We offer a fine dining Italian dinner menu that is like no other in the area, we have something for everyone. We offer a full Italian banquet luncheon menu that includes a salad, entre, and dessert for each of your guests. Siena Restaurant offers a variety of authentic Italian cuisine and a fine dining experience.
We have something for everyone so please come in and join us for lunch, dinner or a homemade pizza. We also have drop-off catering and banquet services for your events. Welcome to Siena Restaurant, a fine dining Italian experience that you won't find anywhere else in Buffalo, NY. We strive to bring authentic Italian cuisine to our customers, which is why we had a master pizzaiolo from Italy train our entire team.
We have something for everyone so please come in and join us for lunch, dinner or a homemade pizza. We also have drop-off catering and banquet services for your events. Welcome to Siena Restaurant, a fine dining Italian experience that you won't find anywhere else in Buffalo, NY. We strive to bring authentic Italian cuisine to our customers, which is why we had a master pizzaiolo from Italy train our entire team.
Services
We take pride in our Italian fine dining cuisine, and we aim to create an unforgettable experience for every customer who walks through our doors. We offer delicious contemporary Italian dishes and our entire team has been trained by a master pizzaiolo from Italy, which means we have authentic Italian pizza and food that you won't find anywhere else in the area.
Siena Restaurant is always happy to cater your parties and events. That is why we offer convenient drop off catering for customers in the Buffalo, NY area. We can deliver your food in disposable packaging, or provide service staff and a chef if available. We offer a large Italian catering menu to choose from including hors d'oeuvres, sandwiches, side dishes, antipasti, and desserts.
At Siena Restaurant, we aim to offer excellent service to each and every one of our customers. Whether you have dined at our Italian restaurant in the past or you have never tried our Italian cuisine, we can't wait to see you at our location in Buffalo, NY. For your convenience, we have provided directions, hours, and contact information below.
Below you will find a photo gallery of our contemporary Italian cuisine and our fine dining restaurant. The quality of our food and dining experience is very important to us, and that starts with the taste and authenticity of our Italian food, but goes much further. We strive to create an elegant atmosphere that will instantly let you know you are in a real Italian restaurant when you step inside.
If you are looking for fine dining Italian gift cards, we have several great options to choose from. We have gift cards available for Siena Restaurant, in addition to 800 Maple and Rocco's Wood Fired Pizza. Simply select the denomination you would like, and make your purchase using our secure, online checkout system.
Reviews (23)
Linda Wallensky
Jan 25, 2022
Report
Jon White
Jan 02, 2022
Report
Jane Theriault
Dec 20, 2021
Report
New Year's Eve is my birthday. My husband made reservations for us for dinner at Siena for my birthday. We've dined there on other occasions but last night's experience topped them all. The "din" was warm and welcoming on arrival and our server, Kate, was super attentive in spite of what was clearly a full house. She came up with a perfect drink suggestion for me as someone who is not a wine aficionado. Always look forward to the luscious charcuterie plate. The seafood scampi was so perfectly prepared and sumptuous. A perfect dining experience. Many thanks to Kate and Siena!
Kellie M.
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Excellent service! Excellent meal. Started with a Mediterranean Bliss cocktail that was very good. The bread, olives and cheese they bring to the table was warm and tasty. The margarita pizza was delicious. The rigatoni arrabbiata was delicious. Can't say enough about the outstanding service. Highly recommend. Will definitely be back!!
George Ouimet
Nov 30, 2021
Report
Great place for a nice dinner. We were served by Mike B, who was very charming and thoughtful. The place has a very nice ambiance to it, and if you go at the right time when there’s a lot of people it becomes a very welcoming and friendly environment. They were properly staffed so none of the workers seemed overextended or stressed in any way, they could take the time to ensure that each table had what it needed. 10/10!
Jim K.
Nov 13, 2021
Report
My wife and I have been here many times and have never been disappointed. The staff is very friendly and always make you feel welcome. We had Tuna Tartare and Oysters to start, they were delicious. For entrees we had Halibut and Penne Pasta, we finished everything and is was also delicious. The serving staff was great as well, our server was one of the best we have had at a restaurant, no rushing and always there when we needed something. Can't wait to visit Siena next time.
They have something of everyone and sometimes we just split an appetizer and have a pizza sitting at the bar when
They have something of everyone and sometimes we just split an appetizer and have a pizza sitting at the bar when
Lorraine Carr
Oct 31, 2021
Report
Cactus L.
Oct 17, 2021
Report
Ate here a couple nights ago. the buffalo trace was rockin!!! the charcuterie board here is next level and the oysters were excellent. i had the filet which was cooked to perfection and for dessert the cookie baked inside a brownie served with ice cream left me feeling like the chef had fallen from fat kid heaven
Denise H.
Sep 19, 2021
Report
Kimberly Virden
Sep 04, 2021
Report
Fantastic place for dining! Very upscale, clean and the staff is fantastic! We enjoyed the filet mignon as well as the scallops and were NOT disappointed. The assistant manager Sean, was fantastic! He made sure we had everything we needed and that everything was good. We were beyond impressed with the cuisine provided. Great ambiance for a date night or even just a night out with friends. Their choices are phenomenal. Would 100% recommend!
