Butler Insurance Services
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Whether you are seeking knowledge about Insurance, specifically looking for a quote, or seeking a strong relationship with an agent you can trust, you have come to the right place! We strive to create a relationship of trust where you can be sure that you will get the service and industry expertise you deserve.

Our team is committed to your peace of mind and assisting to make the most of your insurance dollars. We promise to work hard to fulfill the promise that each insurance policy makes. To be there when you need us most! Butler Insurance Services Inc. is a family owned insurance agency based in the state of Idaho with more than 50 years experience helping customers with all types of insurance needs.
Services
Shane is US Navy Veteran, and Idaho native. Throughout his life in Idaho and 18 year insurance career, he has come to know many local families and develop relationships with businesses all over the state. These local relationships have helped him better understand the needs of our agency, and the community we proudly serve.
Working with Jenni the past couple of months has been a breath of fresh air. She helped me with a smooth and easy transition from my previous malpractice insurance to my current policy. She found a policy that gives me great coverage, and was helpful in answering any and all questions. She continues to be a helping hand and actually answers the phone and responds quickly to emails.
We offer online billing to manage your policy and pay online, you can call us to pay with debit/credit over the phone, or mail in your payment. Some carriers offer a pay in full discount and our agents are available to help with most of your billing questions and concerns. Collision is defined as losses you incur when your car collides into another car or object.
Each year the team at Butler Insurance Services chooses a local non-profit organization to support with volunteer work and financial donations. In 2020, we are supporting Camp Rainbow Gold. Camp Rainbow Gold provides emotionally empowering experiences to Idaho children and their families who have been diagnosed with cancer.
If an accident does happen, trust us to help you through it. From arranging repairs at a reputable shop to getting you a rental vehicle so you don't miss work, we're dedicated to handling all the details. Not knowing how the associated costs will be handled can make an already stressful situation worse.
Reviews (10)
Jerry Nowland
Jerry Nowland
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Was very quick in responding to me and explaining everything to me would tell everyone about them
Dan Balluff
Dan Balluff
Nov 04, 2021
Report
I lead a very busy life and have been wanting to change personal insurance companies for a couple years now because I knew I was paying way too much for basic auto coverage and homeowners. I should have made the time to do so and saved myself thousands on coverage.
My previous agency never once asked me to come in and review my policies. Jennifer at Butler reduced my personal lines of insurance by $2500 per year and added an umbrella policy on top of it all. I wish I had taken the time to save myself the $5000 over the past two years.
Kahlah Obrien
Kahlah Obrien
Oct 26, 2021
Report
I decided to switch insurance companies and it was the best decision I could have ever made! They are all very helpful and very friendly. My parents actually go there as well and I’ve gone there for many years and absolutely love it. Emma is so kind and I absolutely love talking to her. Hailey is the One who helps me with all my wants and needs. I always have lots of questions or concerns and she is always happy to help and Is never irritated or annoyed with all my questions. She jumps at the chance to make sure that I am taken care of! I love her and everything this company stands for. I always
Gary Fost
Gary Fost
Oct 20, 2021
Report
Met with Stacy Butler in August to go over home owner and auto policies. Seven policies were due in September. She said she would go over all of them and get back to me. I waited 10 days and called, Stacy was out of the office so I left a message for her to call me. I waited another 2 weeks and called again. Stacy was out of the office again so I left another message to call me. Never heard from her.I am now with a different company.
Cindy Martinez
Cindy Martinez
Oct 20, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism
Shane and Stacy at Butler Insurance have been my auto and homeowner's insurance agents since 2008. I trust them to take care of my insurance needs by providing peace of mind with exceptional coverage.
Dallin Torell
Dallin Torell
Oct 17, 2021
Report
I've enjoyed working with everyone at Butler Insurance. Their staff goes above and beyond my expectations every time I work with them. Great customer service.
Bj Vanorder
Bj Vanorder
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
I have done business with Don Dill Insurance for 12 years and was always pleased with the service. When Butlers took over my service never missed a beat. They are very friendly and professional and I wish them every success.
Connie Murphy
Connie Murphy
Sep 07, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Shane, Stacy and their team are always quick to respond to my needs and inquiries. I needed insurance for a new home and Stacy had a policy prepared and to the title company the next day. I appreciate their advice and guidance on all of my insurance needs.
Leslie Folwell
Leslie Folwell
Aug 30, 2021
Report
Butler Insurance has been our agent for car and home insurance for years. They always respond to us in a timely matter and are knowledgable about what fits our needs best. We recommend them to all.
Lety Rios
Lety Rios
Jun 22, 2021
Report
I am always helped promptly and with a smile. My brother-in-law moved to the area and I recommend Butler Insurance to him.
My grandson was diagnosed with leukemia last year. Emma never fails to ask about him. She also gave me information about a camp for cancer patients and their families to attend.
AWESOME people to do business with.
Thank you
Lety Rios