Grateful Deli
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Grateful Deli
Grab a platter or order a sandwich to stay we'll make sure you will get the best service you deserve, it's like home eating here! Or take it go as you go to work, choosing from our quick selections of freshly daily pre-made Gourmet Wraps, Fruits, Desserts, and more!

For 20 years our service was known for having great sandwiches, catering services, and hospitality as a family-owned delicatessen business, from locations such as Manhattan, Queens, & eventually to Long Island!I stop here on my way to work, I'm always greeted warmly and we usually laugh about something.
Reviews (24)
John S.
John S.
Oct 31, 2021
Report
This place never gets my order right. Last time I ordered a breakfast sandwich with bacon and I got home and it was just bacon on the sandwich no eggs or cheese. This time I ordered two sandwiches bacon egg and cheese and sausage egg and cheese. And people bought both with ketchup. Neither one of them have ketchup and they forgot the sausage. So inconvenient and they write down on the paper what's gonna go on the sandwich for The Cook. I question whether or not The Cook is sober or just doesn't care.?? Oh well next time I drive an extra five minutes and go someplace else.
M. D.
M. D.
Oct 30, 2021
Report
I ordered several trays of food for my daughter's wedding (getting ready in the morning).
All the trays were very full and arranged beautifully. The fruit was ripe, the wraps were fresh and the veggie and cheese/cracker trays were huge! Michelle was wonderful to work with.
Pat C.
Pat C.
Oct 24, 2021
Report
This is a real deli. Cold cuts, salads, pastries, sandwiches, wraps, etc. They open very early so I can get on my way and are very accommodating. They'll put whatever you want in a sandwich. In the morning I get a BLT with avocado, no mayo, salt or pepper. Extra bacon. They don't give me a blank stare like other stores or a negative comment. Their comment is that sounds good...and it is. Very positive attitude and very nice people. Love stopping there.
Tom Wright
Tom Wright
Oct 21, 2021
Report
The place is done up with GD items but you'd think that you might hear GD music.....Noooo.
Elaine Meyer-Syrkin
Elaine Meyer-Syrkin
Aug 14, 2021
Report
The best wrap I ever had. Turkey wrap with sliced thin green apple. I ordered it 2 days in a row. Lovely and caring family. 💕
Lance G.
Lance G.
Jul 09, 2021
Report
Serviceable deli, food is nothing special. If you want Turkey on a roll, it's fine. However, I resent that the owners are using the greatest American band for marketing their business. The staff all have Grateful Dead t-shirts, they play videos of the band on the TV, but when I asked who is the Deadhead, the girl laughed and said, "we are just using the theme". Yuck.
L. Q.
L. Q.
Jul 03, 2021
Report
Don't pass up the opportunity to stop in and enjoy a wonderful experience. The staff always welcome you with a smile and are so friendly. They offer a great variety of hot or cold sandwiches and meals. They also have deli salads and pastries. This family owned and operated business is amazing. I go every chance I get. Try them, they may become one of your favorite places.
Katherine T.
Katherine T.
Jun 10, 2021
Report
I was really excited to get a delicious, healthy salad from this deli. We have been loyal customers for years getting their sandwiches and LOVE them. So, I thought it was nice to have healthier salad options. I ordered the Tuscan salad which includes grilled chicken, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, avocados and lettuce. I was very upset with the amount of ingredients that came in the salad - while the amount of grilled chicken was fine the rest was about less than 1/4 cup of mozzarella, less than 1/4 cup of roasted red peppers and two thin, small slivers of avocado and then about 4 giant cups
Diane McConnell
Diane McConnell
May 15, 2021
Report
Always a wonderful experience. Fresh food, very clean place and super friendly service. Definitely recommend!
Julie D.
Julie D.
Apr 24, 2021
Report
I just picked up a good sized order and the staff at this deli was absolutely wonderful. Food looks fresh and there's a wide variety to choose from. Highly recommend.
Andrea Vignola
Andrea Vignola
Jan 14, 2021
Report
Clean deli, covid protected, food was delish. Somehow I thought I woukd see grateful dead items and music here. None to be found but I did enjoy a delicious avocado blt!
Trish R.
Trish R.
Aug 23, 2020
Report
This place has a lot of options whether you're vegan, gluten free, dairy free, etc. Very delicious and fast service! It hads loads of options from breakfast, lunch, and dinner ranging from things like, hot food, salads, sandwiches, burgers, etc..

