Not Your Typical Deli
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Not Your Typical Deli
Not Your Typical Deli is a full service delicatessen and bakery, located in Gilbert, Arizona. We showcase local products and services, including local artists, bakers and other culinary professionals, and provide guests with a unique dining and shopping experience. NYT Deli was created to make a difference, not only do we serve incredible food, we also have an integrated work environment for those with developmental disabilities.

The unemployment rate for adults with Autism Spectrum Disorder in Arizona, is nearly 90%. It is our objective to provide capable adults with developmental disabilities, comprehensive training that will qualify them to work in the restaurant industry. Local culinary businesses will be encouraged to hire our students and they will be informed about the value that our students can bring to their business.
Reviews (27)
KaileyMay
KaileyMay
Feb 01, 2022
Report
Here is one of my favorite spots in Gilbert! The food is delicious and the service is wonderful. They are awesome. Everyone, come eat here!
Jason H.
Jason H.
Feb 01, 2022
Report
Awesome Reuben sandwich, loved the dill
Pickle. Everything else looks Yummy too, if you're looking for a great deli, go here now. I'll be back
Kelli N.
Kelli N.
Jan 30, 2022
Report
My first time here and I loved it ! Friendly people.. clean place! Super FAST service! My pizza sammich was amazing and those cookies are to die for ! I'll be back for sure !
Brian D.
Brian D.
Jan 27, 2022
Report
Always polite and welcoming. Food is excellent and large servings, plenty to fill a hungry guy!
Jonathan S.
Jonathan S.
Jan 23, 2022
Report
Went in on Saturday 1/22/2022 with my family and I ordered a Don Pastrami sandwich and DAMN WHAT A GOOD SANDWICH!!! Best pastrami sandwich I've had in my life for real! Funny thing is I love pastrami but I hate slaw so I actually pretty much just kept an open mind and asked for my slaw on the side just to try NYT's version of coleslaw. The slaw wasn't heavy at all and it didn't taste like straight mayo with no other ingredients. I actually liked NYT's slaw a lot and I ended up putting it in my Don Pastrami sandwich. I also ordered an M&M cookie that was huge and delicious
Amanda D.
Amanda D.
Jan 17, 2022
Report
Amazing place! Great food with huge servings. My kids split a meatball sub. We had a Philly cheesesteak that I would recommend to anyone. Nice people and cute things to purchase off the side. Ohhh and the cookies ... are HUGE. We'll go back for sure!
Thomas P.
Thomas P.
Jan 15, 2022
Report
Love this spot!
Order off the menu or have them build it your way, it is all good.
We've been three times, had something different each time. The cookies are delicious.
Kelsey R.
Kelsey R.
Jan 01, 2022
Report
The Sandwiches are amazing! Always lots of meat with great flavor. It is a little more expensive considering it's sandwiches but I think it's worth it. Didn't care for "the worlds best cookies". They have more of a cake like texture.
Rae T.
Rae T.
Dec 24, 2021
Report
I've heard great things about this deli. I was excited to try it since the area severely lacks in this department. I ordered the pastrami sandwich and a can of soda. This came to a little over $18! Okay the sandwich was good and was seasoned well. They do like on the meat and use just the right amount of brown mustard...but almost $20 for a sandwich and a can of soda? I'm feeling inflation everywhere, gas, groceries and apparently sandwiches. Will I be back? Sure, if I get a raise or sell my kidney on the black market so I can afford to splurge again.
Kelsey J.
Kelsey J.
Dec 11, 2021
Report
I have been wanting to come here for such a long time, and I will say I am pretty disappointed in my visit based on how many 5 star reviews there are! I had the Turkey Pesto and it was just ok, it didn't make me feel like I needed to go back soon. I think maybe I needed to get a different sandwich. Also the fountain drink machine was broken, which is fine but when I asked for a cup of water, I had to have a whole new transaction for a bottle of water. That was pretty disappointing.
Christine G.
Christine G.
Nov 30, 2021
Report
Absolutely excellent deli. The Turkey, bacon ranch ciabatta was excellent. My kids enjoyed the french bread pizza and the spaghetti wuth marinara. The chocolate chip cookies are insanely huge and insanely delicious!! The people were awesome and the food was fantastic. We will definitely be back.
Roy Ward
Roy Ward
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Amazing food. I had a Ruben and it was top notch!
The staff is always friendly. The cookies are mouthwatering good. I will most definitely be back again it's worth the drive!
Courtney B.
Courtney B.
Oct 24, 2021
Report
This place is just amazing. On top of the food being great, the young men who served us our meals were super nice! We got 3 meals abd 4 desserts. HUGE SERVINGS!
Also, the the butter cake (maybe it was a pie) is so good, we got 2 a big cookie, and another dessert. We also got pizza fries, a burger and a pastrami sandwich. Try anything I bet it's all amazing
Christopher Bullard
Christopher Bullard
Oct 22, 2021
Report
Omg the amount of food is amazing! My pics are half aten. Will update the next time I come with better photos.
Bryan D.
Bryan D.
Oct 15, 2021
Report
Had the Rueben and Turkey Club. Fantastic! Good sized portions. Tucked away toward the back next to the Regal theater. We'll worth the drive from queen creek for lunch! Next time bringing our friends from NYC.
Jon K.
Jon K.
Oct 05, 2021
Report
I've eaten the meatball sandwich, the spaghetti sandwich, and the Italian beef sandwich here. For the spaghetti sandwich I made sure to order it with meatballs to get some protein. It was unique but also messy. Still good though. Just be prepared to use utensils. The meatball sandwich is excellent and perfectly toasted. The Italian beef sandwich is enormous and stuffed to the brim, it's definitely going to require utensils as well. I enjoyed it though. You honestly can't go wrong with any of the sandwiches here.

