Phil's Pizzeria & Ristorante of Wantagh is now open and ready to serve you the best Pizza and Italian Food you've ever eaten. With over 35 years of combined restaurant experience, the owners of Phil's Pizzeria & Ristorante promise to give you the Italian food experience you've been waiting for. All of Phil's pizza and entrees are prepared from scratch every day with only the finest and freshest ingredients available that day from the market.
Our sauces, dough and breads are always made fresh daily so that we can keep our customer's taste buds happy and always wanting more of our wonderful, delicious foods.
Our sauces, dough and breads are always made fresh daily so that we can keep our customer's taste buds happy and always wanting more of our wonderful, delicious foods.
Reviews (25)
Pye D.
Jan 26, 2022
Report
Anthony Calabrese
Dec 12, 2021
Report
Nick Lira
Oct 29, 2021
Report
I ordered today at work they said itd take 30 ish mins i said okay thank you...
Cut to an hour 20mins later, my shift ended around 45 mins earlier so im waiting and the guy shows up i tip him say thank you wait for him to stop talking then i go to my car and open it and its literally freezing cold.
If you like hot food and getting stuff on time
This aint it pal
Cut to an hour 20mins later, my shift ended around 45 mins earlier so im waiting and the guy shows up i tip him say thank you wait for him to stop talking then i go to my car and open it and its literally freezing cold.
If you like hot food and getting stuff on time
This aint it pal
Octavio Diaz
Oct 19, 2021
Report
Olivia K.
Oct 15, 2021
Report
My family and I love this place!
To start: Parking is easy, they have a lot out front. Everything is fairly priced! They do special though out the week, depending on the day. They have dining space if you want a quick slice or they have a sit down side!
We come at least once a week, and never have a complaint. Sal, Nino, and all their staff make this place so welcoming and inviting. Alaina is usually our server, she is extremely kind and sweet!
My go to is penne a la vodka. I do have a gluten allergy but they're always able to accommodate me! I've had grilled chicken frandsche which
To start: Parking is easy, they have a lot out front. Everything is fairly priced! They do special though out the week, depending on the day. They have dining space if you want a quick slice or they have a sit down side!
We come at least once a week, and never have a complaint. Sal, Nino, and all their staff make this place so welcoming and inviting. Alaina is usually our server, she is extremely kind and sweet!
My go to is penne a la vodka. I do have a gluten allergy but they're always able to accommodate me! I've had grilled chicken frandsche which
Rosie Tzimas
Oct 12, 2021
Report
Found Phil’s pizzeria ad in my mailbox, went to the place for dinner and loved it. That same night we placed a catering order for 2 parties ( Halloween party and Sweet sixteen ). The food…. AMAZING!! Service was incredible and very helpful . We had 2 great parties thanks to Phil’s pizzeria in Wantagh.
Sandi Vega
Oct 02, 2021
Report
Rich M.
Aug 04, 2021
Report
We ordered 4 dinners to be delivered. Delivery was faster than expected. Phil's is great in that. They really are organized and their staff is excellent. We got 3 parm dinners. The portions were huge and the cheese was above and beyond piled on that it was so heavy to eat. The eggplant was very heavy and oily as was the chicken. It lasted 3 meals because it was so heavy. If you like big portions like this, then Phil's is your place, but we would rather have better food.
Randi Foster
Jul 11, 2021
Report
Don’t know what Zuni Suarez is talking about. Because of the pandemic we ordered from here a lot. Always good, sometimes GREAT. Have actually called on several occasions after a delivery to tell them how good everything was. Always quick & food hot. Prices are satisfactory although price of food everywhere is nuts. I highly recommend.
Marc Kramer
May 30, 2021
Report
I went into this restaurant at 8 pm for 3 slices of Grandma pizza. Only one was available. So what did these guys do? They made me a fresh half pie. Oh and by the way the slices are enormous and delicious. The portions for dinner are also quite large and taste great. The food is always ready on time. Do yourself a favor and give this place a try. You won't regret it.
Zuni Suarez
May 18, 2021
Report
Food is a hit or miss: it’s either good or it’s absolutely terrible but never even enough to be satisfactory. Service is absolutely horrible and the below average quality of food is not enough to make up for it. Poor establishment altogether. Save your money you’re better off going to one of the other 50 different pizzerias in the area. I order from here regularly and order the same dish every time (chicken parm). I don’t think there has ever been a time where I received my complete order without having to call and have them send the delivery driver to deliver what I did not receive. Every
Shan P.
Mar 22, 2021
Report
Boys and gals! Let's take some time out of our day to appreciate the local business!
Phil, my darling you fed me and grammy tonight! We love and appreciate you. The food is mighty scrumptious. The folks behind the counter are most attentive and accommodating!
Thank you Phil's pizza for keeping us gals most happy tonight!!
P.S. Gram thought the alfredo was smashing! Keep it up!
Phil, my darling you fed me and grammy tonight! We love and appreciate you. The food is mighty scrumptious. The folks behind the counter are most attentive and accommodating!
Thank you Phil's pizza for keeping us gals most happy tonight!!
P.S. Gram thought the alfredo was smashing! Keep it up!
Marc Thompson
Mar 12, 2021
Report
Great food and great customer service. Placed a delivery order on Sunday and they made a mistake and set it up as pick up. After an hour I called and they then switched it to delivery unfortunately the food was cold. I called afterwards and spoke to Leo and he apologized and said they would fix it and that my next order was on them. Called today and they got my food out super fast and the food was delicious. Will definitely be ordering more from them!
Samantha R.
Jun 07, 2020
Report
Eric G.
