Locally sourced seasonal ingredients, raw bar, indoor/outdoor seating, fine international wines, and much more. An elegant dining experience of the highest quality. Gibraltar, Lancaster PA's best seafood restaurant, delivers thoughtfully prepared, ever changing and seasonally focused fare, sourcing the world's finest seafood, wild caught fish, shellfish, prime and organic meats and local produce.
Emphasizing organic, sustainable and ethically cultivated products, all complimented by a well-rounded wine cellar, creative artisan cocktail list and fresh local craft beer selection. Gibraltar exceeded our expectations! From the perfectly prepared dry-aged NY Strip to the moist and flaky halibut special and ending with a nice selection of desserts, the evening did not disappoint.
Emphasizing organic, sustainable and ethically cultivated products, all complimented by a well-rounded wine cellar, creative artisan cocktail list and fresh local craft beer selection. Gibraltar exceeded our expectations! From the perfectly prepared dry-aged NY Strip to the moist and flaky halibut special and ending with a nice selection of desserts, the evening did not disappoint.
Services
For twenty years Gibraltar has delivered extraordinary dining and magnificent memories, offering the ideal setting for the perfect special occasion, or no occasion at all. Casually elegant, inspired, fresh and ever changing, we've refined the traditional Gibraltar style you've come to love, and invite you to experience the evolution.
Having earned a reputation as Lancaster's premiere dining venue, our team is prepared to expertly execute your next business meeting, party, presentation or special event, with the distinction and style for which Gibraltar is known.
We offer a number of private dining rooms, with seating for up to 50 guests, signature platters and seafood specialties available for pickup along with full service, off-premise catering in your home or venue of choice.
We offer a number of private dining rooms, with seating for up to 50 guests, signature platters and seafood specialties available for pickup along with full service, off-premise catering in your home or venue of choice.
If you're interested in learning more about great cuisine, service, wines and spirits from around the world, and enjoy interacting with people, we are always on the lookout for talented individuals to join the Gibraltar team. We offer a rewarding work environment with great wages and flexible full or part-time schedules.
Reviews (28)
Annette Minnich
Feb 03, 2022
Report
Melonie W.
Jan 27, 2022
Report
When I tell you this was the best restaurant experience that I have had in years, I mean it. The ambiance was beautiful. Restaurant was clean and smelled so good. Our server Matthew, made us feel like he had known us for years. His knowledge of the menu and his pleasant demeanor was unmatched. Chef Carl was/is amazing!!!! we had the New York Strip, Filet, Lobster Fettuccini, Crabcake, truffle fries and butternut squash ravoli. Everything was soooooo fresh and well seasoned. Cooked to perfection. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. It was my friend's birthday and we were treated
Steven Armstrong
Jan 21, 2022
Report
Out of all the things I love about Gibraltar, consistency is at the top of the list. No matter who your server is, or if you sit at the bar, you get the best service around. On top of that the food is good EVERY SINGLE TIME. Times when my wife and I eat elsewhere to change it up we wish we would have just gone to Gibraltar :)
Katie Martin
Jan 19, 2022
Report
Karyn Miller
Dec 28, 2021
Report
Outstanding experience at Gibraltar for my office holiday party. We had a private room that was perfect for our function. The food was amazing and the service was second to none. They went above and beyond to accommodate us and made the night special for everyone. A great place to celebrate for any occasion!
Erin G.
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Lyndsey Brendle
Nov 30, 2021
Report
My husband and I went to Gibraltar for the first time tonight for our wedding anniversary. The food is absolutely amazing! Actually some of the best food I've eaten. The service was impeccable. The drinks from the bar were perfection. Obviously an experience like this is going to be quite pricey but it was absolutely worth every dollar spent. We will be back again for sure! We had such a lovely time.
Amanda Del Carmen Ward
Nov 24, 2021
Report
The food here was delicious. Our server was attentive. The only reason I did not give this place 5 stars is we were seated in a poorly lit corner of the restaurant, so we had a hard time reading our menus. And when we asked the host if he could light the candle on our table, he was very short with us and said our server would do that.
Lena G.
Oct 18, 2021
Report
Moved to Lancaster half a year ago，Friends choose Gibraltar Grille to congratulate us on our housewarming.