The atmosphere is clean and homely. The employees are always eager
Carlos Schulz
Carlos Schulz
Sep 24, 2021
Report
Have been here several times and everything we come i know why we come back. Food is great, staff is friendly and interactive.
Tuna Melt, Spaghetti Sandwich, Turkey Pesto Sandwich and the Mac and Cheese all were prepared to perfection. Don't even get me started on the baked goods for dessert...sinful! Try the peanut butter cup cookie...wow!
Tracey S.
Tracey S.
Sep 18, 2021
Report
I've been wanting to come here for months due to A. The positive reviews and B. The fact they go out of the way to provide adults with autism with jobs.

The service was very friendly and prompt. We got the pastrami sandwich which was delicious. The meat was sliced a little thin for my taste (I like the NY thick cut which was displayed on their photo) but the flavor and rye bread they chose was delicious.

The decor is adorable and each table had real flowers on it which I thought was a nice touch. We will be back to try more than just the sandwich.
Nina C.
Nina C.
Sep 11, 2021
Report
Yes yes yes! I have been sleeping on this place and not sure why it took so long to try it. We last minute decided to try this place for lunch. My husband has been here before and raves about it. I have been all about deli sandwiches and salads lately. I tried the chopped Italian salad with no cheese, no chickpeas. My husband got the pastrami sandwich and we shared the meats. Damnnnnnnnnnnnnm! Please don't sleep on this place and go get the damn pastrami! I could have eaten a TUB of the pastrami with spicy mustard. The salad was also kick @$$. I am now obsessed. Coming back soon to try the
Alex Rezabek
Alex Rezabek
Jul 16, 2021
Report
Wife and I were finally able to get out on a date and we've heard so much about this place and all the great things this place represents! Hearing that #Stevo had made an appearance here we decided to give it a try! Let me tell you they did not disappoint! Can't wait to go back and try another sandwich and leave room for the massive cookie for desert!
Mike T.
Mike T.
Apr 23, 2021
Report
Stopped by here with a bunch of my coworkers for lunch. Guy taking orders was super friendly and helpful. My coworkers all swear by the Reuben. I decided to try the Pastrami.

Food was delivered very quickly. The pastrami was very good. Very generous amount of pastrami and the rye bread was good. Normally I'm not a big rye fan but I enjoyed it on this sandwich.

I grabbed some of the cookies on the way out and the kids loved them. I took a bite and they were fantastic.
Nisha J.
Nisha J.
Mar 18, 2021
Report
Only gave 3 stars because I was disappointed with my sandwich based on how the menu described it.

I ordered the caprese grilled cheese that was under the hot section. I picturer the cheese to be melted in the sandwich but it was not. The sandwich itself was tasty but I just expected a hot sandwich instead.

We ordered a side of French Fries and the dipping sauces it came with were good!

Will try another sandwich next time though! Everything else on the menu sounded good too!
Alex K.
Alex K.
Jan 01, 2021
Report
Really terrific sandwiches. And LOTS of great choices so I was torn trying to decide. Online ordering was seamless, and the order was brought out to the car (still piping hot) the instant we arrived. Sergio provided great service!

Now onto the specifics... The pressed Italian pork was delicious. I've never had Italian style pulled pork, but the flavor was great and the giardiniera on top packed the perfect crunch and saltiness. The bread was light and just crispy enough from the press. The pastrami sandwich was also fantastic - yummy marbled rye piled very high with meat, so come hungry.
A. Hall
A. Hall
Dec 19, 2020
Report
Delicious! Customer service is the best of any place in the valley. We ordered the Ruben and the club (with potato salad and macaroni salad as sides for additional fee) and both are phenomenal and filling. Also shared an Oreo cookie and a smores stuffed cookie. Huge and satisfying.
Jaici Duncan
Jaici Duncan
Aug 05, 2019
Report
Incredible! Best sandwiches in the valley! I had the Cubano and my husband had the white BBQ pork sandwich! We were greeted immediately upon entering by the owner who gave us recommendations. Very friendly staff and fast service! We will definitely be back soon! Indoor and outdoor seating.
Jo Bolin
Jo Bolin
Jul 29, 2019
Report
Absolutely FANTASTIC! Great atmosphere- community focused and comfortable. The food portions are a wonderful value for the money and shareable... or not... ha! The staff was very friendly and genuine. The cutest decor including fresh flowers on every table- a very nice touch! Food suggestions:
- Reuben (killer, perfect ratio of corned beef to kraut, 1/2 lb, photo attached)
- Roast Beef Sandwich (also very generous)
- Potato Salad (mustard based, but very balanced if you aren't a mustard fan, creamy dressing, chunky red taters, shareable portion)
- Pasta Salad (seemed mustard based as well,
R. W.
R. W.
Jun 05, 2019
Report
Saw that this place won best deli in Arizona so we had to try it. It was amazing. Hubby got the tuna melt to eat there and he got the chicken salad sandwich to go. I got the hot pastrami on an Italian roll to eat there and got the meatball sandwich to go. We got the famous chocolate chip cookie and the Reese’s stuffed cookie. Wow! Nice clean place with friendly and helpful staff. We will go back to try the pasta salad, potato salad and Mac-n-cheese.
Update 10/12/19 evening:
Just had half of my hubby’s chicken salad sandwich (but put it on thin round bread at home) and it is great. So tasty