Costa Pizza
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Costa Pizza
Costa Pizza restaurant, established in 2012 in the heart of New Haven, CT, is a family-owned business. The team at Costa Pizza are experts in catering. Every menu item is available for our catering services and is guaranteed to taste as fresh and appetizing as it looks. We have served many large groups in the community including customers from Yale University and the surrounding businesses for meetings and other special events.

Upon request, we can also serve your business for lunch on a daily basis with Italian food catering. Costa Pizza is one of the leading Italian restaurants in New Haven serving vegan pasta and other vegan Italian food from some of the best vegan brands on the market. Costa Pizza restaurant is one of the best in New Haven, CT, serving Italian salad.
Services
Medley of iceberg, mixed green, romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes, mushroom, cucumber, olives & mixed peppers. Fresh spinach leaves, artichoke hearts, grape tomatoes, cucumber, olives, mushroom, mixed pepper & gorgonzola cheese. Grilled eggplant, mixed greens, artichoke hearts, goat cheese, roasted red peppers, grape tomato & almonds.
Reviews (18)
Carigan M.
Carigan M.
Oct 17, 2021
Report
Really delicious pizza- i got a vegan pie and my friend got one that was gluten free, but ridiculously expensive for a personal pizza pie with a few veggie toppings !
Tia K.
Tia K.
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Haven't had much of an experience with this place, however, we ordered door dash thinking it would be an easy dinner. Our door dash order was apparently picked up by someone. When our door dash driver arrived at the restaurant, they told him the food was picked up, and they refused to remake the order while our driver was there. I work in the industry, and normally when a door dash, grub hub, uber eats, etc. driver picks up food they show the name of the order on their phone to confirm and then are given the corresponding order. It really wouldn't have been difficult to remake our order
Megan B.
Megan B.
Aug 31, 2021
Report
Great vegan options when you're too lazy to cook and want something a little naughty, like a burger & fries!
Eh E.
Eh E.
Mar 05, 2021
Report
Always great and a staple for my late night food cravings. Every pizza I've tried has been delicious and I've tried various appetizers or sandwiches/subs which have also been very good with generous portions.
Bryce W.
Bryce W.
Feb 13, 2021
Report
Costa Pizza has been absolutely delicious everytime I've had it. Tonight the staff made my night and took great care of me! I would definitely recommend anyone looking for late night pizza!
Adam B.
Adam B.
Aug 09, 2020
Report
Awesome food and in a really reasonable amount of time. The food was far better than I was expecting. The entrées, sides and desserts were all amazing. Definitely going to have to go back again!
Lory R.
Lory R.
Jun 05, 2020
Report
K so for starters YES that size large salad is just for me and so is that loaf of bread which I'll regret tomorrow, my belly looks like I'm expecting after that meal too lol. This was honestly soooooooo good it hit every spot in my belly. I had Italian dressing with that fresco salad and garlic bread with marinara. They gave me some garlic knots which weren't tasty but who cares the rest was so good I honestly can say my belly is satisfied. They even packed it all cute too bad I'm a hungry beast and tare the bag up like a feen. I want to just say they could add more dressing
Beau B.
Beau B.
Apr 21, 2020
Report
Very good. Ordered on April 20th during the COVID-19 hysteria and my food was incredible. Ordered a philly cheesesteak and a slice of carrot cake (random items, i know)- and I was still impressed! Will definitely be back!
Faith N.
Faith N.
Jan 28, 2020
Report
Very close to the court house which when on jury duty it is nice. Pizza was good. Thin crust super crunchy, lots of choices fOr the slice. I also got a chicken and cheese sub. That I'll be honest im not impressed with. It has peppers and onions on it which I usually like but it over powered the sub. Stick with the pizza.
Darya V.
Darya V.
Aug 30, 2019
Report
It's delicious pizza! Really good I recommend to try different slices . Tastes like truly Italian
Ryan H.
Ryan H.
Jun 11, 2019
Report
Best pizza in the area family owned and very friendly when you go in take out or dine in, the chicken parmesan is to die for, had it delivered and was very fast Usually don't give reviews to pizza places but had to for them
If you want good food and friendly faces go to costas
Abdelhamed H.
Abdelhamed H.
May 18, 2019
Report
Costa is one of the best pizza's in New Haven. I highly recommend their Mash potato pizza. I live in NYC so I have high standards in pizzas but I highly recommend this place.
Ihab A.
Ihab A.
May 13, 2019
Report
Great pizza. People are friendly. I like their cheese pizza. Also the have phenomenal pasta. Keep it up guys
Christi M.
Christi M.
Jul 25, 2018
Report
Costa Pizza in New Haven, CT is AWESOME!!! I've lived in New Haven for years and not only do they deliver later than most places, their food is delicious. Their pizza is right up there with New Haven finest. The sauce is great and the crust is so flavorful, it's not too oily and not cardboard-like like a lot of these new, expensive gourmet pizza joints that are popping up all over are. Try the Hawaiian pizza with ricotta, yuuuum! The meatballs are excellent too. The staff is super nice and my order is always right. And delivery with a smile, ALWAYS! Delivery is fast and food is always
Manny H.
Manny H.
May 19, 2017
Report
There simply cannot be a smaller pizza shop than this one. But one thing is for sure is that the lunches that were ordered were flying out the door.

That poor cook was non stop working and sweating. Great selections.
Freesia S.
Freesia S.
May 06, 2017
Report
This is my go-to for a late-night slice.

Costa isn't somewhere I find myself unless it's really late at night and there's no where else open, but when it's late and I need some form of sustenance before bed, this is it. I appreciate the late hours and the availability of cheap slices, and I appreciate the late delivery options. The pizza is a solid thin crust with a good amount of greasy, chewy cheese, and it's exactly what I want for a night cap.
Meaghan M.
Meaghan M.
Jul 09, 2015
Report
Pizza and mozzarella sticks were delish! Food was served fast, was piping hot and tasted fresh.
Employees were friendly.

I'm not from the area but if I find myself in New Haven again, I'd visit Costa Pizza again!
Joe C.
Joe C.
Apr 05, 2015
Report
They make a generic New York style pizza which just doesn't fly really well with this New Haven raised boy. Just look at the photo of my slice. Does that look appetizing at all?

Their sign out front advertises the words "Italian cuisine". Ha, saying this place creates Italian cuisine is like saying Burger King creates American cuisine. Give me a break.

To those who say this pizza compares with the other New Haven greats, I really really want to know what you're smoking. Seriously. I think maybe some Yale students are forgetting to turn on their fume hoods in their chem lab