Name: Sterlington Deli
Address: 3 Sterlington Cmns, Greenport, NY, 11944, US
Telephone: (631) 477-8547
Rating: 4.93

The Schultz family has a rich history of owning and operating delicatessens over the past few decades, preparing fresh, traditional deli classics from breakfast sandwiches and platters to hearty lunch specials. The Sterlington Deli is located in Greenport New York near the Shelter Island Ferry and is a great place to stop and get a bite to eat on the run or dining in.

Their friendly staff is waiting for your order 7 days a week. Keep us in mind for not only your day to day needs, but for your personal and professional catered events.

Website Update

Reviews (15)

Write a Review

Ray Jacobsen

Feb 01, 2022

Report

Awesome place for breakfast and lunch.
I'm a New Yorker living in Virginia, they have real Kaiser rolls and real bagels, the food is made fresh too. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Craig Smith

Jan 02, 2022

Report

Bacon egg and cheese is worth the trip out. Friendly atmosphere and service. Don’t tell too many people about it. See you there!

Aurora Richard

Nov 30, 2021

Report

Was staying in Greenport for a few nights over Thanksgiving holidays and came upon this gem. The owner was very welcoming and recommended the BEC on a roll which was delicious! Hearty portion of crispy bacon makes the sandwich! Highly recommend!

Justine Hand

Oct 30, 2021

Report

Place was packed on a Wednesday morning at 11:30am yet I was in and out in moments with one of the best breakfast sandwiches I have had in a while 😋 plus very friendly staff. Im thinking I will need to go back again today!! 🙃

Nicole Dobranski

Oct 02, 2021

Report

Fred and his staff over at sterlington are amazing. We recently worked with them for our wedding morning of breakfast catering as well as day after wedding brunch catering and it was all just wonderful. Fred is the best to work with, he immediately makes you feel like family. 10/10 would recommend.

Kaylee La Spisa

Aug 01, 2021

Report

Little pricey, but good service! Bagels are solid, believe it or not, my baconegg&cheese had too much bacon on it. Pretty good, used to come a lot when I was working on the Firefighter.

Henry Stebner

Jul 24, 2021

Report

Small Town style deli, off the main street while the"in spots" are crowded you can usually find a seat here, large menu, made to order , fast service. What's not to like.

Mark Balcerak

Jul 23, 2021

Report

Great place to stop for lunch if you're in the area or on the way to the ferry. Large selection of sandwiches and they don't skimp on ingredients. Everything is fresh and comes out tasty. Good variety of local and area side items, too.

Maureen Derose

Jun 29, 2021

Report

So I hosted a brunch the day after my daughter’s wedding, the food was amazing! Fred was so great when I called him to add more food. He was so accommodating. Fred called me after the event to make sure I was happy.. I highly recommend this amazing place because the food is awesome but the owner is incredibly accommodating.

Matt Still

Jun 29, 2021

Report

I've lived all over the US and this is easily the best deli I've ever been to. They are friendly, generous with the pickles and develop a rapport with their patrons. The sandwiches are unreal. If I could give it 6 stars I would.

Doreen Tohill Crowe

Apr 20, 2021

Report

Amazing service and food! Breakfast catered for 2 separate events and could not be happier with everything we got!! Food was delivered fresh, hot and delicious! So easy to work with too! Thank you Sterlington Deli and Fred for everything!! We will definitely recommend and use again!!

Grant Hinkle

Oct 24, 2020

Report

Awesome food and friendly folks! If you're in greenport check them out!

Diana DeJesus

Mar 24, 2020

Report

Best breakfast sandwiches.People come from miles around.Friendly staff!!

Len Van Vliet

May 21, 2019

Report

Nice place to sit and have breakfast. good food, nice people, local crowd, very enjoyable!

Fred Rice

Sep 08, 2018

Report

Got a couple great turkey sandwiches there this morning which we ate at Orient Point State Park.