After 31 years in Batavia, Ficarella's Pizzeria is now the oldest family run pizzeria in town! Our menu for sit down, pickup or delivery includes a huge variety of pizza, hot and cold subs, fish fries, pasta, salads, side dishes and specialty sandwiches. Everything is made fresh and with great care.
New items appear regularly as do the new customers who discover that quality food, friendly service and consistency are all an integral part of the Ficarella's business model. Sign up for our ONLINE Loyalty Program and earn points toward FREE FOOD! We've added some new items!
New items appear regularly as do the new customers who discover that quality food, friendly service and consistency are all an integral part of the Ficarella's business model. Sign up for our ONLINE Loyalty Program and earn points toward FREE FOOD! We've added some new items!
Reviews (8)
Keith Gierke
Dec 26, 2021
Report
Recognize the greatness,
I love pizza and there is only two joints in town that have good zaa. Ficarella's and "Unmentioned." This is a Ficarella review. I have seen the reviews here and I am astonished at what some people have said. Your subs are giant, deals are good and not to mention, best boneless wings in town. so you had a pizza underdone.... what if there was a new worker? Perhaps next time go to the store for you issues instead of the internet. Good job to all that make it possible.
I love pizza and there is only two joints in town that have good zaa. Ficarella's and "Unmentioned." This is a Ficarella review. I have seen the reviews here and I am astonished at what some people have said. Your subs are giant, deals are good and not to mention, best boneless wings in town. so you had a pizza underdone.... what if there was a new worker? Perhaps next time go to the store for you issues instead of the internet. Good job to all that make it possible.
Richard Erhardt
Dec 16, 2021
Report
Stephanie Steigerwald
Sep 21, 2021
Report
Jonnyonwheels
Aug 21, 2021
Report
After just moving out to Batavia we decided to try Ficarella’s after getting their flier in the mail (and being able to order online). Pizza and wings were piping hot when they arrived at my door. Ordered right in the middle of peak dinner time (5:45p)on a Thursday and it showed up in an hour. Driver was friendly and polite. Fresh dough, good sauce(flavor & amount), good amount of cheese and pepperoni, bottom crust had a little more chew than expected but not bad, could just be the hearth oven or b/c they were busy? Wings were good, mild sauce was tangy and not too much heat. Will definitely
Chad Higgins
Aug 20, 2021
Report
Liz Lawrence
Jul 17, 2021
Report
Absolutely hands down the most genuine restaurant I have ever been to. As out of towners we showed up at 9:55PM, not realizing they close at 10PM. They invited us to dine in with the full open menu, smiles on their faces, the most personable employees. Their food was excellent! Just an overall great atmosphere! Thank you for being so accommodating, very much appreciated!
- The Blovat and Lawrence family- Ilion NY
- The Blovat and Lawrence family- Ilion NY
John Satella
Jul 03, 2021
Report
Ordered the party deal on Sunday and everything was cooked to perfection. Pizza was very tasty and the dough was perfect. Wings were cooked perfect and the amount of sauce was just right...they weren't swimming in sauce and they weren't dry. Best pizza place in Batavia hands down. I don't think I've ever had a bad meal here and i've been coming here for over 15 years.
Terry Barber
Aug 05, 2019
Report
Reminisce the way pizza is supposed to taste. Portion sizes for land locked giants and hungry patrons. Staff were very friendly and even referred other restaurants in the area for other cuisine options. I was immediately taken back to memory lane for northeast pizzerias that bring you in from the cold and warm you up with cheesy and freshly baked crust. Pepperonis were real and sausage was super flavorful. I will visit again and bring the wife as she loves Italian cuisine 👍
