Name: Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery
Address: 9801 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria, FL, 34216, US
Telephone: (941) 896-5308
Rating: 4.3

Visit our family-owned creamery and bakery store at the heart of Anna Maria Island and look at our exquisite offer of original handmade Italian Gelato, Sorbettes, pastries, assorted desserts, handmade truffles and locally roasted gourmet coffee specialties. Anna Maria Island on the Coast of Manatee Count is known to be the ultimate Gulfside Hideaway for locals and visitors alike.

Superb restaurants, shops, colorful houses, palm trees and seven miles of pure white beaches will have anyone relaxed upon immediate arrival. This beautiful spot of authentic Florida deserves authentic Italian ice cream. We work with all natural ingredients from fresh fruits to local dairy and produce our gelato onsite.

Website Update

Reviews (10)

Write a Review

Linda Whitworth

Nov 03, 2021

Report

The ice cream was one of the best. My husband lover butter pecan & I have to say it was the best I have ever tasted. I chose white chocolate raspberry. It was a close second. This place is not to b missed.

Sarah Grace

Oct 20, 2021

Report

Amazing ice cream! we are not locals but we were just passing through, and stopped at this ice cream shop, 10/10 recommend <3 (i got the toasted marshmallow)

Laura Fernandez

Sep 15, 2021

Report

Ice cream is great but the lady that just took care of our family was extremely disrespectful… she shouldn’t be working at a family vacation spot if she doesn’t know how to treat customers.

Murilo

Aug 27, 2021

Report

Great variety of superior quality ice cream and friendly service. Bakery section is mouthwatering too.
Just can't understand the bad reviews, specially the ones regarding flavor and price.

Summer Ann

Jul 25, 2021

Report

I love love love this place! Their desserts were exceptionally delicious and their caramel iced latte was soooo good!! I definitely recommend stopping here!

Meg Henning

Mar 21, 2021

Report

We came here for gelato and left with a sampling because everything looked so good. The peanut butter layered brownie was to die for - by far my favorite. The sorbet was amazing (flavors watermelon and passion fruit). And although we went for the gelato, that took 3rd place for me between the various items we bought. I will say, across all the little goodies we tried, the textures and flavors are *there*. I think we found our go-to dessert spot here on AMI.

Heather Whelan

Jun 02, 2020

Report

We found the service very friendly and it's sparkling clean. I had the pistachio gelato, and it was a little boring ( but there was nothing wrong with it either). There are many flavors to choose from. Now the chocolate cake, YES, that was the true winner. It was fantastic.

Ac Home

Feb 03, 2020

Report

Amazing place and the ice cream is good. The kids helping to serve are really nice, and they always have an smile. I do recommend this place

Maria D. Whitney

Nov 16, 2019

Report

The cakes were richly delicious! The gelato was creamy and of full flavor with lots of varieties, and they also a offered soft serve ice cream and chocolates. A great place to satisfy your sweet cravings! Yummo!

Leon Robinson

Jun 13, 2018

Report

Stopped in here by chance and glad we did. My wife got half a dozen of the chocolate which not only looked good, but tasted good as well. I got a piece of the salted caramel cake and it was also delicious.