Name: Di Maggio's Pizzeria
Address: 3 W Village Grn, Hicksville, NY, 11801, US
Telephone: (516) 796-0611
Rating: 4

DiMaggio's Pizzeria has been serving Long Island for over 25 years. Here at DiMaggio's we use only the finest ingredients in preparing our homemade Italian food. Our menu consists of our famous sesame seed crust pizzas, over 20 variety of pasta dishes, and a large selection of Italian hot hero's. We also offer a full catering menu for your convenience.

We are committed to bringing you the best pizza on Long Island whether it's take out by our professional delivery service or dining in, your experience will be a pleasant one.

Website Update

Reviews (8)

Write a Review

Jenna B.

Dec 27, 2021

Report

Went to pick up a pizza the other day. None of the employees were wearing masks. A couple of people sitting at a table with NO food or drinks in front of them not wearing masks. and they had the nerve to say something about me wearing a mask. Then I said you are supposed to wear masks inside and the owner/manager said "you must be a Democrat"

Brian Rooney

Sep 29, 2021

Report

Pizzas average. Ordered a half pepperoni Sicilian. I asked for garlic powder, red pepper flakes and grated Parm on the side and who I assume is the owner nearly had a heart attack saying you gotta charge him a dollar each!!! They didn’t charge me but left a bad taste in my mouth. Anyway two brothers pizza is across the street. Cleaner, friendlier, and they don’t stroke out when asking for sides of condiments.

Laura Haber

Aug 18, 2021

Report

I come from Astoria Queens and Marios is the closest to authentic New York Pizza!! Bravo!!

Diana Villa

May 29, 2021

Report

Amazing!!! Visited from out of town, and stopped in randomly and it's a wonderful place I stumbled upon. Great staff.. amazing food. Great prices!

Michael Graciolett

Mar 28, 2021

Report

Everyone is awesome there, they remember their regulars by name and new customers like there family. Been going there since they first opened in the 80's. There awesome !

Irfan Punekar

Jan 21, 2020

Report

Excellent New York style pizza with a great selection and some of the best crust I've ever had. Tastes like home. Very friendly staff and quick service too.

Tdubble Dog

Oct 21, 2018

Report

Yes, the sesame seed crust makes the pizza different from most, but the sauce is the key. That's why the pizza, the baked ziti, the meatball heroes are the best around. I grew up near here and used to enjoy the pizza all the time. Now I have to travel a bit, but it's worth every mile. Pat is a great guy and they make great food.

Christopher Zinno

Dec 10, 2016

Report

I drove 1350 miles from Florida just to have the best NY pizza. They did not disappoint. Crust crisp but chewy. Toppings not skimpy. Hot and fast. Not to mention a clean chow hall. Worth the drive...Gunny Z.