Michael Anthonys Pizza
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Michael Anthonys Pizza
Call, or stop in today, and treat yourself to a handmade pizza or homemade Italian beef sandwich. Planning a party? There's no better way to celebrate a special occasion than by serving up some hot, fresh pizzas, hand-crafted sandwiches, or pasta trays. We offer catering for birthdays, schools, businesses, anniversaries, and any other occasion you can celebrate.
Reviews (28)
Susan Pleune
Susan Pleune
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Best Pizza- they also offer a Gluten Free version- Fire grilled wings one of a kind!
Friendly atmosphere.
Dine in. Take out or Delivery Catering too
Juan Murillo
Juan Murillo
Nov 26, 2021
Report
If it was possible I would give 0 minus stars , don't understand how you can have 4 star reviews . Making someone wait 1+ hours to get garbage pizza that looks like throw up. Have the cooks own up to there mistake instead of blaming others .
Chris C.
Chris C.
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Definitely good pizza. Nice menu with a wide variety of choices among pizza, sandwiches, burgers, and Italian plates. I almost got the baked lasagna, which sounded amazing, but really wanted to try the pizza. I ordered the St. Christopher, which has Italian beef, pepperoni, mozzarella and ricotta. It was very good, and I got about 3/4 of a 12" pie down by myself with little problem. The only issue is the pizza also has giardiniera peppers on it, and they really make the pizza pop. If you don't like spicy stuff, you had best order the pizza minus the peppers.

They offer thin crust, pan
Jen Knoll Jenknoll
Jen Knoll Jenknoll
Nov 13, 2021
Report
Pizza is good but their BBQ wings and cheesy garlic bread are both amazing! Definitely ordering again.
Dan D.
Dan D.
Nov 05, 2021
Report
Amazing pizza! Its hard to come across a good thin slice in the Chicagoland area, especially thin crust. I would definitely recommend the St. Christopher. Hands down favorite pizza, especially if you're a fan of Italian beef and giardiniera peppers. Great staff, quick, polite, and SUPER clean. Definitely would recommend!
Lindsey B.
Lindsey B.
Oct 25, 2021
Report
Updating review after the owner provided nice feedback. The food we were able to eat was very good and delivery-while it said would take over an hour, actually arrived well before that. If you have dietary restrictions though, I would make it a point to note that when ordering or call ahead as not all ingredients are listed.
Martika Gartman
Martika Gartman
Oct 23, 2021
Report
Very yummy chopped salad and ribs. The ribs were tender and very tasty. The salad had a kick to it. Tony was very kind and the pizza looked and smelled amazing us we loved the fries and Cole slaw. You gotta try this place!
Jessica Melone Cogley
Jessica Melone Cogley
Sep 12, 2021
Report
Received wrong entree, was told we would get 10% off of something we didn't want. Refused that and asked for entree that was ordered. New order was good. Although a sandwich that was ordered had good quality, it lacked quantity in it. I've got several friends who love this place, hoping Friday was a fluke.
Karen Tummillo
Karen Tummillo
Aug 29, 2021
Report
I love this Michael Anthony’s!!! The food is delicious the staff is wonderful always friendly! If I could I’d give them 10 ⭐️
Thank You again!!😉😉
Amo Ruiz
Amo Ruiz
Aug 28, 2021
Report
We ordered a large cheese thin crust pizza and smashed the whole thing in literally ten minutes. The sauce was flavorful and we ordered extra cheese and it was perfect! The kids loved it we’ll be back we love our pizza.
Laura G.
Laura G.
Aug 22, 2021
Report
I was craving pizza and was in the neighborhood with my mom, went on Yelp to see what was near by, saw the reviews, decided to go and wow! The pizza was amazing. Been there 2 times already and the people that work there are nice! Very homie feeling! This is my mom's and I place to go for pizza when I visit my mom.
Daniel Alberti
Daniel Alberti
Jul 17, 2021
Report
Thank you for the, "Welcome to the Neighborhood" pizza, we really enjoyed it! It reminded me of one of my favorite thin crust pizzas from my friends restaurant, Balistreri's in Wisconsin, so it felt a little like being back home. We will definitely be back!...and I look forward to trying your canoli!
Jeffry S.
Jeffry S.
Mar 25, 2021
Report
Well I never would have ordered from here a second time, but the kids did and it was a bit better than the only other time I had tried them. Delivery was quick and the order was correct and the pizza hot. This is mainly the reason I would kick the rating up a star, S the pizza was still a little bland and definitely under-sauced.
Maddie C.
Maddie C.
Mar 23, 2021
Report
This is one of my favorite pizza spots in Villa Park. It's more on the pricier side, but it's definitely worth it. I've gotten them a few times, but I have to say my favorite pizza of theirs is their thin crust white pizza! The white pizza is topped with a variety of cheese and a ranch based sauce to top it all off. It was phenomenal! Their crust is always crispy and their cheese is melted to perfection without it being greasy. Another good pizza option from them is the St. Christopher. The St. Christopher pizza consists of Italian beef, giardiniera, pepperoni, ricotta, and mozzarella
Matthew S.
Matthew S.
Mar 22, 2021
Report
Delicious personal sized pizza. Stopped selling lunch slices due to lack of customer lunch traffic.
Lacey Mizell
Lacey Mizell
Jan 07, 2021
Report
Wow!!! Having lived in the city for the past 3 years, I’ve had no shortage of good pizza experiences. This place is tops on my list, we tried a stuffed pizza along with a St. Christopher special. Exactly what I want in a pizza, quality ingredients, perfect dough texture and lots of toppings. Chopped salad is delicious and it has TONS of basil in it which I LOVED!!!
This was quite a nice surprise and a gem in Villa Park.
Thank you so much for a wonderful food experience!!!
Brendec B.
Brendec B.
Dec 04, 2020
Report
I order pizza there frequently on Friday night. The thin crust pizza is amazing and i enjoy the wings. The staff is really friendly. I've tried many pizza places in the area and this is a gem.
Justin S.
Justin S.
Nov 22, 2020
Report
I ordered a thin crust sausage pizza and the Combo Platter for an appetizer. My favorite part of the combo platter was the broccoli cheese puffs. Lots of pizza choices in the area and would definitely add to the rotation but not necessarily make it the "go-to"