I like the seafood here, the creativity and taste of the dishes are amazing.
The restaurant environment is also nice, but there are no tablecloths on all tables, Disharmonious with the grade of the restaurant. During the pandemic, when I go to any restaurant, I have to wipe the table with paper towels and check the red wine glasses.
My favorite today is grilled squid. Thick and tender. Endless aftertaste. The taste of corbieres red wine in 2014 is also very good, only $49…
I like the seafood here, the creativity and taste of the dishes are amazing.
The restaurant environment is also nice, but there are no tablecloths on all tables, Disharmonious with the grade of the restaurant. During the pandemic, when I go to any restaurant, I have to wipe the table with paper towels and check the red wine glasses.
My favorite today is grilled squid. Thick and tender. Endless aftertaste. The taste of corbieres red wine in 2014 is also very good, only $49…
B. S.
Oct 09, 2021
Report
Mike M.
Sep 28, 2021
Report
We never tried the food because we were treated rudely by Sal at the "greeting" station. We reserved an outdoor table but then asked if there was any availability at that early hour (5:00pm) for an indoor table. A rude and inhospitable response was the result. Ultimately and reluctantly he sat us down in a room with not another table occupied. The waiter promptly provided us with the wine lists. We were still so upset with how we were treated that we decided to leave and spend our hard earned money elsewhere and told Sal why we were not staying and would not return. The food might be
Kay B.
Sep 12, 2021
Report
I travel often to PA, usually once a week or so as my father is in a nursing home in Lititz, so unwinding after a visit is important to me. I tend to go to a few usual places and wanted to break out to something different this time. One of my last visits was to a Thai place and I noticed another restaurant across the way and felt it would be more conducive to us.
My friend forgot to make the reservation, on a Friday no less, and so we went as a walk in. The place was packed and quite busy and we could see everyone moving at a maximum to handle the capacity.
We sat outside as it was a beautiful
My friend forgot to make the reservation, on a Friday no less, and so we went as a walk in. The place was packed and quite busy and we could see everyone moving at a maximum to handle the capacity.
We sat outside as it was a beautiful
Katy B.
Jul 25, 2021
Report
My experience there has always been fantastic! Food is superb and staff is very nice. However, after last night, it's the last time we'll ever go back. It was my birthday and my family all flew in from California to celebrate. I made reservations from Sal himself 3 weeks prior while having dinner there. I had a party of 6 to eat in the Wine Room specifically. He guaranteed my request. Even called and texted 3 days in advance.
Well!!! We arrive and he unapologetically and pompously told me it's already taken by a party of 10. ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?! He said we'll go to
Well!!! We arrive and he unapologetically and pompously told me it's already taken by a party of 10. ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?! He said we'll go to
Allen C.
Jun 14, 2021
Report
Megan Hoffman
Apr 30, 2021
Report
This is the kind of place I would normally leave 5 stars. The food was PHENOMENAL. Naturally gluten free seafood was next level. The atmosphere was very clean elegant and well spaced out. It was not crowded or noisy. Our server gram was very attentive polite and at our every beck and call. The drinks were absolutely delicious I had a pineapple blueberry mojito. The bartender was very polite and made excellent drinks. The hostess was very polite. Literally everything about our experience was terrific except the owner/front end manager Sal. He seemed very disrespectful to his hostess when she was
Rob A.
Apr 08, 2021
Report
Great service! They called to confirm our reservation. Seated right away. Had they lobster ravioli which was absolutely amazing! Service was amazing!
Although they had an extensive wine list, the prices were absolutely ridiculous! $18-$20 bottles of wine that I personally buy, were $95-$120
Normally $50-$60 is what I usually pay at restaurants for those type of wines. Hence the reason for the 4 stars instead of 5
Although they had an extensive wine list, the prices were absolutely ridiculous! $18-$20 bottles of wine that I personally buy, were $95-$120
Normally $50-$60 is what I usually pay at restaurants for those type of wines. Hence the reason for the 4 stars instead of 5
Joanne M.
Feb 27, 2021
Report
William H.
Feb 20, 2021
Report
Better than outstanding! Gina is an excellent hostess! Mikella did the best service job ever! So attentive and personable! Now for the food: secret special off the menu item-THE BURGER! Do it! The oyster special appetizer melted in your mouth! The burger and fries were superb! The wine selection perfect, the cocktail perfect too. Highly recommend this place. GOOD LUCK IN GETTING A TABLE!
