Gary's Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Gary's Insurance has been providing affordable auto insurance in New Jersey for over 10 years. We specialize in competitive insurance rates and superior customer service. We offer a convenient place to get a quote and buy a policy that will have you covered same day. Our experienced insurance agents have the knowledge to help you make an informed decision on your car insurance coverage needs.

You get great customer service from the most reliable and affordable auto insurance agency in NJ, we match you up with the insurance company that will save you money. Get What You Need For Your NJ Car InsuranceAre you buying auto insurance NJ for the first time? You probably don't even know where to start.
Services
Gary's Auto Insurance Agency, LLC. has been in business since the 1980's. Since our inception we have helped thousands of people in New Jersey find the lowest rates available with the best coverage. We can do the same for you! Our highly trained car insurance specialists are ready to assist you in finding the best auto insurance as well as to handle your claims in a timely manner.
Our insurance agents will help you build an auto insurance policy that helps fit your needs. Medical coverage helps pay for medical treatment for accident-related injuries, regardless who is at fault. These costs may include hospital costs, doctor visits, EMT and ambulance fees, surgery, x-rays, and other medical related expenses.
Reviews (9)
Barbara Kelley
Barbara Kelley
Dec 29, 2021
Report
I had the displeasure of meeting sister girl.
after waiting three minutes with No one but me inside waiting for service. She can't get off her rear-end to greet me. I had to come to her. And I don't spend my money in places where I'm treated like I need them when she's got it twisted. They need my business. So smirk on that..
Jennifer Roman
Jennifer Roman
Dec 29, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Awesome, fast quote. Gary was so pleasant to talk to abs team members were great and fast
Kaciyana Senatus
Kaciyana Senatus
Dec 16, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
If you are looking for affordable car insurance look no further. Gary's Insurance Agency is here to help you. After stressing and calling so many places I found Gary and he was able to help me so polite and so fast
Alberto Soberon
Alberto Soberon
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
These people have been helping me with insurance since I first started driving(15years) Always provided me with the lowest and best coverage possible for whichever circumstance I found myself in. I Recommend them to all my friends and hopefully this review helps others trying to switch coverage.
Jai Rob
Jai Rob
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Been coming to Gary since 2000 and nothing has changed except the location. Gary has always been the same nice guy since day 1. I did have an interaction with 1 longtime employee of Gary's but maybe she was just having a bad day. All in all, Gary's a great guy and does great business.
Tania Ince
Tania Ince
Nov 23, 2021
Report
Positive: Quality
I have a great experience with this insurance company every time I go there I have an excellent outcome every time. I wish more places of business would be like Gary’s Insurance. Thank you for the great service.
Kuuipo Arthur
Kuuipo Arthur
Nov 22, 2021
Report
Well I hate to say this but Gary's employees need to go back to school and learn how to be a little bit more decent a little bit more professional and a lot nicer on the telephone standoffish cold arrogant and so completely rude that if I ever related to clients in that manner at my job I'm sure I'd be let go. I know we're in hard times and finding people to work is difficult but I'd rather answer my own phones than have these people represent my business I think Gary is a nice guy he seems to be he's always been professional and kind I think he needs to sit down and talk to his people about the
Kimberly Rosario
Kimberly Rosario
Oct 31, 2021
Report
My first insurance company and they’re always there for me when I need them most. My first car accident they helped me understand how everything works and provided all the information I needed. They work quick and effective to get what I need done. And are always by my side when it matters. Great low prices and great insurance quotes that work best for me financially. Don’t hesitate they are worth looking into!
Valerie Campione
Valerie Campione
Sep 19, 2021
Report
Absolutely had the best experience with Gary’s insurance. I spoke with Tova. She was professional and polite. Walked me through what coverages I need to insurance all my personal items. I loved that she quoted 3 different companies for my car. Explained what I need for home insurance. One stop shopping. I’m lucky to have an agent like Tova. Insurance isn’t fun but Tova made it a pleasure. I highly recommend calling them. Even if the rate is higher the customer service is unbeatable.