Hopefully indoor dining will open soon and I can review the actual location instead of just delivery.
Joy P.
Joy P.
Oct 03, 2020
Report
The most authentic pizza in the west suburbs. I love their chicken wingso as well, very flavorful.
Steve K.
Steve K.
Jul 06, 2020
Report
Cross another great tavern style thin crust off my list. The crust on their pizza is the same no matter where you grab from. Everything I enjoy about a tavern style thin crust is at this place. Would highly recommend and will definitely try again!
Richard McKee
Richard McKee
Jun 24, 2020
Report
I’m in town for work and after looking over the menu, I had to order. Definitely not to be disappointed. The young lady that took my order was polite and patient ( I had to look up my hotel address and was not familiar with a Panzerotti).
I just received my meal, which is meat tortellini and a baked panzerotti. Not only is the food amazing but they added in utensils and paperware. Now, while these things don’t seem like that big of a deal to have with an order, I travel quite a bit and it’s very rare to have a restaurant include those things.
Thank you for a great dinner!
A. R.
A. R.
Jun 08, 2020
Report
For me and my hubby to have found you on yelp! I am pleased, to say our food was great! It was fresh, tasty and delicious!!!! We will be eating again.
Elissa P.
Elissa P.
May 19, 2020
Report
We've been getting pizza from michael Anthony'sfor a while; always so good. Recently, we decided to try some of their other menu items and were just as pleased. It's hard to find a good eggplant parm sandwich around here. Michael Anthony's uses amazing bread, the eggplant isn't mushy, the sauce is perfect and just the right amount of mozz. The pasta dishes are all cooked perfectly, every sauce we've tried, tasty. Highly recommend!
George H.
George H.
Jul 09, 2019
Report
Outstanding thin crust pizza some of the best I've had in the west suburbs. Pizza sauce was delicious and cooked to perfection. Staff was friendly and super nice. Prices are pretty reasonable. I will definitely be back for more. Also was clean inside.
Abby B.
Abby B.
Jun 08, 2019
Report
This place is amazing!
Let's start by saying the appraiser broccoli cheese puffs are heaven in a bite.
Also the best thin crust pizza in the burbs and get this at a reasonable price!!!! The red gravy sauce doesn't give me any acid reflex please note that this does have meat in it BUT the red marinara doesn't have meat in it and is just as amazing!! Omar recommends all of the best pizza toppings ask to speak with him and you'll be set!!! Also don't leave without getting a homemade breadsticks

PS ask to speak with Omar of you want your pizza to be cooked the best
Morris N.
Morris N.
May 21, 2019
Report
Good local pizza place that mostly caters to deliveries and carry-outs although they do have a few tables if you'd like to eat there. They have a pretty extensive menu although we've only had their pizza and wings. The thin crust pizza is good and made with fresh ingredients. I really liked the pizza sauce and sausage. The wings were OK but a bit overdone.
J. P. P.
J. P. P.
Apr 12, 2019
Report
I was looking to take a bite of nostalgia, and a thin crust pizza as well.

The neon 'Pizza' sign out front sends a beacon of light that immediately attracts you attention. It has that vintage appeal much like the interior of the Pizzeria; four tables, three booths, red checkered table cloths and an open kitchen for your viewing pleasure.

A neighborhood style pizza joint that offers a believable 60's retro look. Places like this remain tempting; oversized booths are a natural attraction while the only missing pieces are pitchers of beer and a cigarette machine.

As for the pizza
Christian K.
Christian K.
Oct 03, 2016
Report
Our company was doing some repairs at Ovaltine Court for about two months and this was our go to spot.
Service is amazingly fast and friendly. Shannon was lovely to talk to while waiting for my to go orders. The cooks were super friendly and can cook up a mean NY Strip Sandwich.
As far as the food goes, I can honestly say that I haven't had a single item on the menu I didn't enjoy.
Pizza by the slice is delicious and a helluva deal 2 slices and a can of pop for less than $4 if you get a meaty topping, cheaper if you opt for plain cheese.
The cheeseburgers are fantastic, very filling