Worthy Cakes & Supplies
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Worthy Cakes & Supplies
Our start was with the love of baking, and designing unique cakes for those special days. To this day, we continue and have expanded that tradition to share with our local community. We take pride in our custom cake designs, and want to ensure that magic for your special event. Due to this, we have limited availability, and are typically booked for 2-3 weeks in advance.

To get started, please email us at info@worthycakes.com or use the contact form on the Contact Page to speak with a Custom Cake Specialist. You can also call us directly for faster assistance. A flagship product of ours, called "Jakes", or cake, in a jar! It's that simple, yet so delicious. We provide these eight (8) ounce jars that come with their own spoon, and available in all of our favorite flavors.
Reviews (20)
Aiza Skelton
Aiza Skelton
Jan 02, 2022
Report
Awesome cake! My husband turned thirty and I ordered a cake from Worthy Cakes for his birthday! It was delicious-moist and so so awesome! I sent over a photo and ordered via e-mail. Super easy process and with short notice they were able to make the cake and make it exactly as I wanted it. You will not be disappointed! Will be ordering from here again! I have ordered many of these cakes for many different events from several different places in Orlando that are much pricier and regard themselves as high-end....I have often found these vendors to be difficult to work with and hard to reach as well
Aimee S.
Aimee S.
Dec 30, 2021
Report
The cake was delicious and the design was beyond expectations! The frosting under the fondant was well portioned and very tasty. The design process was easy and their suggestions were wonderful. The cake was packaged well and transported easily.
Renee D.
Renee D.
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Simply Delicious! I used them for my husband's 50th birthday cake. I loved the vanilla flavored cake and their buttercream icing is simply delicious! They were very easy to work with and picking up the cake at their location in WG is very convenient.
Ignacio Vasquez
Ignacio Vasquez
Nov 04, 2021
Report
The cake looked amazing. The creativity surpassed my expectations. It tasted as good as it looked. Thank you so much for creating such great memories. I will be back for more cakes in the near future.
Cecily Boche
Cecily Boche
Oct 14, 2021
Report
I ordered some push-up cakes for my daughters first birthday and they were amazing! The cake was perfectly moist and the frosting was not overwhelming! They even offered us a no charge smash cake for her to go with my order. They are very responsive and on time with pickup! Looking forward to future orders
Arlisa
Arlisa
Sep 02, 2021
Report
This is no ordinary bakery! The keto treats, cookies and cakes are phenomenal. They taste very fresh, homemade and baked with love. Worthy Cakes was a HUGE hit at our #KetoOrlandoSummit and I can't wait to order more. Thanks for the deliciousness 😋
Renee M.
Renee M.
Jul 31, 2021
Report
I was referred to Worthy Cakes by a Keto Coach since I was going to be in Orlando Florida for my birthday. I can bake cakes and I Love Red Velvet Cakes but every time I try some one else’s Red Velvet Cake they miss the beat by adding red food coloring to a chocolate cake and they call it Red Velvet. Well, let me tell you all this, the Keto Red Velvet Cake from Worthy Cakes is awesome. It taste like Red Velvet Cake, it was very moist and served a cute jar. The service you receive is top notch; they are so nice make you feel like family. When I am in Orlando FL, I will go back Worthy Cakes.
C. I. C.
C. I. C.
Jul 30, 2021
Report
Got the cutest cakes from here! Worthy Cakes provided me the kindest service and beautiful, yummy desserts. Not to mention their delicious banana pudding and Oreo cheesecake! Will definitely be coming here again!
Karen J.
Karen J.
Jun 14, 2021
Report
Worthy Cakes made the most beautiful cake for my mother's eightieth birthday! My sister in law ordered it, and it was perfect. I'm so glad to have learned of them! I live 30 minutes away, but I will be traveling the distance to buy from Worthy Cakes in the future! Excellent!
Corrine Cardona
Corrine Cardona
Jun 04, 2021
Report
Rave: loved my delicious classic red velvet cake with cream cheese icing from Worthy Cakes! Great bakery that makes gluten free, Keto, sugar free, vegan, & regular cakes (and cake jars, cake push pops/shooters, etc). It’s been hard to find a really good gluten free cake so I’m thankful to have found them. It was so good I had to double check the label & ingredient list to confirm it really was gluten free lol Texture was perfect, taste was delicious, & you can see how gorgeous it looked to boot! Highly recommend!
Jeff H.
Jeff H.
May 23, 2021
Report
The cakes in a jar were extremely dry and there were no dates on them so who knows how long they were there prior to purchase. Terrible.
Torrie W.
Torrie W.
Apr 25, 2021
Report
I'm so excited to have a cake decorator with a variety of options for the health conscious. Hopefully I don't get addicted to this place before my birthday and expand a size. I'm pretty sure their vegan and gluten free options will be my number one choice for awhile. Being a peanut butter fool, that will most certainly be my next choice!
Chanele S.
Chanele S.
Apr 06, 2021
Report
As a family that now has diet restricts finding desserts and cakes are such a difficult thing! My sisters birthday was coming up I couldn't find a bomb sugar free cake to save my life! On the day of her birthday I discovered Worthy Cakes not even 10 mins from my house! How had I missed this?!

