Family owned and located in Schererville, Indiana, we strive to keep our customers happy and coming back for more. We make our own dough and sauce fresh daily, and we use only the highest quality ingredients with which to top our pizzas. We also offer a full menu consisting of salads, appetizers, sandwiches, Pastas and dessert.
Gluten free pizza also available upon request. It was the most beautiful pizza I've had in years. It was prepared with love all the sausages sat on top of the pepperoni and it looked like it belonged on a TV commercial. And it tasted as good as it looked. Thanks for the beautiful pie keep doing what your doing!
Gluten free pizza also available upon request. It was the most beautiful pizza I've had in years. It was prepared with love all the sausages sat on top of the pepperoni and it looked like it belonged on a TV commercial. And it tasted as good as it looked. Thanks for the beautiful pie keep doing what your doing!
Services
At Sicilian Joe's, our desire to share great food drives everything we do. Which is why we'll search high and low for the best ingredients and why we use real family recipes. It's how we've done things for over 15 years. And it's how we'll continue to do things. Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy.
Reviews (8)
Jenkie Jolson
Aug 29, 2021
Report
The 10" pepperoni pizza was delicious. Their pepperonis have a small amount of black pepper on them, which adds a nice, but mild kick of flavor to the pizza. Crust was thin, as we prefer it. The spaghetti with garlic butter sauce was terrific. Super flavorful and less messy than a tomato-based sauce. The breadsticks could be improved upon, as they were too hard and not nearly as tasty as our other menu items. We'll definitely be back though for more of that pizza and spaghetti!
Angelica Smith
Aug 27, 2021
Report
Cheryl Bailey
Jul 19, 2021
Report
Vette In
Jun 03, 2021
Report
Johnny Perez
Jan 06, 2021
Report
Paul Gross
Nov 20, 2020
Report
Jared Rizzo
Aug 18, 2017
Report
I got 24 wings, which were very soggy, looked nasty, and were not that good at all. You have to actually cook wings then put the sauce on, so they are not a pile of sog. Tomato bread, which was literally 1/2 a slice of a bun with 2 tomato slices, and cheese. The bread not baked at all, which would of been pretty good, but since it was not baked it became soggy. Lastly an antipasta salad which was chunks of a giant mess and so far from antipasta it was a joke that went straight to the trash. Their pizza is very expensive, but that may be good, I should have got that. The menu is way too big. When
John Tarrant
Dec 07, 2016
Report
This pizza is by far the best pizza you could get in North West Indiana. The crust is perfect you can really tell it's hand tossed and not frozen like some other places in the area. The sauce is excellent! The pizza sauce isn't too sweet but not bitter at the same time. There is no skimping on the toppings which is a big deal too me. All in all if you want good quality pizza for the price go to Sicilian joes you will not be disappointed!
