Italiano took the Initiative to find the elevation for the flood insurance that made my decision a lot easier. If your look for a company that the extra mile to serve the Customer that is the company I'm going to use.
Thank
Chris Mehaffie
Chris Mehaffie
Jun 10, 2017
Report
I wanted to let you know that we have dealt with Charity Huerta and Italiano Insurance for more than one year now, and it has been a great experience. We have been homeowners for many years, but we have never had the customer service that Charity Huerta provided. In every aspect she has been professional, and has always looked out for our best interest. We greatly appreciate Charity Huerta and Italiano Insurance.
Jonathan B.
Jonathan B.
Dec 16, 2015
Report
I've had my homeowner's insurance with Italiano for almost a year, and just signed up for their auto coverage today. Melissa Jones was my Account Manager while handling the quote process and application. She provided multiple quotes almost immediately, and when I had made my decision regarding which policy I wanted, she promptly had the rest of the documents waiting for me in my email inbox, ready to be signed. The entire process was extremely quick and easy. I significantly recommend Italiano Insurance Services for your insurance needs.
Leslie M.
Leslie M.
Oct 13, 2015
Report
The best service, rates and customer service anywhere! We have our home and auto personal insurance as well as all our business insurance with Italiano because of that. You can count on them every time for anything. Karen Bruton is awesome. She goes above and beyond to answer questions, deliver requested insurance certificates quickly, help us with necessary adjustments to ensure we are completely covered. I used to dread anything insurance related until I switched to Italiano. One of the best decisions I've ever made.
Jennifer Poirier
Jennifer Poirier
Oct 04, 2015
Report
This company is the best. They are so easy to deal with and all the staff members are very knowledgeable. I work directly with Ardythe on regular bases. She is amazing and familiar with my insurance needs. When I have a question she makes sure that I receive a response within 24 business hours. Also she makes sure that I have the correct documents that I request, such as COI, updating liability insurance, adding a new one and the list goes on. I love working with them. They make my life so much easier especially when I have to deal with 10 companies all at the same time. Thank you and keep up the
Kristin Cannell
Kristin Cannell
Sep 18, 2015
Report
I highly recommend Italiano Insurance for your personal and commercial insurance needs. They were able to save me almost $500 in homeowner's premium through another carrier that actually gave me more coverage than my prior one. They are responsive, diligent in their research and always enthusiastically professional. Great team!
Richard Marx
Richard Marx
Sep 02, 2015
Report
Outstanding services and great rates. I strongly recommend using Italiano Insurance for all your insurance needs. We work with Charity and she is a rock star. The best service ever. Quickly returns all emails and calls even after work hours. She's the best!!
Kathy Swan
Kathy Swan
May 31, 2015
Report
I have worked with Italiano Insurance for 2 plus decades. Their dedication to customer service and providing a product that fits the insured's needs are superior to none. Karen Bruton has handled our insurance needs since she began there. She shops our G/L, structure and auto policies each year to make sure we are getting the best rates. When I need a COI, I e-mail Karen and my request is immediately addressed and typically, within the hour, my customer has their certificate and I have a copy in my in box for our records. I highly recommend Italiano Insurance to anyone who has commercial or personal