I enter and a super friendly lady helped me out. We found 4 (keto) cake jars that were sugar free products! Omg I couldn't believe it. I got everyone their own flavor and I got myself a red velvet cookie with cream cheese frosting, also sugar free!

When I tell you everyone was so happy. I will
Laura G.
Laura G.
Dec 16, 2020
Report
As soon as you walk through the door of Worthy Cakes you feel the love. I was greeted with warmth and genuine smiles. This is a family owned and operated small business that takes pride in the quality and service that they give to the community.

Worthy cakes sells keto , gluten free, vegan and traditional cakes. Every category displayed looked delicious but I was in the market for traditional cakes. I had my choice of ten flavors and went with the vanilla birthday cake, strawberries and cream and tres Leches. All three of the cakes were moist and loaded with flavor. They cost $7.00 for a small
Glenda R.
Glenda R.
Dec 04, 2020
Report
This was my first time at their shop. Pre Covid, I would enjoy their delightful cakes in a jar at the Lake Eola Sunday market.

This location is tucked on the strip mall to the left of Marco's pizza.

I am a lover of sweets, and in my pursuit of great pistachio cakes Worthy Cakes does not disappoint.

I would definitely recommend their large cakes in a Jar $9 vs. their small cakes in a jar at $7.
Jill O.
Jill O.
Jul 16, 2020
Report
I discovered Worthy Cakes at the Winter Garden Farmers Market last year. Their cake in a jar is perfect! Great for a simple treat. They have so many flavor options you will never get bored. Keto friendly too!
Marc H.
Marc H.
Jun 21, 2020
Report
I tried out Worthy Cakes on a recommendation of a friend, and I wasn't disappointed. I've been trying to exclude sugar from everything I eat (which is difficult), and Worthy Cakes is a great help with their keto offerings. Frankly, we really need more options like Worthy Cakes where you can find true sugar free food products with no artificial sweeteners (they use monk fruit to sweeten their keto products).

I picked up three of their keto cakes in a jar (pecan, red velvet and lemon drop) and one of their chocolate keto cakes. I've only eaten the pecan and red velvet (the others
Chantal H.
Chantal H.
May 30, 2020
Report
Worthy Cakes is the place to go to get all of your baking needs, specialty cakes, or cakes in general. Everyone is super nice and helpful. The selection of cakes is wonderful as well as accommodating dietary needs with their vegan and keto cakes as well! I will always go to Worthy cakes for all of my cakes. I highly recommend supporting this local business
The cake they did for my daughters 5th grade graduation turned out amazing!
Cora N.
Cora N.
Mar 26, 2020
Report
Last year, I ordered a custom cake for my son's birthday. At the big box stores, I couldn't find a Hot Wheels design so I contacted Worthy Cakes. The cake they created was not only delicious, but it was amazingly designed and my son loved it!

Fast forward to this year:
First, I've already ordered my sons birthday cake for this year (by his request! He specifically asked for me to order from the same place as last year). Can't wait to see it!
Second, we are presently going through the COVID-19 pandemic, and I saw on Facebook they had keto desserts. Since I'm on the keto
Kim V.
Kim V.
Mar 12, 2020
Report
What a cute little shop! The owners are husband and wife and they were both very nice. I picked out my birthday cake from the pre-made selection. They also had a LOT of vegan and keto options as well. The shop does cake classes, too! The cake was delicious!