Sugar Hi is a destination boutique sweet shop serving freshly baked goods, custom cakes, premium ice cream, trendy freak shakes, hand crafted chocolates, liege hot waffles and a huge selection of bulk and novelty candy. At Sugar Hi we are all about fun! Our baked goods are made from the finest ingredients and are a twist on American Classics like homemade Ring Dings, Pop Tarts, Banana Pudding, S'mores, Snicker Bars and Naughty Brownies.
Our custom cakes are unparalleled in taste and design. Our platters are oversized and fabulous. They can be customized for any event and your corporate gift giving needs. Twin sisters Hillary Assael and Elissa Weinhoff are the team behind SugarHi. They opened SugarHi in 2017 fulfilling a life long dream of starting a business together.
Our custom cakes are unparalleled in taste and design. Our platters are oversized and fabulous. They can be customized for any event and your corporate gift giving needs. Twin sisters Hillary Assael and Elissa Weinhoff are the team behind SugarHi. They opened SugarHi in 2017 fulfilling a life long dream of starting a business together.
Services
Our staff is happy to discuss cake, cupcakes, or other dessert options. Please be aware that our bakers leave by 4:00 p.m., so best to inquire when they can help you! Delivery is on a case by case basis. Sugar Hi can deliver larger cakes locally in Westchester, with a delivery fee, and up to our discretion.
Reviews (9)
Cara Ramirez
Nov 20, 2021
Report
I placed my Thanksgiving order knowing the bakery was 45 mins away, but I was impressed with the reviews and social media presentations. Sadly it wasn’t worth the hype for me. I ordered a cake and pumpkin pie and purchased additional sugar cookies in store when I arrived. The cake was average at best, pumpkin pie good, the 6 cookies I purchased for $27 in store were crack your teeth, rock hard. I attempted eating one on the way home, but was honestly afraid of the dental bill.. I could barely bite them. When I finally got back to NJ my kids immediately went wanted the cookies and turned them
Jackie Almonte
Aug 28, 2021
Report
Banana pudding was amazing.
This was our first time trying had to tell the guy at the register since he continued saying anything else hey let us look it's our first time here my daughter felt rushed so we just ended taking the pudding but I'm sure everything there is amazing! I want to go back and try the cake pudding and more.😋
This was our first time trying had to tell the guy at the register since he continued saying anything else hey let us look it's our first time here my daughter felt rushed so we just ended taking the pudding but I'm sure everything there is amazing! I want to go back and try the cake pudding and more.😋
Chris Giorgio
Oct 03, 2020
Report
I ordered a sprinkle cake for my daughter's college acceptance. The logo of the school is a red dragon. I was disappointed that the logo was orange and not red. I was told they had no control over how it printed. Red is a primary color, so I didn't understand why it wasn't red.
I felt bad for my daughter, so I printed a RED dragon on paper to cover the orange. I was refunded the fee for the logo. On a positive note the cake was delicious. Super moist and very tasty, but I'm not sure if I'd make the 30 minute drive to use them again.
I felt bad for my daughter, so I printed a RED dragon on paper to cover the orange. I was refunded the fee for the logo. On a positive note the cake was delicious. Super moist and very tasty, but I'm not sure if I'd make the 30 minute drive to use them again.
Robert
Jun 14, 2020
Report
Sugar Hi is absolutely amazing!! I ordered a 50th birthday cake for my wife. I wanted a LV (louis vuitton) theme. Hillary assured me that she would make one that was beautiful and boy was she right! I came to pick it up and saw it for the first time. I was stunned at how great it looked. The cake was an absolute hit with everyone especially my wife. Oh and it tasted so good!! I will be definitely coming back to this great place!!!
Mike Snyder
Jun 16, 2019
Report
DragoMon
Jun 14, 2019
Report
Looks like a really nice place. The staff we met were very friendly. The milkshake was really good. We had the Hillary Cake one and it was very good. Red velvet bar and s'omers bar were very good as well. The place was very busy. Parking is very limited and tight. There was a party so there was very limited seating too (only 2 chairs). We will be back soon. I recommend you check it out. It's an awesome please for kids of all ages with a sweet tooth
Tina-Ann Rella Rooney
Dec 22, 2018
Report
Stephanie Pisanchik
Nov 27, 2018
Report
Large selection of baked goods and ice cream. Bakery items were fresh and had an interesting "homemade" twist to them.
However, even though this place is aimed at kids they weren't very friendly to my excited 2 year old, who was amazed at all the goodies. The seating area is small and a bit cramped for any moms looking to bring in a stroller. While my daughter enjoyed her ice cream, the treats we brought home were super super sweet. They were so sweet that we took a few bites and discarded them.
TIP: If you're making the trip to visit them and can, try to do so before school dismissal as it was
However, even though this place is aimed at kids they weren't very friendly to my excited 2 year old, who was amazed at all the goodies. The seating area is small and a bit cramped for any moms looking to bring in a stroller. While my daughter enjoyed her ice cream, the treats we brought home were super super sweet. They were so sweet that we took a few bites and discarded them.
TIP: If you're making the trip to visit them and can, try to do so before school dismissal as it was
Richard Schagrin
Nov 19, 2018
Report