Ashley N.
Feb 15, 2021
Report
Steve M.
Feb 13, 2021
Report
Cat P.
Jan 11, 2021
Report
We had a really excellent meal here back in October. I was not comfortable dining indoors due to the pandemic, so we selected a table on their outdoor patio. Despite the cold temperatures, their heating lamps were actually surprisingly powerful! It was a lot cozier than I thought it would be. My filet was cooked perfectly and since I have some allergies, the staff replaced the mashed potatoes with roasted fingerlings and then gave me a side of steamed green beans. Everything was delicious. Their dessert menu looked incredible, but we were too full. I'm unsure if I'll be back in Lancaster
Brittany M.
Nov 26, 2020
Report
Denise Brossman
Nov 23, 2020
Report
Gibralter is a treasure to which everyone should treat themselves. Absolutely fantastic. By far, the best restaurant in the area. From the knowledgable and friendly staff to the spectacular food, just brilliant. Never had a bad experience and on par with the best eateries I've experienced in NY. Can't wait to get back to regular status post-covid. . Keep up the great work everyone!! BRAVO!
Tommy H.
Nov 16, 2020
Report
Mike F.
Jun 16, 2020
Report
Super good food! Just don't get Michael.
Our server, Michael, seems to have a chip on his shoulder. It seems his goal is to make everyone around him miserable. But try as he might, we didn't let his cold demeanor ruin our evening.
Every dish we ordered was impeccable. Bold flavors, beautiful plating, cooked to perfection.
The Kennet Square Mushrooms... WOW! A crispy polenta cake topped with buttery sauteed mushrooms and shaved parmigiana in a black truffle cream sauce. Might be my favorite appetizer ever.
And again, the entrees were friggin' fantastic. Absolutely no complains
Our server, Michael, seems to have a chip on his shoulder. It seems his goal is to make everyone around him miserable. But try as he might, we didn't let his cold demeanor ruin our evening.
Every dish we ordered was impeccable. Bold flavors, beautiful plating, cooked to perfection.
The Kennet Square Mushrooms... WOW! A crispy polenta cake topped with buttery sauteed mushrooms and shaved parmigiana in a black truffle cream sauce. Might be my favorite appetizer ever.
And again, the entrees were friggin' fantastic. Absolutely no complains
Robert Lloyd Iii
Jun 02, 2020
Report
Becky D.
Mar 11, 2020
Report
My husband and I enjoy doing date nights, especially at new restaurants. I found Gibraltar via Opentable. I do recommend making a reservation as it seems to be relatively busy when we came on Saturday night. Finding it along with parking is super easy!
We were greeted by the friendly hostesses and sat immediately upon arrival. The ambiance is wonderful. It's very relaxing and beautiful inside. It's also a lot bigger inside than I expected.
Our server was Aaron, and he was OUTSTANDING! He asked us great questions like if we had ever been there before and how we found out about the
We were greeted by the friendly hostesses and sat immediately upon arrival. The ambiance is wonderful. It's very relaxing and beautiful inside. It's also a lot bigger inside than I expected.
Our server was Aaron, and he was OUTSTANDING! He asked us great questions like if we had ever been there before and how we found out about the
Eugenio L.
Aug 11, 2019
Report
Classy restaurant with an upscale vibe. Our hostess was an attractive young woman who was friendly and had a great smile.
The service was stellar! Our server was professional knew the menu inside and out and was accommodating with all our questions regarding the menu.
Now, to the food, I ordered oysters 3 different types that were just splendid! Great tray with fresh lemons to squeeze on top and/or cocktail sauce and/or a vinegary onion red dipping sauce that was delish.
Ordered the scallions, they were good on presentation, great on taste but waay to small on portions, I was thinking they
The service was stellar! Our server was professional knew the menu inside and out and was accommodating with all our questions regarding the menu.
Now, to the food, I ordered oysters 3 different types that were just splendid! Great tray with fresh lemons to squeeze on top and/or cocktail sauce and/or a vinegary onion red dipping sauce that was delish.
Ordered the scallions, they were good on presentation, great on taste but waay to small on portions, I was thinking they