5/5 rating
Le R.
Le R.
Jul 12, 2020
Report
I love this spot, they have delicious sandwiches, salads, wraps, etc and are so sweet and accommodating if you have any dietary restrictions and need to personalize an order. My go-to spot whenever I'm out here.
Phil Probert
Phil Probert
Jun 17, 2020
Report
Our favorite deli in town. And not just because it’s down the street. There are a few others nearby but this deli has it all and the owners go above and beyond to welcome you. They truly appreciate our business and let you know every time. We’ve been coming here for years for everything from breakfast sandwiches to picnic lunches to grab n go snacks for the boat. They never disappoint and are always smiling. Love this place!
Nolan Kier
Nolan Kier
Oct 12, 2019
Report
Stopped here for a sandwich right before we began our wine explorations. The breakfast sandwiches were perfect! They hit the spot and the space is so cozy. The desserts look amazing too and we couldn't help but grab a brownie on the way out. Good coffee and the owners are the nicest people ever.
Katie M.
Katie M.
Oct 07, 2019
Report
Great little deli for breakfast or lunch sandwiches. Food is always fresh, and the staff is amazing! Great selection of food, chips, drinks, etc. Highly recommend for takeout sandwiches on the North Fork - whether you're heading to the wineries or to the beach.
Cathie M.
Cathie M.
Jul 10, 2019
Report
Fresh Deli sandwiches made to order. Have been here many times. Quick service by helpful staff. Stopped by after closing one day last week and they saw us and while we were walking to car they invited us In and to make sandwiches.
Ben M.
Ben M.
Aug 14, 2018
Report
Very cute little deli. The counter is very pretty and the food looks delicious. We all ordered lunch food and it was all delicious. Only complaint was that the chocolate chip muffin was a little dense. I saw that for a flower bed they were growing vegetables which I thought was very nice and sustainable. If they use those veggies in the store, it would be even cooler! The best part was the owners. They were extremely attentive and cared a lot about their customers and how they were served. I wish I were a local here, the owner knew every local who walked in the door. Very caring people.
Anthony P.
Anthony P.
Jan 15, 2018
Report
Awesome deli good food fast service. The owner is always smiles and is always friendly.
Benjamin B.
Benjamin B.
Aug 27, 2017
Report
Our go to spot for delicious deli sandwiches! Much better than Wayside across the street. We get a hero with turkey, havarti, lettuce, tomato, red onion, spicy peppers, mayo and avocado. Perfectly made every time... So good!
Garrett A.
Garrett A.
May 28, 2017
Report
Good little deli. Fresh ingredients. Large Subs (think better than subway for the same price). They have pre-made wraps and salads, as well as good sides (pasta salad, Vermont chicken salad, etc). If you're looking for a LI deli, this lives up to that for sure.
Carrie T.
Carrie T.
Dec 21, 2015
Report
I stop here on my way to work, I'm always greeted warmly and we usually laugh about something. Great way to start my day!! The food is really good, fresh and made daily, not to mention the coffee. But lets talk about it anyway ;) I don't know how they can make it taste that good...
The owners and staff are simply wonderful and it has to be one of the cleanest deli's I have ever been in. If you are looking for a new place to stop look no further!!!
Shu Jin S.
Shu Jin S.
Oct 13, 2013
Report
I'll admit. We'd had a couple glasses of wine at neighboring vineyards, arrived just a little tipsy and starving. The owners are so incredibly nice, and I ordered a Philly steak wrap, a bag chips and a giant (much needed) bottle of water. My wrap was piping hot and delicious.

Service is fast and very friendly. What a lifesaver!
Benjamin M.
Benjamin M.
Jan 20, 2012
Report
This place is ridiculously awesome for the North Fork. It's a few notches up from what we're accustomed to at local deli's. Like, avocado? Seriously?

They are also quick and friendly. Woo!