Mar 14, 2020
Report
The pizza is good here but I'm giving it a 1 Star. Today is March 14th 2020. I feel terrible for all the small business owners around here because it's going to take a toll on their businesses for sure. But I'm out spending money and eating at their restaurants. The corona virus is spreading across Long Island like wild fire. Everyone is saying don't shake people's hands, don't touch door knobs....you touch my food that I'm about to eat with your hands after you....
Slapped high fives with a Co worker
Picked up a phone to take an order
Touched a credit card
Accepted
Slapped high fives with a Co worker
Picked up a phone to take an order
Touched a credit card
Accepted
S. B.
Feb 21, 2020
Report
It's just ok. I'm trying to figure out what I'm missing given all the other 4/5 star reviews. I e been here a couple times and ordered different types of slices (including plain) and just didn't enjoy it beyond it satisfying my hunger. It wasn't awful either but compared to others in my immediate vicinity I don't choose it even though it is convenient between my home and the train station daily.
Hoping someone can tell me if it's just me or I'm missing something.
Hoping someone can tell me if it's just me or I'm missing something.
Joe H.
Aug 10, 2019
Report
First, let me say that the pizza is delicious and that the variety is great.
That said, we had an issue last night that we are posting here because GrubHub refuses to take responsibility.
We ordered a Neapolitan pie, half pepperon and meatball and half meatball, mushroom, olives and onion.
With tax, tip and delivery, this came to $50!
When you look on Phil's website, the pie alone is $15.65, half toppings are $2.50 each and 3-4 toppings are $10. There shouldn't be any reason for this pie to reach $50-even with tip and delivery fee.
Not to mention that I never agreed to the tip amount
That said, we had an issue last night that we are posting here because GrubHub refuses to take responsibility.
We ordered a Neapolitan pie, half pepperon and meatball and half meatball, mushroom, olives and onion.
With tax, tip and delivery, this came to $50!
When you look on Phil's website, the pie alone is $15.65, half toppings are $2.50 each and 3-4 toppings are $10. There shouldn't be any reason for this pie to reach $50-even with tip and delivery fee.
Not to mention that I never agreed to the tip amount
Jenny T.
Aug 05, 2019
Report
Visiting friends and decided on pizza delivery for the kids. It was a good choice.
Delivery time was adequate, didn't feel long though the site indicated it was up to 50min for food to be delivered.
Pizza came a bit lope-sided but not too much to affect the quality of the pizza.
Order garlic knots, 3 for $1, pretty decent size and was good.
Spaghetti with meat sauce was really good. It was al dente and enough meat to have a bite of meat with spaghetti in every bite. It was a good size to feed maybe 6-8, if having other items, too. Be we weren't big eaters so it could be considered less
Delivery time was adequate, didn't feel long though the site indicated it was up to 50min for food to be delivered.
Pizza came a bit lope-sided but not too much to affect the quality of the pizza.
Order garlic knots, 3 for $1, pretty decent size and was good.
Spaghetti with meat sauce was really good. It was al dente and enough meat to have a bite of meat with spaghetti in every bite. It was a good size to feed maybe 6-8, if having other items, too. Be we weren't big eaters so it could be considered less
Sam G.
Jun 17, 2019
Report
We had great service here. I'm all about customer service adding to the business. I had their margarita slice that was great. Good flavor. Excellent crust. The plain slice was good with lots of cheese.
My daughter had dropped her slice and we went to buy another but they were so sweet and gave her another free of charge. Now that is genuine kindness.
Plenty of room to eat. Parking in front lot is there. Staff is nice. Place is clean. I would definitely come back.
My daughter had dropped her slice and we went to buy another but they were so sweet and gave her another free of charge. Now that is genuine kindness.
Plenty of room to eat. Parking in front lot is there. Staff is nice. Place is clean. I would definitely come back.
Robert B.
Jun 16, 2019
Report
This was my first time ordering a delivery . I called I ordered claims,grilled chicken salad
With a bottle of Diet Coke .....45 mins later
I received my claims , salad ( no chicken)
Iced tea . Sooo my salad was warm , my diet coke was replaced with a warm bottle of ice tea...ITS CALLED ICED TEA , that means cold! No napkins or utensils . And a 2:00 fee for delivery never heard of that , and my whole order was wrong.
What a terrible 1st experience spend 30 bucks and did not even get what I wanted. Last time I there The address 1378 WAntagh ave WAntagh 11793
With a bottle of Diet Coke .....45 mins later
I received my claims , salad ( no chicken)
Iced tea . Sooo my salad was warm , my diet coke was replaced with a warm bottle of ice tea...ITS CALLED ICED TEA , that means cold! No napkins or utensils . And a 2:00 fee for delivery never heard of that , and my whole order was wrong.
What a terrible 1st experience spend 30 bucks and did not even get what I wanted. Last time I there The address 1378 WAntagh ave WAntagh 11793
Mike P.
Jun 04, 2019
Report
Service is terrible. I placed an order to stay. There were. Very few customers. I stood in front of the counter for 10 minutes and no one asked what I was waiting for. I finally asked where my order was and the girl at the counter said something to the guy making pizzas who I saw put my order in the oven just then. I asked is that my order and she just stared at me. No apologies or comments. Won't be coming back.
Pamela L.
Mar 22, 2019
Report
Linda K.
Feb 15, 2019
Report
Stopped by Phil's for a quick lunch after a visit to nearby Bide-A-Wee. I got a square spinach artichoke slice with melted fresh mozzarrella and it was humongous! Too cheesy for me and not made w/tomato sauce which I prefer, still good but would try something else next time. Hubbie got chicken parm slice which he said was tasty. We usually get two slices each but couldn't eat another bite. Friendly smiling guy brought our slices to our booth, a nice unexpected touch.
Sammi G.
Jan 11, 2019
Report
Louise A.
Jan 10, 2019
Report