Troy Richards
Sep 01, 2021
Report
Outstanding! I would call it Northern Italian cuisine with meat and fish dishes. Not a big pasta place if that is what you are looking for. Also have gourmet wood-fired pizzas. Menu small but very high quality and creative. Everyone in my party of 13 loved their food. Service was excellent. Portions were also very good. Expect around $30 for entre but worth it. Compliments to the chef!
Kym Seiss
Aug 19, 2021
Report
Kathryn Manetta
Aug 15, 2021
Report
Samantha D.
Aug 03, 2021
Report
Absolutely perfect evening. All of the food my party got was incredible. Mussels, crab bruschetta, salmon, halibut, tuna tartare, seafood scampi, steak. The consensus was that every dish was fresh, unique, and perfectly seasoned and accompanied. The service was impeccable and everything was timely and beyond expectations. Lovely place with equally lovely, accommodating staff and kitchen. Definitely on the pricey side, but you get what you pay for. Siena is worth the price for a quality dinner and atmosphere.
Karin Fryer
Jul 28, 2021
Report
When your wallet has some money in it, go here. Was pricey but really worth it. The flavors are amazing! Very cozy atmosphere and timed just right. They do food artfully and thoughtfully. Cocktails are varied and delicious. Wines are vast. Siena is a great spot right in the heart of Amherst. Noy great parking but everything Siena is drowns that out.
Jennifer O.
Jul 27, 2021
Report
Siena lives up to its reputation and it was hopping on an otherwise quiet Wednesday night.
It does seem the restaurant is the dining spot to see and be seen. There were a few power brokers dining that evening and they were greeted as regulars.
Siena has a warm, romantic look and the decor is well balanced: A rich, sleek design with lowered lighting on one side and a wall of windows, lighter and brighter, on the other.
Siena features a mostly Mediterranean menu whose specialty is pasta, fish and their thin-crust pizzas.
I had the tuna tartare ($18) that was beautifully plated with glistening
It does seem the restaurant is the dining spot to see and be seen. There were a few power brokers dining that evening and they were greeted as regulars.
Siena has a warm, romantic look and the decor is well balanced: A rich, sleek design with lowered lighting on one side and a wall of windows, lighter and brighter, on the other.
Siena features a mostly Mediterranean menu whose specialty is pasta, fish and their thin-crust pizzas.
I had the tuna tartare ($18) that was beautifully plated with glistening
N. S.
May 17, 2021
Report
This is for my fellow gluten-free buffalo peeps. I am compelled to write this review because of the exceptional service I received this evening. Not only is this the best gluten-free pizza in town (Toscana) The staff and management went above and beyond to ensure I got my food without complications. They respected the details of my diet restrictionsI am writing this review because they made right on a previous order of mine and I value their service and devotion to customers with restrictions
Samantha L.
Apr 22, 2021
Report
I came here for my one year anniversary with my boyfriend. They had us seated quickly and it was very busy. The tortellini en brodo was okay, but not amazing. I enjoyed my pasta entree but I don't know if I'd get it again. The real thing for me to write home about was the dessert. It was absolutely delicious! Overall it wasn't amazing, but it was pretty good.
Erica F.
Feb 28, 2021
Report
The place doesn't seem to "social distance" much.. service was okay. I got Seafood Scampi. it was about a 6/10, scallops were amazing, lobster was bland, shrimp as well. Creme Brûlée was also bland with no vanilla. honestly just like heavy cream & sugar. wouldn't go out of my way to come here again.
Scott G.
Dec 09, 2020
Report
Takeout. Ordered a chicken entree during the COVID period of late 2020 and enjoyed it enough to arrive on Yelp. Paid in cash, ready on time and might have been the last order they served before 8:30 close. It's the upscale meal that I needed. Dish was cooked to perfection and the flavor, seasoning and glaze was utmost perfection. Looking forward to returning once in person dining is acceptable. Hats off!
Megan M.
Nov 19, 2020
Report
Delicious, everytime. Wait staff is fantastic. We loved our cocktails and wine. Try the blood orange mule for an Italian soda spin off that's SO good. We got tuna tartare, buratta and caesar salad for starters. Their caesar is a step above the rest to be sure, perfectly coated and with prosciutto! My pesto orrechiette was delish and my table mates enjoyed veal milanese and an arrabiatta pasta. Wish I'd taken pictures but we were too hungry!
Eva G.
Aug 04, 2020
Report
Everything at this restaurant is delicious!!! Venne-something pizza (shrimp and sausage w/goat cheese); Anti-something pasta (ricotta, shrimp, bell peppers, sausage), Sienna burger w/garlic parm fries, Ceasar salad w/anchovie lemon dressing, Creme Brule...omgggg!!! Thank you to our waiter Sean W (hope u got the tip we left on the table--we had to run to beat the storm). Great location...great service!!!
Melissa M.
Feb 02, 2020
Report
Siena is a Buffalo classic. It's a romantic, intimate restaurant located in the heart of Snyder. They do not take reservations for groups under 6, which results in a wait of usually 30 minutes on the weekend. The Italian food is top-notch; it is one of the best in the City. They have a variety of options from traditional pasta dishes to pizza to meat-based entrees. I tend to order the chicken cutlets parmigiana, because it's delicious. The pork chop and pizzas are also good choices. The small charcuterie board is worth the price and is a nice start to a fantastic meal.
